Which storage is right for you?

Students using different computers

If you start your music project at home and open it at school later, make sure you have the complete project folder, a suitable file system and compatible ports. Ableton and Apple Support explain important points about collecting project files and using external drives.

Students who regularly edit audio

If you often copy project folders or open them directly from the drive, you can compare a portable SSD with an HDD for larger files you access less often. CHIP and COMPUTER BILD explain the differences in access speed and storage for your money.

Students with a large project archive

If you keep recordings and older versions of projects, first work out how much space you need and plan to keep an independent backup copy. The Verbraucherzentrale explains how a backup can help you restore lost files.

What should you look for when buying?

Portable external SSD

A good choice if: you often transfer large project folders between home and school, or regularly work directly from the drive.

Trade-off: CHIP and COMPUTER BILD’s comparison shows that HDDs offer more storage for your money. An SSD’s top speed also depends on your computer and cable.

Portable external HDD

A good choice if: you mainly store complete project versions or lots of audio files, and rarely edit directly from the drive.

Trade-off: COMPUTER BILD and CHIP describe HDDs as slower and more vulnerable to knocks than SSDs.

What matters What to check before buying Who is it especially relevant to?
Avoiding lost projects Back up the complete project folder, keep another copy separately and test it. If I don’t want to lose recordings and project versions, I need an independent copy as well as my working drive. An additional backup is the top priority for around 33% of consumers.
Editing and transferring files on the move Compare the ports and cables on your computer and drive; don’t assume advertised top speeds are guaranteed. If I often work in different places or edit my project on the move, easy transfers matter to me. Editing on the move is the main priority for around 27% of consumers.
Opening files on more than one computer Check the USB ports and file systems on both computers; find out how your music software collects the audio files you use. If I want to work on the same project at home and at school, I need to be able to use the drive on both computers. This compatibility is the main concern for around 20% of consumers.
Space for recordings and older versions Check the size of your existing project folders, including audio files, and allow for any extra versions you plan to keep. If I want to keep lots of recordings and older project versions, I want to know how much space I’ll actually need in advance. Sufficient archive space is the top priority for around 20% of consumers.

Common buying and usage mistakes

  • Treating the external drive as your only copy of a project

    External storage can also fail or get lost. If that happens, you could lose your only copy of your school project.

    Whichever drive you choose, make another copy, keep it separately and check that you can open the files from it. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends disconnecting a backup medium from the device when it is not being used for a backup.

  • Transferring only the music software project file

    A project may refer to audio files that aren’t automatically saved in the project folder. Ableton Live doesn’t save plugins with the project, so you’ll need to install them separately on the other computer.

    In Ableton Live, use ‘Collect All and Save’, then test the complete folder on the computer you’ll use it on. If you use different music software, check its equivalent feature.

  • Assuming USB-C or top speed guarantees performance

    The maximum speeds Samsung quotes for the T7 require a compatible computer, a suitable cable and UASP.

    Compare your computer’s USB mode with the drive and check the cable standard before choosing a model based on a maximum speed alone.

  • Changing the file system without making a backup

    Formatting a drive deletes the files already stored on it.

    First check the current file system and back up any project files you need separately before formatting.

Brands to consider

Samsung

The portable SSD T7 is an option for frequent project transfers. Samsung Germany describes the MU-PC1T0T/WW variant, which has 1 TB of storage.

  • Samsung quotes read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1.000 MB/s for the T7, and includes two connection cables.
  • These manufacturer figures require a compatible host, suitable cable and UASP; they are not guaranteed for every school computer.

Kingston

The XS1000 portable SSD is available in 1 TB and 2 TB variants.

  • Kingston quotes USB 3.2 Gen 2, read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1.000 MB/s for the XS1000. It also includes a USB-A cable with a USB-C adapter.
  • These performance figures apply to the XS1000 and are not guaranteed for every computer or other Kingston models.

Western Digital

The Elements Portable is a family of HDDs for larger project archives that you don’t access as often. Western Digital’s data sheet includes, among others, a 2-TB variant.

