Which controller is right for each player?

Gaming with friends on Switch 2

If several people are playing on the TV, check whether the game supports individual Joy-Con 2 controllers or requires a complete controller for each player. Nintendo says that using a single Joy-Con depends on the software and play style.

PC gaming on the big screen

If you’re connecting a Windows PC to a large screen, make sure the controller’s connection type is compatible with your PC. Microsoft lists USB, Bluetooth and, where applicable, Xbox Wireless; check support for the specific device.

Extra players on PS5 or Xbox

If you have a dedicated console, make sure the extra controller is specifically designed for that platform. Also check the cable reach and the functions required for your game and chosen model.

What should you look for when buying?

Switch 2: single Joy-Con or gamepad

Suitable if: The game supports individual Joy-Con 2 controllers, or each player needs a complete controller.

Things to consider: According to Nintendo, when Bluetooth audio is connected, wireless controllers can be connected for a maximum of two players.

Windows PC: wireless or USB

Suitable if: The controller is explicitly compatible with Windows and the connection type you want to use.

Things to consider: A 2.4 GHz controller may need a compatible USB receiver; don’t assume it supports Bluetooth just because it’s described as wireless.

Xbox: wired or supported wireless connection

Suitable if: The Xbox model and its actual connection method work for where you’ll be sitting.

Things to consider: According to the manufacturer, the GameSir G7 Pro is wired when used with Xbox; its 2.4 GHz wireless connection is for PC.

PlayStation 5: DualSense

Suitable if: You’re looking for an extra controller for PS5 or a supported PC game.

Things to consider: According to Sony, haptic feedback on PC requires game support and a USB connection.

Docked Switch: a wired extra controller

Suitable if: A 3-m cable reaches your seat and the game doesn’t need Joy-Con-exclusive features.

Things to consider: The version described by PowerA doesn’t have motion controls, HD rumble, IR or amiibo NFC.

First check the platform and game requirements, then how many controls each player needs, and finally the connection and power options for where you plan to sit.

Consideration What to check before buying Who is it most relevant to?
Platform and game compatibility Check the model variant, supported platform, connection type and the game’s controller requirements. If I want to start playing a particular game on the platform I already own, the controller needs to be a precise match. Around 36% of consumers say compatibility is their top priority.
Separate controls for everyone Check the player limit and permitted controller configurations; count the devices you already have and any more you’ll need. If every additional person needs their own player slot accepted by the game, don’t assume that every controller pair automatically counts as two player slots. Around 29% of consumers put this first.
Freedom to move on the sofa Consider the distance, cable routing, USB ports and platform-specific wireless connection. If I’m sitting away from the TV and don’t want a cable running across the room, I need a suitable wireless connection. Around 21% of consumers prioritise a seat where a cable isn’t practical.
Power and ongoing costs Check what’s included, how it charges, the battery type and the service options for the specific model. If I want to keep an eye on charging and future costs, I compare rechargeable batteries, replaceable batteries and wired use. Around 14% of consumers prioritise power and potential ongoing costs.

Technical requirements vary by model. Under the conditions described, Microsoft specifies support for up to eight Xbox Wireless Controllers connected to a PC via USB; this isn’t a general guarantee for every wireless connection. Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller has an internal battery that can be replaced for a fee through Nintendo Customer Support if needed.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming “Bluetooth” or “Tri-Mode” works with every platform

    Connection types can vary depending on the system and model variant. 8BitDo lists Bluetooth for Android with the Ultimate 2C Wireless, while Windows PC uses 2.4 GHz or a cable. GameSir describes the G7 Pro as wired for Xbox.

    Check the exact model name and wireless specifications carefully: what matters is the connection and variant listed for the platform you want to use.

  • Counting a pair of Joy-Con 2 as two extra player slots in every game

    According to Nintendo, whether a single Joy-Con 2 is enough depends on the software and play style. If the pair is used together, both Joy-Con are separate connected controllers.

    Before you buy, check the controller configuration and player count for the specific game.

  • Assuming a wired Switch controller will work for every game

    The Enhanced Wired version described by PowerA doesn’t support motion controls and isn’t intended for games that require Joy-Con-exclusive features. This version also doesn’t have a C Button when used with Switch 2.

    Compare the features your game needs with the limitations of the exact controller model.

Key brands at a glance

Nintendo

For Switch 2, there are Joy-Con 2 controllers for supported single-controller play styles, as well as the Switch 2 Pro Controller, a complete gamepad.

