Who should consider their options?

Local multiplayer groups

You need an extra controller that works with your existing system and the game. The number of controllers that can be paired doesn’t automatically tell you how many people can play locally in a particular game.

Players who need subtitles

If you want to read text during fast-paced matches, check the game’s subtitle and display options separately from your controller choice. The Game Accessibility Guidelines include text size and subtitle presentation among the areas that may be adjusted.

Players who need customisation

If you want to reach buttons more easily or assign them differently, compare the controller’s features with the options available on your platform and in the game. Microsoft lists customisable button mapping for Xbox games; the available options depend on the game.

What should you look for when buying?

First check compatibility with your system and game, then look at subtitle options, player numbers, and the controls and connection that work best for your group.

What to considerWhat to check before buyingWho is this important to?
Platform and game Check your existing system and the exact model variant against the game’s controller support. If I’m looking for an extra controller for my existing system, it also needs to work with the specific arena game. Around 33% of consumers put platform and game compatibility first.
Reading subtitles Check that the language you want is available, and look at the text size and display options in the game. If I want to read subtitles while playing, the specific game needs to offer suitable text options. Around 27% of consumers prioritise readable subtitles.
Playing with others Check the game’s local player limit and how many inputs can be used at the same time. If other people are joining in on the same console or PC, the game needs to support the number of players in your group. Around 20% of consumers put additional player slots first.
Controls and power Check the button mapping you need, as well as whether your chosen model uses batteries, a rechargeable battery or a cable. If I need to reach certain buttons more easily or plan the power supply before a gaming session, controls and power are essential. Around 20% of consumers prioritise ease of use and power.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming controller numbers equal player numbers

    The number of controllers that can be paired doesn’t guarantee that a particular arena game supports the same number of local players. Nintendo says that, in most cases, up to eight wireless controllers can be paired with Switch 2; the number supported may also depend on the type of controller and its features.

    Before buying more controllers, check the local player limit and which inputs the specific game supports.

  • Assuming similarly named versions are interchangeable

    Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller doesn’t work with the original Switch. 8BitDo lists the Ultimate 2C Wireless and Ultimate 2C Bluetooth for different target systems.

    Check the full model name and the platform specified by the manufacturer before deciding.

    Choosing an incompatible model could mean you need to buy another one.

  • Overlooking the cable, dock and missing features

    PowerA says its Wired Controller for Nintendo Switch has a detachable 3-m cable and can be used while the console is docked. PowerA also notes that it lacks features including motion controls, HD Rumble, IR, amiibo NFC and the C Button.

    Check the distance from your seat, plan a safe cable route and make sure your game doesn’t need any of these features.

  • Assuming wireless means a built-in rechargeable battery

    Microsoft says the Xbox Wireless Controller uses AA batteries or a compatible rechargeable battery solution.

    Check the power requirements and what’s included with the specific model so it’s ready for your gaming session.

Key brands at a glance

Microsoft Xbox

An option for Xbox and supported Windows games, provided the controller and game work with your existing platform.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth and customisable button mapping for the Xbox Wireless Controller.
  • Xbox Support lists AA batteries or a suitable rechargeable battery solution; this doesn’t mean the controller is supported by other consoles.

Sony PlayStation

DualSense is an option for PS5; Sony also describes connecting it to a PC via USB-C or Bluetooth.

  • Sony describes the Access Controller as a customisable controller kit for PS5.
  • A PC connection alone doesn’t confirm that a particular game supports every feature. The Access Controller kit won’t necessarily suit everyone.

Nintendo

Choosing between Switch and Switch 2 controllers depends on which generation of console you own.

  • Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller has assignable GL/GR buttons and a headphone jack.
  • Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller cannot be used with the original Switch.

8BitDo

Consider the Ultimate 2C models separately, according to the systems they’re listed for.

  • 8BitDo lists Windows and Android for the Ultimate 2C Wireless, and Switch for the Ultimate 2C Bluetooth.
  • Despite their similar names, the models have different platform specifications and shouldn’t be confused.

PowerA

The Wired Controller for Nintendo Switch may suit gaming sessions with a docked console and a suitable cable route.

  • PowerA lists a detachable 3-m cable and compatibility with Switch 2.
  • PowerA notes that it lacks the C Button, motion controls, HD Rumble, IR and amiibo NFC.

Controllers at Joybuy

The Joybuy controllers below list PC, consoles or mobile devices as compatible systems, depending on the model, and offer different control layouts. Before buying, check that the specific version works with your platform and the game you want to play.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

For a supported game on Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS or Android, if you’re looking for an all-button hitbox layout.

Features listed in the product title: Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz or wired connection; hot-swappable mechanical switches and RGB.

View at Joybuy
The G-Lab K-PAD-HELIUM-WL Wireless Gaming Controller

The G-Lab K-PAD-HELIUM-WL

For a supported PC game, if you’re looking for a wireless controller with extra rear buttons.

Features listed in the product title: 2.4 GHz wireless connection and two rear buttons.

View at Joybuy
EasySMX D10 PC Controller

EasySMX D10 PC Controller

For a supported game on PC, Switch, Android or iOS, if you’re looking for a controller with switchable trigger modes.

Features listed in the product title: Bluetooth, TMR joystick, dual-mode triggers, mechanical buttons and a 1000 Hz polling rate.

View at Joybuy
Razer Wolverine V3 Tournament Edition White USB Gamepad

Razer Wolverine V3 Tournament Edition White

For a supported game on Xbox Series X|S or PC, if you’re looking for a wired controller.

Features listed in the product title: USB gamepad for PC and Xbox Series X|S.

View at Joybuy
Black wireless DualShock-compatible game controller

Wireless DualShock-compatible Controller, Black

For a supported game on PS4 or PC, if you’re looking for a wireless controller.

Features listed in the product title: compatibility with PS4 and PC.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will a different controller make subtitles bigger or switch them on?

No, you can’t assume that from the controller’s features alone. Check whether the specific game offers subtitles in your preferred language and lets you adjust the text size, contrast or display.

Can eight people play an arena game on Switch 2 at the same time?

Not just because of the controller limit. Nintendo says that, in most cases, up to eight wireless controllers can be paired, depending on the controller type and its features. The game itself must support the number of local players.

How do I connect and power an extra controller before a gaming session?

It depends on the model. Sony lists USB-C or Bluetooth for connecting DualSense to a PC. Microsoft lists AA batteries or a compatible rechargeable battery solution for the Xbox Wireless Controller. Check the connection and power requirements for the version you’ve chosen.

What are my rights in Germany if a controller is faulty or bought online?

For newly purchased faulty goods, Verbraucherzentrale generally lists two years of statutory warranty rights against the seller. Many online purchases also come with a right to cancel, generally within 14 days of receipt; check the applicable exceptions and conditions separately. This is distinct from a voluntary manufacturer’s guarantee.

Can an old controller go in household rubbish?

No. The German Environment Agency says that old electrical equipment must be disposed of separately from household waste.