Which controller is right for you?

Players with a preferred input style

If you want to practise a particular joystick or directional-button movement repeatedly, start by checking the layout. The input style matters more for practice than a general performance claim.

Players using a specific console

If you’re training for a particular game on PS5, Xbox, Switch or PC, check the platform details for the exact controller variant. Some configurations may require an adapter and compatible firmware.

Players with a dedicated practice setup

If you practise regularly at a desk or on your lap, consider the space available, your hand position and the cable routing. The case shape or height alone won’t tell you whether a controller will suit you during long sessions.

What should you look for when buying?

Joystick fightstick

A good fit if: you specifically want to practise combo inputs using joystick movements.

The trade-off: The joystick and case take up space, and the movements differ from inputs made using individual directional buttons.

All-button controller

A good fit if: you want to enter directions deliberately with individual fingers and repeat that exact sequence.

The trade-off: The button layout calls for a different set of movements; a low-profile design alone doesn’t guarantee a comfortable hand position.

Joystick controller with additional platform support

A good fit if: you need a joystick and specific PC modes or other platforms listed by the manufacturer.

The trade-off: For the PS5 configuration of the MAYFLASH F500 Elite described by the manufacturer, you’ll need to account for a compatible MagicBoots-S5 adapter and suitable firmware.

For long combo practice sessions, the input style you want to use comes first. Then check the platform variant and the space available in your practice area.

What matters What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Directional and attack inputs Decide whether you want to practise joystick movements or use individual directional buttons, then check the actual button layout. If I want to repeat a particular move in a game, the layout needs to suit it. Around 31% of consumers put their preferred input sequence first.
Game and platform Check the full model name against your system and, if necessary, check the adapter and firmware requirements. If I’m practising a particular game on my console or PC, the exact variant needs to be compatible. Around 31% of consumers prioritise platform compatibility.
Space and hand position Consider the case footprint, your hands and cable routing; a low-profile design doesn’t guarantee a comfortable position. If I practise in the same place for long periods, I want to be able to position the controller and my hands comfortably. Around 19% of consumers focus mainly on the space available.
Setup and maintenance Check access for maintenance, compatible parts, any software required and what’s included with your configuration. If I want to customise parts or keep setup to a minimum, the extra effort matters too. Around 19% of consumers prioritise maintenance and setup.

Common buying misconceptions

  • Models with similar names are designed for the same platforms

    That isn’t necessarily the case: 8BitDo lists different controllers for Switch and Windows, and for Xbox and Windows.

    Check the full product name against the system you’ll be practising on.

  • Multi-platform compatibility means you can use it with PS5 straight away

    For the F500 Elite configuration with PS5 described by MAYFLASH, you’ll need to account for MagicBoots-S5 and suitable firmware.

    Check adapter compatibility, firmware and what’s included for your exact configuration.

    Depending on the configuration, you may need to buy an adapter and spend time setting up the firmware.

  • Short button travel automatically improves combos or comfort

    Manufacturer claims about a controller’s design don’t prove that you’ll learn faster or that your hand position will be comfortable during long sessions.

    Choose a layout to suit the practice sequence you want to use, and assess the setup and hand position separately.

Key brands to help you decide

HORI

Offers joystick fightsticks; HORI lists PS5, PS4 and Windows 11/10 compatibility for the Fighting Stick α SPF-013U.

  • For this model, HORI specifies HAYABUSA joystick and buttons, as well as an opening case for customisation and maintenance.
  • These details don’t prove better combo execution and don’t necessarily apply to other variants.

Razer

The Kitsune is an all-button model that Razer describes as compatible with PS5 and PC.

  • Razer lists four directional buttons, low-profile optical switches and a detachable USB-C cable.
  • A leverless layout won’t replace a joystick if you want to practise joystick movements; claims of superior inputs aren’t independent evidence.

8BitDo

The range includes different joystick and all-button controllers for specific listed platforms.

  • 8BitDo lists several connection options for its Arcade Stick, and interchangeable switches for the Arcade Controller for Xbox.
  • Platform variants aren’t interchangeable. Performance and latency claims aren’t a substitute for independent testing in your practice setup.

MAYFLASH

The F500 Elite is a joystick fightstick with PC modes listed by the manufacturer.

  • MAYFLASH lists Sanwa components, as well as XInput and DInput for PC.
  • For the PS5 use described with MagicBoots-S5, you’ll need to account for a compatible adapter and suitable firmware.

Hit Box Arcade

The manufacturer describes the PC Hit Box specifically as a PC model with all-button inputs.

  • For the PC Hit Box, the manufacturer lists a non-slip base and a detachable cable.
  • Platform details for other Hit Box variants can’t be assumed to apply to this PC model.

Joybuy products for combo practice

The Joybuy products below are all-button or leverless controllers for practising combos with individual directional buttons rather than joystick movements.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller for Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller for Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android

For practising combos with individual directional buttons rather than joystick movements.

Connection options: wired, Bluetooth and 2.4 GHz.

The product name specifies hot-swappable mechanical switches.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How can I check whether a controller is suitable for combo practice?

First decide whether you want to practise joystick movements or use individual directional buttons. According to Capcom, Street Fighter 6’s Training Mode lets you record and replay actions performed by the training dummy. This allows you to repeat input scenarios, but it doesn’t guarantee that a particular controller will improve your performance.

What should I consider when setting up and maintaining my controller?

Check the input mode and instructions for the exact model variant. HORI describes the SPF-013U as having case access for maintenance; the F500 Elite configuration with MagicBoots-S5 described by MAYFLASH requires suitable firmware. Don’t assume that instructions for one model apply to other variants.

What rights do I have when shopping online in Germany?

According to the Verbraucherzentrale, consumers generally have a 14-day withdrawal period for online purchases, which usually starts when the goods are received; you must notify the retailer if you wish to withdraw from the purchase. The Verbraucherzentrale also explains that, if newly purchased goods are faulty, consumers can assert their statutory warranty rights within two years of delivery or receipt. These rights are separate from a voluntary guarantee.

What should I look for on product labels and when disposing of a controller?

For products covered by the relevant EU harmonisation legislation and placed on the EU market, the Bundesnetzagentur says CE marking is mandatory. It also recommends checking the product identification, manufacturer details and any instructions required in German. Electrical and electronic waste must be collected separately; whether a retailer is required to take it back depends on the relevant conditions, as explained by the Umweltbundesamt.