Choose an extra controller that your platform and the specific game support as a separate player input, then check the headphone connection and audio setup. Depending on the platform, the DualSense, Xbox Wireless Controller and Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller have a headphone jack; Joy-Con 2 can be used individually in compatible games. However, having a jack doesn’t necessarily mean two people can listen through separate headphones at the same time.
Who needs an extra controller?
Console group with separate headsets
You need extra inputs and want to check which headphone connection and audio settings actually work on PS5, Xbox or Switch 2 before buying. PlayStation, Xbox Support and Nintendo each set out requirements for controller and audio connections.
Switch 2 group with changing player numbers
You’re choosing between Joy-Con 2 that can be used individually and full-sized gamepads. The specific game and Bluetooth audio may affect how many controllers you can use at once; Nintendo sets out conditions that vary by platform and configuration.
PC gaming group on the sofa
You want to connect several gamepads to Windows and check headphone output, connection type and cable length separately. PlayStation says you need a wired controller connection to use the DualSense headset jack on PC and Mac; cable specifications apply to specific models.
What should you look for?
First, check that the platform and game support the controller as an additional input. Then find out how game audio reaches your headphones and whether the connection will work with your seating position.
| What matters |
What to check before buying |
Who should consider this? |
| Platform and game compatibility |
Console generation and game title; supported local mode and controller type. |
If I need an extra player input, I want to know first whether the console, game and controller are compatible. Around 33% of consumers put compatibility first. |
| Headphone connection and audio output |
Compatible plug and connection; audio setup and number of headphones that can receive audio at once. |
I want to hear game audio through my headphones and know whether the multiple-output setup I need will work. Around 27% of consumers prioritise the headphone connection and audio setup. |
| Separate inputs |
How many controllers the game supports; whether you need individual Joy-Con or full-sized gamepads. |
If several people are playing, I need enough inputs for the specific game to recognise. For around 20% of consumers, extra player inputs are the top priority. |
| Connection and seating distance |
Wired or wireless connection and suitable cable length; power requirements. |
I want to play from my seat without awkward cable routing and plan for the right connection. Around 20% of consumers prioritise connectivity from their seating position. |
Which assumptions should you avoid?
-
A headphone jack doesn’t automatically mean everyone can listen
The documented jack and an audio setting don’t prove that two connected headphones can receive separate audio at the same time.
If everyone needs their own headphones, check support for your exact platform, game and headset configuration before buying.
-
Don’t treat Switch and Switch 2, or Joy-Con and Pro Controller, as interchangeable
Nintendo says that Joy-Con 2 and the Switch 2 Pro Controller aren’t compatible with the original Switch. Whether Joy-Con 2 can be used individually as inputs also depends on the software and supported play style.
Check the console generation and the type of input required for the specific game.
-
Bluetooth on PC doesn’t guarantee headset audio through an Xbox controller
The headset function described by Xbox for its controller doesn’t apply when the controller is connected to a PC via Bluetooth, as explained in its guidance.
Decide separately how to connect your controller and route your audio before choosing any additional devices for your gaming session.
Which brands are worth considering?
Nintendo
A good option for Switch 2: full-sized gamepads with a headphone jack, as well as Joy-Con 2 that can be used individually depending on the game and play style.
- Nintendo specifies a four-pole 3.5 mm CTIA-standard jack for the Switch 2 Pro Controller.
- Nintendo says Joy-Con 2 and the Switch 2 Pro Controller aren’t compatible with the original Switch. When using Bluetooth audio on Switch 2, you can sync a maximum of two wireless controllers.
Sony PlayStation
Worth considering if you need extra DualSense controllers for PS5 or want to use supported features on computers.
- Sony says you can use up to four controllers at once on PS5 and provides settings for headphone audio output.
- Sony requires a wired controller connection to use the DualSense headset jack on PC and Mac. Other features depend on the device and game.
Microsoft Xbox
Worth considering if you want an Xbox Wireless Controller with a compatible headset, or a documented connection option for Windows.
- Xbox Support explains how to connect a headset to the 3.5 mm jack on an Xbox Wireless Controller paired with the console.
- The documented limits on simultaneous controller and headset combinations vary by headset type. The controller headset function described doesn’t apply when connecting to a PC via Bluetooth, as explained in the guidance.
PowerA
The Advantage Wired Controller for Xbox Series X|S with Hall Effect is a wired alternative for Xbox and Windows.
- PowerA specifies a 3.5 mm headset jack and a 3 m USB-C cable for this model.
- The cable needs to reach your seat. These specifications apply to this model and don’t automatically apply to other versions.
8BitDo
The Ultimate Wired Controller for Xbox is a wired option for Xbox and Windows.
- 8BitDo specifies a 3.5 mm CTIA jack and a 2.5 m cable for this model.
- These specifications apply to the Ultimate Wired Controller for Xbox and don’t automatically apply to other Ultimate versions.
Joy-Con 2 for local multiplayer on Switch 2
These Joy-Con 2 are an option for local games on Nintendo Switch 2, provided the game supports using individual Joy-Con as separate inputs.
No image available
Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 (2-piece set, Blue/Light Yellow)
For local multiplayer on Nintendo Switch 2, provided the game supports these controllers as separate inputs.
The set includes one left Joy-Con 2 and one right Joy-Con 2.
Using them individually depends on the software and supported play style. Designed for Nintendo Switch 2 only.
View on Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is a headphone jack on the controller enough for two people to listen at the same time?
No, you can’t assume that from the jack alone. Microsoft documents limits on simultaneous use with certain Xbox controller and headset combinations; the manufacturer documentation consulted doesn’t confirm a corresponding feature for two simultaneous headphone outputs on PS5 or Switch 2.
What should I bear in mind when using Bluetooth headphones and several Switch controllers?
According to Nintendo, a maximum of two wireless controllers can be synced on Switch 2 while Bluetooth audio is in use; the left and right Joy-Con 2 count separately. For the original Switch, Nintendo says Bluetooth audio is disabled in local mode, for example when a local multiplayer game starts. This doesn’t apply automatically to every game played together on one console.
How do I set up an extra PS5 or Switch 2 Pro Controller?
For the first pairing of a DualSense with PS5, Sony recommends connecting it with a USB cable. Nintendo says you can connect the Switch 2 Pro Controller for the first time via USB or sync it using “Controllers” and “Change Grip/Order”.
What should I consider when it comes to batteries and ongoing use?
Check whether the specific model uses batteries or a rechargeable battery, and how it’s charged or replaced if necessary. Nintendo describes the Switch 2 Pro Controller’s battery life as an estimate and says that battery replacement, if needed, is a chargeable customer service.