For a larger photo archive that you access infrequently, an external HDD may be a good option. If you often copy files or take the drive with you, an SSD may be more convenient. To protect restored family photos, you’ll also need a separate local backup: the Federal Office for Information Security and the consumer advice centre recommend checking that you can restore your backups and keeping multiple copies. Before buying, check the connection, file system and, if needed, encryption for the specific model.
Which option is right for you?
A family archive of irreplaceable photos
If you want to protect restored photos from loss without using the cloud, plan a second local copy and keep it in a separate location. The Federal Office for Information Security and the consumer advice centre offer guidance on backing up and restoring data.
A large collection of scans and restored images
If you want to keep the original scans and edited versions as well as the finished photos, first work out how much storage your collection needs and allow for future growth. The right capacity depends on these files and the additional backup.
Accessing photos on several devices
If you want to connect the drive to different devices, check the cable, connection and file system for the specific model. Toshiba notes that its Canvio ranges differ in their cables and formatting.
What should you look for when buying?
For a local family photo archive, your backup routine, storage requirements and the devices you use should all work together.
| Consideration |
What to check before buying |
Who is it important to? |
| Separate backup |
Alongside your archive, plan a second local copy in a separate location and test whether you can copy files back from it. |
If my restored photos matter to me, I want another copy that I can restore even if a drive fails or I accidentally delete something. Around 31 % of consumers would put protection against loss first. |
| Archive capacity |
Work out how much space your originals and edited versions need, and allow for expected growth and the second copy. |
If you keep lots of scans and different versions, you’ll want to choose a size that suits your collection rather than picking a one-size-fits-all capacity. Around 25 % of consumers would prioritise available storage space. |
| Local access protection |
Check whether you can use the drive without a cloud account and, if needed, set up suitable encryption. Keep recovery information separate. |
If you want to store private photos locally only, protecting them if the drive is lost may also be important. Around 25 % of consumers would put local access protection first. |
| Device compatibility |
Check the USB connection, cables included, supported operating systems and pre-installed file system against your devices. |
If you switch between devices, you’ll want to connect your archive without finding that the cable or formatting is unsuitable the first time you use it. Around 19 % of consumers would prioritise compatibility with their own devices. |
Common photo archiving mistakes
-
Your new hard drive becomes your only copy
Even a new drive can fail. If you keep several devices in the same place, one incident could damage every copy.
Plan a second local copy in a separate location and test whether you can restore files from it.
-
A USB connection doesn’t guarantee compatibility with every device
Cables and pre-installed file systems vary by model. For the Canvio Basics model it checked, Toshiba specifies NTFS and says reformatting is required for the macOS versions listed there.
Check the exact model before copying files for the first time. Back up any existing files before reformatting a drive.
Finding a suitable cable or preparing carefully to reformat the drive may take extra time.
-
Encryption is mistaken for a complete backup
Access protection won’t prevent a drive from failing. If you lose the unlock code, it could also make it harder to access your photos.
Treat encryption and data backup as separate tasks. For the Verbatim Store ’n’ Go Secure model 53401, the manufacturer lists a security update; check the notice for this specific model.
Brands to consider
These notes apply to the product ranges and models mentioned, not necessarily to every version from each brand.
Toshiba
Canvio Basics and Canvio Flex are external HDD ranges designed for different connection requirements and use across multiple devices.
- Toshiba offers Canvio Basics with capacities of up to 4 TB. The manufacturer says Canvio Flex includes USB-A and USB-C cables.
- For the Canvio Basics model it checked, Toshiba specifies NTFS and says reformatting is required for the macOS versions listed there. This information doesn’t necessarily apply to every model.
Seagate
The One Touch HDD range is described as suitable for local backups over USB.
- Seagate describes simple or scheduled local backups.
- The manufacturer lists password protection and hardware encryption for certain models. Check the features of the specific model.
Western Digital
My Passport and WD Elements are external HDD ranges that the manufacturer lists in several capacities.
- The different capacity options may suit archives with varying storage needs.
- Check the features, file system and connections for the specific product version.
Verbatim
Store ’n’ Go Secure is aimed at users considering a code-based way to unlock the drive itself.
- For model 53401, Verbatim lists a 1-TB HDD with a keypad and AES-256 hardware encryption.
- The manufacturer says this model requires a security update. The Nero backup software listed in the documentation is not specified for macOS.
Samsung
The Portable SSD T7 Shield is an SSD option for frequent copying or taking files with you; it doesn’t replace a second archive copy.
- For the German 2-TB model MU-PE2T0S/EU, Samsung lists maximum sequential speeds and an IP65 rating tested under controlled conditions.
- According to Samsung, performance depends on the host configuration. Liquid and dust damage are not covered by the warranty.
Joybuy products for local photo storage and access
This selection includes external HDDs for a locally stored photo archive and an SSD option for frequent access or taking files with you.
No image available
WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C
An external HDD for a larger local archive, with 5 TB of storage for your photos and files.
5 TB; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 1. The description says it works with Windows and Mac.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C
An external HDD for photos and other archive files, if 4 TB suits your collection and planned backup.
4 TB; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 1. The description says it comes pre-formatted for Windows and Mac.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements 2TB Portable External Hard Drive, USB-C
An external hard drive for a local photo archive, if 2 TB is enough for your collection and intended use.
2 TB; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 1; exFAT. The description says it works with Windows and macOS.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements 8TB Desktop External Hard Drive
An external desktop HDD for a large photo archive, if a fixed setup suits the way you use it.
8 TB; USB 3.0; 3.5-inch desktop form factor. The description says the included power adapter is required for operation.
View at Joybuy
No image available
KEXIN External SSD 512GB, USB 3.1 Type-C
An external SSD to consider if you often copy photos or want to take the drive with you; it doesn’t replace a second archive copy.
512 GB; USB 3.1; Type-C. The description says it works with PC, Mac and Android.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is one external hard drive enough as my only archive?
No, not if you want your photos to survive a drive failure or damage at the place where they’re stored. Keep another local copy in a separate location and test whether you can copy files back from it; you don’t need cloud storage to do this.
What should I check the first time I connect it to Windows or Mac?
Check the connector, cable and pre-installed file system for the specific model. For the Canvio Basics model it checked, Toshiba specifies NTFS and says reformatting is required for the macOS versions listed there. According to Toshiba, Canvio Flex is available pre-formatted for compatible Windows and Mac devices. Back up any existing files before reformatting a drive.
How can I check that my backup is working?
Try copying some files back and check that you can open them. The Federal Office for Information Security stresses that you need to be able to back up and restore data.
Are a manufacturer’s warranty and statutory rights the same thing?
No. The consumer advice centre distinguishes statutory rights against the seller from a voluntary warranty with its own terms and conditions. Check what the warranty covers, and don’t assume it protects you against data loss or includes data recovery.
What should I do before giving away or disposing of an old hard drive?
Protect the photos stored on it from being accessed before you give the drive away or dispose of it. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends securely deleting personal data; for Germany, the Federal Environment Agency advises that old electrical equipment should be collected separately.