Choose an HDD based on the measured size of your film files and how much you expect your collection to grow. A desktop HDD may suit an archive kept beside a computer, while a portable HDD is easier to store separately. Also check that the connection and file system are compatible with your computer and backup method. A single hard drive is not an additional backup: the Federal Office for Information Security recommends keeping another copy and checking that you can restore your files.
Who is this type of backup suitable for?
Families with a growing film archive
If you already have your digitised films as files, your HDD should have room for your current collection and future backups. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends allowing enough storage space for backup copies.
Anyone preserving irreplaceable recordings
If you want to recover films after accidentally deleting them or a drive failing, you need a separate copy. You should also check that you can open files from it. The Federal Office for Information Security points out that the lifespan of storage media cannot be predicted precisely.
People using more than one computer
If you back up or open films on different computers, make sure the connection, file system and backup method all work together. For Apple Time Machine, Apple recommends APFS or APFS (Encrypted) for backup volumes.
What should you look for when choosing?
First, check how much storage your film files take up and allow for the growth you expect. Then decide whether the drive will usually stay beside the same computer or be stored separately.
| What matters |
What to look for when buying |
Who should pay particular attention? |
| Capacity for your archive and future growth |
Check the size of your folders and make sure the capacity of the specific model is enough for your current collection and planned backup. |
If my film archive is growing, I want to allow enough room for existing and new files. Around 34% of consumers put capacity for their film archive first. |
| Restoring a separate copy |
Decide where to keep the original and the backup, then try opening a file from the backup. |
If my recordings are irreplaceable, I want to have a readable copy if a drive fails or files are deleted. Around 33% of consumers prioritise being able to restore their films. |
| Connection and file system |
Check that the connection and cable work with your computer; for Time Machine, check the required format for the backup volume. |
If I use more than one computer or Time Machine, I want to avoid buying a drive that connects successfully but isn’t suitable as a backup destination. Around 20% of consumers put compatibility with their computer and backup method first. |
| Separate storage and portability |
Check the design and power supply of the specific model, and decide where you’ll store it safely. |
If I want to keep my backup in another secure location, it matters whether I can conveniently take the drive and its power supply with me. Around 13% of consumers prioritise separate storage and portability. |
What mistakes should you avoid?
-
Moving your only copy of your films to a new hard drive
You would still have only one copy, which could be lost if the drive fails or files are accidentally deleted. The Federal Office for Information Security also points out that the lifespan of storage media cannot be predicted precisely.
Keep another copy separately and check that you can open a film file from it.
-
Assuming a USB connection means it’s compatible with your backup method
A drive may connect successfully but still need a different file system for the backup method you want to use. For Time Machine, Apple recommends APFS or APFS (Encrypted); a Windows-formatted HDD cannot be used as a Time Machine destination without reformatting.
Check the connection and backup method before you buy. Back up any existing data separately before reformatting a volume, as this will erase the data stored on it.
-
Choosing a desktop HDD for frequent moves without checking its power supply
Seagate’s specifications show that the Expansion Desktop needs a power adapter, while the Toshiba Canvio Basics is powered via USB. The design and power supply therefore vary between models.
Check that the specific model suits your storage plans, and remember to factor in the power adapter and cable when transporting it.
Which brands are worth considering for external HDDs?
Western Digital
Western Digital offers the WD Elements Desktop as a stationary drive and the separate, portable My Passport as a different product line.
- Western Digital Germany lists a capacity of 8 TB for the WD Elements Desktop WDBWLG0080HBK-EESN. For this model, the manufacturer specifies USB 3.2 Gen 1 and says it can be used straight away with Windows.
- These details don’t guarantee how long data will remain stored or that every WD model will work with every backup method. Check the specifications for the exact model.
Seagate
Seagate offers portable Expansion Portable and stationary Expansion Desktop drives in different designs.
- According to Seagate, the Expansion Portable is powered via its USB cable and doesn’t need a separate power adapter.
- According to Seagate, the Expansion Desktop needs a power adapter. Seagate says its Rescue Data Recovery Services isn’t available in every country, and it doesn’t replace your own backup.
Toshiba
The Canvio Basics and Canvio Advance are different portable product lines; details about one range don’t necessarily apply to the other.
- Toshiba lists a USB-powered 4-TB version of the Canvio Basics HDTB540EK3CA.
- Toshiba says the Canvio Basics is supplied in NTFS format for Windows; reformatting is required for the Mac use described. Toshiba lists backup software for the Canvio Advance, not as a general feature of the Canvio Basics.
Joybuy products for local film backups
This selection includes portable WD Elements HDDs for a film copy you can store separately, as well as an 8-TB desktop model for an archive kept beside a computer.
No image available
WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C
For a film archive that fits the planned backup based on its measured size and needs to be stored separately.
Listed with 5 TB, USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 1; described as a portable 2.5-inch HDD.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Portable 6TB USB-C
For a film archive that fits the planned backup based on its measured size and needs to be stored separately.
Listed with 6 TB, USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 1; described as a portable 2.5-inch HDD.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C
For a film archive that fits the planned backup based on its measured size and needs to be stored separately.
Listed with 4 TB, USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 1; described as a portable 2.5-inch HDD.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements 2TB Portable External Hard Drive, USB-C
If 2 TB is enough for your measured film files and you want to use the HDD with Windows and Mac computers.
Listed with USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and exFAT; the description says it works with Windows and macOS and has a portable 2.5-inch design with USB power.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements 8TB Desktop External Hard Drive
For a large archive that will mostly be backed up beside a computer, provided its capacity is right for your measured collection and planned growth.
Listed with 8 TB, USB 3.0 and NTFS; described as a stationary 3.5-inch HDD with an external power adapter. Reformatting is required for the macOS use described.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions about backing up family films
Is it enough to move my digitised films to the new external hard drive?
No, not if you won’t have another copy afterwards. Keep a separate backup and check that you can open a film file from it.
Can I use an HDD formatted for Windows with Time Machine straight away?
A Windows-formatted volume can’t be used as a Time Machine destination without reformatting. Apple recommends APFS or APFS (Encrypted); back up any existing data separately before reformatting the volume, as this will erase the data stored on it.
What ongoing costs and rights should I consider when buying?
If your backup plan includes another separate hard drive, allow for this as an additional storage device. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, consumers in Germany who buy faulty goods can exercise their statutory warranty rights with the seller within two years of receiving them. This is different from a voluntary manufacturer’s guarantee.
Can I put a used external hard drive in household rubbish?
No. The Federal Ministry for the Environment explains that old electrical equipment must not go in household rubbish. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends securely deleting personal data before passing on or disposing of a storage device.