Start by choosing based on your gaming platform and preferred control style, then check that the exact model version supports headphone audio. A fightpad keeps thumb-based controls, an arcade stick uses a joystick, and a leverless controller uses separate directional buttons; none of these layouts automatically suits every play style. If you want to connect your headset to the controller, make sure the connection and audio support are explicitly confirmed for your platform.
Which controller is right for you?
Players who connect a headset to their controller
If you want to use headphones or a headset directly with your controller, check that audio and microphone functions work on your platform. HORI, 8BitDo and Razer specify different connection and platform requirements depending on the model.
Fightpad players
If you want to stick with a directional pad and use a button layout designed for fighting games, a fightpad could be a good option. The PlayStation and Xbox versions of the HORI Fighting Commander OCTA are documented separately.
Players switching to arcade or leverless controls
If you're considering a joystick or separate directional buttons, compare the control style with your platform and the space you have available when playing. GameStar describes different controllers as suiting different play styles, rather than presenting one option as right for everyone.
What to consider when choosing
Fightpad
A good fit if: you want to play using a directional pad and have several front-facing action buttons. HORI lists the Fighting Commander OCTA as separate PlayStation and Xbox versions.
Bear in mind: Platform compatibility and audio features apply to the specific version in question.
Arcade stick
A good fit if: you prefer a joystick and arcade buttons. The 8BitDo Arcade Stick for Xbox lists a 3.5 mm socket and volume control for the specified Xbox and Windows platforms.
Bear in mind: Using a joystick feels different from using a directional pad; the listed version is not documented as compatible with PS5.
Leverless controller
A good fit if: you prefer to enter directions using separate buttons. The 8BitDo Arcade Controller for Xbox lists an all-button layout and a 3.5 mm socket for the specified Xbox and Windows platforms.
Bear in mind: It may take time to get used to the layout. The manufacturer's stated wired latency is based on ideal conditions and is not an independent comparison.
Standard gamepad
A good fit if: you want to stick with a familiar gamepad layout. According to the manufacturer's instructions, the GameSir G7 HE is designed for Xbox and Windows and offers headset controls on those platforms.
Bear in mind: A standard gamepad is no substitute for a six-button fightpad or arcade layout; check audio output for your specific setup.
First, check the exact platform version, then confirm the audio connection and button layout. HORI, 8BitDo, Razer and GameSir document the features of their respective models, including audio; the presence of a socket alone does not prove that audio will work with every device.
| What you're looking for |
What to check before buying |
Who is this important to? |
| Headphone and microphone support |
Check audio support and, where relevant, microphone support for your specific platform. Razer explicitly states that audio is not available on the Raion in PC mode. |
If I want to connect my headset directly to the controller, I check audio and microphone support for my device; around 36% of consumers prioritise controller audio. |
| Platform and model version |
Match the full model name and platform list to your console or PC. HORI documents the Fighting Commander OCTA in separate PlayStation and Xbox versions. |
If I'm choosing a controller for a console or PC, the exact model version needs to work with my device; around 29% of consumers make platform compatibility their top priority. |
| Control layout |
Choose between a directional pad, joystick and separate directional buttons; manufacturer claims about individual components do not prove an overall performance advantage. |
If the way my hands move while playing matters most to me, I'll compare all three control styles before buying; around 21% of consumers prioritise how a controller feels to use. |
| Familiar gamepad or specialist layout |
Check whether your current gamepad is suitable for your gaming platform and audio setup before switching to a different style. |
If I want to start with controls I'm familiar with, I don't need to choose a specialist layout straight away; around 14% of consumers prioritise ease of use. |
Common misconceptions
-
Assuming fightpads with similar names are the same platform version
HORI documents the PlayStation and Xbox versions of the Fighting Commander OCTA separately and advises against using firmware intended for one version on the other.
Before buying, check the full model name, platform list and, where relevant, the firmware identifier.
-
Assuming a headset socket means audio will work with every device
According to Razer, audio is not available on the Raion in PC mode.
Check audio and microphone support for the specific platform you play on; your setup may need a different audio connection.
-
Choosing a specialist layout based solely on promises of precision
A controller with a joystick or separate directional buttons requires a different control style from a familiar gamepad. Manufacturer claims about individual components do not guarantee better results in play.
First decide whether you want to stick with a directional pad or learn a different layout.
If you switch layouts, allow yourself time to get used to the new controls.
Key brands to consider
HORI
The Fighting Commander OCTA range includes documented fightpad versions for PlayStation and Xbox.
- HORI lists a headset input and built-in audio controls for both wired versions.
- Platform compatibility applies to the specific version; the PlayStation and Xbox models are not documented as interchangeable.
8BitDo
Different designs are documented for Xbox and Windows: an arcade stick with a joystick and an arcade controller without one.
- Both of the models listed have a 3.5 mm socket.
- The wired latency quoted by the manufacturer for the leverless controller comes from a test under ideal conditions and does not automatically apply to other 8BitDo versions.
Razer
The Raion is a six-button fightpad for PS4 games and an example of how controller audio support can depend on the platform.
- Razer lists an analogue 3.5 mm audio socket.
- According to Razer, audio is not available in PC mode. On PS5, the Raion supports PS4 games, not new PS5 games.
GameSir
The wired G7 HE is a standard gamepad alternative for the Xbox and Windows platforms listed in its instructions.
- The instructions cover headset volume, game and chat balance, and microphone muting.
- Its gamepad layout is no substitute for a six-button fightpad or arcade layout; details of other G7 versions do not automatically apply.
Joybuy products
The Joybuy products below are standard gamepads for Xbox or PC.
No image available
Razer Wolverine V3 Tournament Edition White
For Xbox or PC if you're looking for a standard gamepad with extra controls on the back.
Wired USB gamepad for PC, Xbox Series S and Xbox Series X.
The product description lists four rear paddles and six assignable buttons.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is a 3.5 mm socket enough to use headphones on a PC?
Not necessarily. Razer explicitly states that audio is not available on the Raion in PC mode. Check the audio information for your specific platform rather than just checking whether there's a socket.
Can I treat the PlayStation and Xbox versions of the Fighting Commander OCTA as the same?
No. HORI documents the models separately and advises against using firmware intended for one version on the other. Check the model name and platform information before installing an update.
What should I bear in mind when setting up and maintaining a wired gamepad?
Connect the GameSir G7 HE to your Xbox or PC via USB-C, following the manufacturer's instructions. The instructions also cover calibration and headset controls; configure the settings and firmware according to the guide for your exact model version.
What rights do I have when buying online from a trader in Germany?
According to the European Union's official consumer information, a standard distance purchase generally comes with a 14-day withdrawal period from the date of delivery; exceptions and conditions apply. Separately, faulty goods are generally covered by a legal guarantee of at least two years. A voluntary manufacturer's guarantee is not the same as these statutory rights.