Who these storage solutions are for

A family archive of irreplaceable recordings

If interviews can’t be recorded again, plan a separate copy alongside your NAS and think about how you would restore files if something went wrong. The Federal Office for Information Security stresses the importance of keeping backups separate and planning for recovery.

A family with personal stories to protect

If interviews contain personal stories, you’ll want to decide who can open or edit them, and whether they should remain private or be published later. The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information distinguishes between activities carried out solely for personal or family purposes and publication, for example online.

Several people with a growing archive

If recordings and related information are created on several devices, a shared local storage location can make them easier to organise and find. Remember to plan clear file names and information about each recording.

What to consider when choosing

First, consider how many people and devices will need access to the archive. Then look at having a separate backup destination, suitable access rights and a process that lets you restore files.

What matters What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Restorable backup Check whether the model can back up to an external device. Disconnect the drive after the backup and test whether you can restore a file. If I want to protect interviews that can’t be replaced, I need a copy outside the NAS and a tested way to restore it. Around 36% of consumers make recovery their top priority.
Private access Check the user accounts and folder permissions. Set up only the local backup destinations you need, and remember to consider access to the separate copy too. If I want personal stories to be accessible only to selected family members, managing permissions is an important part of choosing a solution. Around 29% of consumers put privacy first.
Findability and storage space Allow enough capacity for existing and future recordings. Test whether you can find a file and its related information, then open it outside the NAS. Anyone building a growing archive across several devices will want to find recordings and related information in an organised way later on. Around 21% of consumers prioritise archive organisation and storage space.
Ease of use Know the difference between an enclosure supplied with drives and a diskless enclosure. Check the local setup process and choose connections to suit your actual needs. If I want to back up a manageable collection without much setup, an external hard drive may be easier to manage. Around 14% of consumers focus above all on keeping things simple.

The Federal Office for Information Security recommends disconnecting backups from other systems after backing up and planning how to restore them. A NAS can bring shared local storage and backup tasks together, but it also requires setup and maintenance. An external hard drive may be easier for one person to manage, but you’ll need a regular routine: connect it, back up your files, disconnect it and store it safely.

Common planning mistakes

  • Relying on RAID 1 as a complete backup

    Mirrored drives in the same NAS aren’t a copy kept separately from the device. They don’t offer the same protection as a backup stored separately.

    Plan for an external backup drive, disconnect it after the backup and try restoring a file.

    Your backup plan should include an extra drive and time for recovery tests.

  • Assuming a diskless enclosure is a complete solution

    A NAS enclosure without internal drives isn’t the same as a fully equipped setup. A separate backup also needs its own destination drive.

    Check what’s included, drive compatibility and the full setup before choosing a model.

    You may need compatible internal drives as well as an external backup drive.

  • Assuming synchronisation is the same as a versioned backup

    With a one-to-one folder sync, the source and destination may contain the same set of files. That doesn’t automatically mean you’ll have access to an earlier version of a file.

    Check how the specific backup task handles deletions and versions, and test restoring an older file.

  • Assuming “local” means “no internet needed for setup”

    Local backup destinations don’t necessarily mean that the initial setup or every update can be done without internet access.

    Set up local destinations. If you also need to avoid internet access, check the installation process for your specific model and software version in advance.

NAS brands worth considering

Synology

DiskStation models such as the DS223j and DS225+ are worth considering for shared local storage and backup tasks.

  • Synology’s Knowledge Center explains how to use Hyper Backup to back up to connected external devices.
  • Synology documents an installation process that doesn’t require internet access, provided you download the necessary files in advance.
  • An independent COMPUTER-BILD test lists the need for an internet connection to set up the DS225+ as a drawback. Check the process for the specific model and software version if you need to set it up entirely offline.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a two-bay NAS for storing files locally and backing them up to an external device.

  • According to QNAP, the TS-233 has a Gigabit Ethernet port and a USB 3.2 Gen 1 port.
  • QNAP’s Hybrid Backup Sync guide explains how to back up to a connected external device.
  • Ports and backup features alone don’t show how restoring files will work in your own setup; test the process with a file.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 AS1102T is a model for local NAS access and external backups.

  • ASUSTOR lists 2.5 Gigabit Ethernet for this model; the ADM help guide explains how to schedule backups to external drives.
  • According to ASUSTOR, a one-to-one folder backup synchronises files in the destination folder with the source folder. Check how it handles deletions and versions, rather than assuming that synchronisation keeps a historical file version.

TerraMaster

The F2-425 has two drive bays and a 2.5GbE port. It may be worth considering if you also have other local data to store alongside your interviews.

  • TerraMaster says USB Copy automatically ejects the drive after a backup task.
  • Automatic ejection isn’t the same as physically disconnecting and storing a backup drive separately.
  • The connection and specification details listed are supplied by the manufacturer and don’t replace testing your own backup and recovery process.

NAS models at Joybuy

The following NAS models may suit a shared local archive, with room to expand. Before choosing, check that the number of drive bays and the listed specifications match your actual archiving needs.

Synology DiskStation DS925+ 4-bay NAS

Synology DiskStation DS925+ 4-bay NAS

Could suit a larger shared archive if you genuinely need four drive bays and the option to expand later.

The product listing specifies four bays, expandability to up to nine bays, dual 2.5GbE and M.2 NVMe SSD caching. According to the product description, Synology drives are compatible; suitable drives need to be installed.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ 8-bay NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ 8-bay NAS

Could be an option for a larger shared archive if eight drive bays suit your planned storage needs.

The product listing specifies eight bays, dual 2.5GbE, optional 10GbE and up to 360TB. Drives must be installed in the eight bays before you can use it.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Are two mirrored hard drives in a NAS enough for a backup?

No. Mirrored drives are no substitute for a separate backup. Mirroring can help keep files available if certain drives fail, but it isn’t a separate copy to protect against other causes of data loss. Set up an additional backup destination and test whether you can restore a file.

Can I back up a NAS to an external hard drive without using the cloud?

Yes. Synology and QNAP guides describe connected external devices as backup destinations, and ASUSTOR also explains how to back up to external drives. Check the process for your chosen model and disconnect the drive after backing up if you want it to serve as a separate copy.

Does setting up a Synology NAS for the first time require an internet connection?

Synology documents an installation process that doesn’t require an internet connection, provided you download the installation files in advance. An independent COMPUTER-BILD test lists the need for an internet connection to set up the DS225+ as a drawback. If you need to stay offline from the outset, check the process for the specific model and software version before buying.

Does the GDPR apply to family interviews kept for private use in Germany?

According to the Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information, the household exemption applies when data is processed solely for personal or family activities. If the material is made publicly available, for example, different requirements may apply; the legal position should then be checked separately for the specific purpose. Storing it locally doesn’t settle the question by itself.

Can I record a private conversation without permission or share the recording?

Section 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) makes it a criminal offence to record another person’s non-public spoken words without authorisation, or to use or make available a recording made in this way. Check that you have permission before recording; sharing the recording later is a separate matter.

What should I allow for when planning a NAS backup setup?

Check whether internal drives are included and whether you’ll also need an external backup drive. Remember to allow time for setup, access permissions, updates and recovery tests.