Who is this comparison for?

Editing RAW files on a shared computer

If you often open or move files directly on a workstation, consider the ports, cables and handover process between users. Adobe describes an external drive as a way to use a Lightroom Classic catalogue and photos across several computers.

Photo archive managers

As your image collection grows, plan storage space and a separate, recoverable backup together. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends backing up data regularly.

Teams handling confidential images

If you may be processing images containing personal data on a shared computer, check access permissions and suitable safeguards for your specific workflow. The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information lists encryption as one possible measure, to be chosen according to the risk involved.

What should you consider when buying?

External SSD for working files

Suitable if: you often open, transfer or edit RAW files directly at different workstations.

Consider: CHIP describes SSDs as faster and less susceptible to impact than HDDs, but the advertised maximum speed depends on the host device and cable.

External HDD for archive data

Suitable if: you mostly store a large volume of RAW files and edit them less often, and transfer times are less important.

Consider: CHIP rates HDDs as slower and more susceptible to impact than SSDs. Plan a separate backup for an archive drive, too.

At a shared workstation, choose a drive that suits how it will be accessed, how it will be backed up and the speed of the computers you use regularly.

Priority What to check when buying Who is this important for?
Well-managed shared access Check that the ports and cables work with the computers you use, and agree on a process for files and editing catalogues. If you switch between Windows and Mac, consider the file system too. If several people use files or a catalogue at the same workstation, clear access and a reliable handover matter to me. Around 27% of consumers prioritise shared use.
Backup and recovery Plan for a separate backup drive or another independent backup method, and regularly check that you can restore files. If RAW originals can’t easily be recreated, I want a recoverable copy rather than just a single drive. Around 33% of consumers put data backup first.
Speed when working Check that the interface and cable match the computers you use regularly. Don’t assume a manufacturer’s maximum MB/s figure is guaranteed on every connection. If I often transfer large volumes of images or work directly from the drive, connection speed is a key consideration. Around 20% of consumers prioritise fast transfers.
Archive space Consider your current RAW collection and how much it is likely to grow; plan for your working drive and backup separately. If my image collection is growing and I only access it occasionally, having enough archive space matters more than having a drive for day-to-day editing. Around 20% of consumers prioritise archive capacity.

Common buying decisions and their consequences

  • Keeping the only copy of your RAW files on the new drive

    Storage media can fail. Without another recoverable copy, you risk losing your original files. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends backing up data regularly.

    Plan for backup and recovery alongside your working or archive drive.

  • Expecting maximum SSD speeds from every USB-C port

    An unsuitable host device or cable can limit transfer speeds. Kingston specifically states that the XS2000 needs a USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 port for optimum performance.

    Check the interface specifications of the computers and cables you use regularly.

  • Choosing an archive drive on capacity alone

    An HDD may be slower when you frequently work with files and more susceptible to impact during transport than an SSD. CHIP describes these differences in its comparison.

    Decide whether you need a drive for frequent editing or an archive that will mostly sit unused.

Brands to consider

Samsung

The Portable SSD T9 is one option for frequent file transfers. The specifications below refer to the documented 2-TB version, MU-PG2T0B/EU.

  • Samsung specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2x2, password protection and read and write speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s.
  • Maximum speed is not guaranteed on every computer at a shared workstation.

Seagate

The One Touch Portable Storage is an HDD option for archiving a growing collection.

  • Seagate’s data sheet lists versions of up to 5 TB and specifies USB 3.2 Gen 1.
  • The Rescue service mentioned in the data sheet is not available in every country. Check the features and terms for the specific German version.

Crucial

The X9 Pro is an external SSD for a mixed computer set-up, provided the ports and format are compatible.

  • Crucial specifies exFAT as the format supplied.
  • According to Crucial, compatibility and optimum speed depend on the host device and formatting. Reformatting erases existing data.

SanDisk

SanDisk describes the Extreme PRO with USB4 as suitable for mobile workflows involving large files.

  • SanDisk specifies read speeds of up to 3,800 MB/s for this product range.
  • This maximum is a manufacturer’s figure under suitable conditions, not a measurement taken at your specific shared workstation.

Kingston

The XS2000 is a compact SSD option, available in a documented 2-TB version, among others.

  • Kingston specifies speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s via USB 3.2 Gen 2x2.
  • According to Kingston, the port and cable can limit transfer speeds.

Joybuy product selection

This selection includes external SSDs for use as working drives when regularly accessing RAW files at a shared workstation.

Samsung Portable SSD T7, 1 TB, Grey

Samsung Portable SSD T7, 1 TB, Grey

An external SSD for regularly accessing RAW files.

1 TB; USB 3.2 Gen 2; according to the product description, read speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1,000 MB/s. USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables are listed.

View at Joybuy
MOVESPEED Portable SSD, 1 TB, model YSPSRX20M-1TTG

MOVESPEED Portable SSD, 1 TB, model YSPSRX20M-1TTG

A portable SSD for frequent file transfers, provided the computers and cables you use support the right interface.

1 TB; USB 3.2 Gen 2×2; according to the product description, read speeds of up to 2,060 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1,800 MB/s. Windows and macOS are listed as compatible systems.

View at Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7, 2 TB, Titanium Grey

Samsung Portable SSD T7, 2 TB, Titanium Grey

An external SSD for regularly accessing a larger collection of RAW files.

2 TB; USB 3.2 Gen 2; according to the product description, read speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1,000 MB/s. USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables are listed.

View at Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7, 4 TB, Titanium Grey

Samsung Portable SSD T7, 4 TB, Titanium Grey

An external SSD for a larger collection that you access regularly.

4 TB; USB 3.2 Gen 2; according to the product description, read speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1,000 MB/s. USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables are listed.

View at Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T9, 2 TB, MU-PG2T0B

Samsung Portable SSD T9, 2 TB, MU-PG2T0B

An external SSD for storing and regularly accessing RAW files.

2 TB; USB Type-C. USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables are listed in the product description.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does an external drive automatically back up my RAW files?

No, not if it holds the only copy. Plan a separate backup and check that you can restore the files. Adobe notes that a backup of the Lightroom Classic catalogue only includes the catalogue file, not the photos themselves.

What should I check before using the drive with Windows and Mac computers?

Check the file system, port and cable on both systems. Apple explains how to format an external drive for use with Windows and warns that doing so will erase any existing files.

Will an SSD with USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 reach its advertised speed on every USB-C port?

No. Kingston specifically states that the XS2000 needs a USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 port and a suitable cable for optimum performance. USB-C alone doesn’t tell you what transfer speed the port supports.

Do images on a shared drive always need to be encrypted?

There’s no blanket rule that applies to every RAW file. If personal data covered by the GDPR is being processed, technical and organisational measures should be assessed according to the risks involved. The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information lists encryption as one possible measure. For your specific workflow, also consider access permissions, backups and the consequences of losing a drive.

What should I bear in mind when keeping a Lightroom Classic catalogue on an external drive?

Adobe lists an external drive as a way to use a catalogue and photos across computers. However, Adobe warns that disconnecting the drive during a write operation can corrupt a catalogue. Close the application before unplugging the drive, and back up the catalogue and originals separately.