  • The manufacturer’s data sheet lists USB 3.2 Gen 1 or USB 3.0.
  • You may need to reformat the drive for other operating systems. Back up any existing files separately before formatting.

Seagate

The Expansion Portable is a family of USB-powered HDDs for extra project copies and archive files.

  • According to Seagate, the Expansion Portable model described in the data sheet does not need a separate power supply.
  • The data sheet dates from 2021. Check the specific model’s variant, what’s included and the details of its data recovery service.

Crucial

The X9 Pro is a portable SSD alternative if a clearly specified casing feature is important when you’re carrying it around.

  • Crucial lists an IP55 rating and speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s for the X9 Pro.
  • According to the manufacturer, achievable performance depends on the host. Despite its IP55 rating, the drive must not be submerged. These details don’t apply to all Crucial SSDs.

Joybuy products for music projects

This selection includes portable HDDs for extra project copies and archives, as well as portable SSDs for frequent transfers between computers.

WD Elements Portable 2 TB, USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1, 2.5-inch, exFAT, Black

WD Elements Portable 2 TB, USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1, 2.5-inch, exFAT, Black

A good choice if you want to keep an extra portable copy or an archive of projects you access less often.

  • Capacity: 2 TB
  • Port: USB-C
  • Interface: USB 3.2 Gen 1
  • Format: exFAT
Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7 1 TB, USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2, Grey

Samsung Portable SSD T7 1 TB, USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2, Grey

A portable SSD for frequent project transfers between computers. Check which ports and cables you can use at both locations.

  • Capacity: 1 TB
  • Interface: USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2
Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7 2 TB, USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2, Titan Grey

Samsung Portable SSD T7 2 TB, USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2, Titan Grey

A portable SSD for frequent transfers if you want to store other project versions as well as your current work.

  • Capacity: 2 TB
  • Interface: USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2
Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7 4 TB, USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2, Titan Grey

Samsung Portable SSD T7 4 TB, USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2, Titan Grey

A portable SSD for large project folders and extra versions. Check the capacity against your actual storage needs.

  • Capacity: 4 TB
  • Interface: USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2
Joybuy
Samsung MU-PG2T0B 2 TB, USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2, Black

Samsung MU-PG2T0B 2 TB, USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2, Black

A portable SSD for frequent transfers of large project files. Check that the USB ports on the computers you’ll use are compatible with the interface.

  • Capacity: 2 TB
  • Interface: USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2
Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is it enough to copy just the project file to the external drive?

Not necessarily. In Ableton Live, a standard save may include references to the files you’ve used; ‘Collect All and Save’ copies audio files into the project folder. You’ll need to install plugins separately on the other computer. If you use different music software, check how it manages projects.

Which format should I use with a Mac at home and a Windows computer at school?

Apple Support describes exFAT as an option for sharing files, and recommends it when formatting drives larger than 32 GB. Reformatting deletes existing files, so also check whether your school computer allows external drives. According to Apple, macOS can read NTFS without additional software, but can’t write to it.

What should I do with the drive between editing sessions?

Keep a separate backup copy and occasionally check that you can open files from it. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends disconnecting a backup medium from the computer when it isn’t being used for a backup. This helps prevent things such as malware from affecting the backup too.

Are a manufacturer’s guarantee and your statutory rights the same thing?

No. For a consumer purchase in Germany, the seller is responsible for statutory rights relating to faulty goods. A manufacturer’s guarantee is an additional voluntary service with its own terms and conditions. The Verbraucherzentrale says that statutory rights generally apply for two years from the date of delivery.

Can I store recordings of my classmates on a personal external hard drive?

There’s no general answer without knowing what was recorded, who was involved and what the school’s rules are. The Bavarian Data Protection Commissioner covers personal audio and video recordings in lessons in guidance specific to that state; check the details with your school first. If the files contain personal data, encryption can reduce the risk if the drive is lost.