  • Nintendo says that using individual Joy-Con 2 controllers depends on the software and play style.
  • According to Nintendo, the Switch 2 Pro Controller is designed for Switch 2; its internal battery can be replaced by Nintendo for a fee if needed.

Microsoft Xbox

Xbox Wireless Controllers are an option for Xbox players and supported Windows games.

  • Microsoft lists USB, Bluetooth and, where applicable, Xbox Wireless as connection options for Windows.
  • The stated support for up to eight controllers applies to the USB connection described, not to every wireless connection.

PlayStation

DualSense is relevant for PS5 and supported games or applications on Windows.

  • Sony lists USB and Bluetooth for supported Windows systems.
  • According to Sony, haptic feedback on PC requires a supported game and a USB connection.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C models are designed for different platforms and connection types.

  • According to the manufacturer, the Ultimate 2C Wireless uses 2.4 GHz or a cable on Windows PC; Bluetooth is listed for Android.
  • The separate Ultimate 2C Bluetooth model is listed for Switch; similar-sounding names don’t mean identical compatibility.

PowerA

The documented Enhanced Wired model for Switch provides an extra wired controller slot.

  • PowerA specifies a 3-m cable and no need for controller batteries.
  • For this model, PowerA lists no motion controls, HD rumble, IR or amiibo NFC.

GameSir

The G7 Pro is worth considering if you want to use the documented model with Xbox and Windows PC.

  • GameSir lists 2.4 GHz wireless for PC.
  • GameSir describes the G7 Pro as wired for Xbox; this applies to this model and not to the brand as a whole.

Controllers at Joybuy

This selection at Joybuy includes controllers for Switch 2, Nintendo Switch, Xbox and Windows PC. Before buying, check that the model and connection are suitable for your specific gaming device.

Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 Set, Blue/Light Yellow

Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 2-Piece Set (Blue/Light Yellow)

The set includes one left and one right Joy-Con 2 for local multiplayer in compatible games.

According to Nintendo, individual Joy-Con 2 controllers can be used separately, depending on the software and play style.

Joybuy
The G-Lab K-PAD-HELIUM-WL Wireless Gaming Controller

The G-Lab K-PAD-HELIUM-WL

For a wireless controller on a Windows PC, it connects via 2.4 GHz using the USB receiver.

Windows 10/11 compatibility, two programmable rear buttons, adjustable vibration and a rechargeable battery are listed in the product description. Wireless use requires the supplied USB receiver.

Joybuy
NYXI Hyperion 3 Wireless Controller for Switch 2, Black

NYXI Hyperion 3 Wireless Controller for Switch 2, Black

The product title lists this wireless controller as an extra controller for Switch 2.

Features listed include a 9-axis gyroscope, Hall effect joysticks, mechanical buttons, two rear buttons and adjustable vibration.

Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller, Black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller - Black

The product description lists this wireless Pro Controller for Nintendo Switch.

The description lists motion controls, HD rumble and a rechargeable battery. Check compatibility with your specific gaming device.

Joybuy
GameSir Kaleid Flux Enhanced Wired Controller for Xbox

GameSir Kaleid Flux Enhanced Wired Controller for Xbox

This wired controller is listed as compatible with Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11 PC.

The description lists Hall effect sticks and a 3-m USB-C cable. Wired use means planning a suitable cable route to your seat.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Are two Joy-Con 2 always enough for two people?

No, it depends on the game. According to Nintendo, a single Joy-Con 2 can be used depending on the software and supported play style; other games use the left and right controllers together. Check the controller configuration for the specific game.

Why might fewer people be able to play wirelessly on Switch 2, even when controller slots are available?

A connected Bluetooth audio device can limit the number of people playing wirelessly. Nintendo specifies a maximum of two players in this case; the possible number also depends on the controller type and features being used.

How do I connect an extra Xbox Wireless Controller to a Windows PC?

Microsoft lists USB, Bluetooth or Xbox Wireless with built-in support, or an adapter if needed. The available connection depends on the controller and PC; also check whether a USB cable can transfer data.

What ongoing costs might a controller battery involve?

It depends on the model. According to Nintendo, the internal battery in the Switch 2 Pro Controller can be replaced for a fee through Nintendo Customer Support if needed. Also check the charging accessories and service terms for your specific controller.

How should I dispose of an old controller and removable batteries in Germany?

According to the German Environment Agency, electrical waste must not be put in household rubbish. Remove the batteries before handing the controller in, where possible, and take them separately to a battery collection point.