Who are the different controllers suitable for?

Players who want to practise with a joystick

If you want to repeat movement sequences specifically using an arcade joystick, check that you choose the right platform version and have enough space to use it. HORI and 8BitDo both offer joystick models, each with its own compatibility requirements.

Players who prefer direction buttons

If you want to enter each direction using a separate button, compare the button layout, connection and input mode. Features vary from model to model.

Players in bright rooms

In daylight, assess reflections on your screen separately from the visibility and finish of the controller. A matte button or controller lighting won’t tell you whether your screen is reflecting light.

What should you look for when buying?

First decide whether you want to practise joystick movements or using individual direction buttons. Then check compatibility, visibility, space and maintenance options for your specific setup.

Consideration What to check before buying Who is this particularly important for?
Input type Joystick or individual direction buttons; the layout needs to suit the movements you want to practise. If I want to learn specific combos using a joystick or individual direction buttons, that particular movement pattern is essential; around 25% of consumers put the right input type first.
Platform compatibility Check the exact model variant, console or operating system and, where applicable, game version. If the controller needs to work with my existing gaming system, I check the details for the exact model; around 25% of consumers say platform compatibility is a priority.
Visibility in daylight Assess the light and screen position; view the controller’s surfaces in similar lighting conditions. If I play in a bright room, I want to see the screen and buttons clearly; around 20% of consumers prioritise visibility in daylight.
Space and hand position Check the available desk space, cable route and hand position; only assume layouts are adjustable if this is stated for the exact variant. If I practise at the same desk regularly, I need enough room for the controller and my hands; around 15% of consumers pay particular attention to space and playing position.
Maintenance Check access to the casing, compatible replacement switches and any included accessories. If I want to use the controller long term or replace components, access to compatible parts matters to me; around 15% of consumers put ease of maintenance first.

Which buying mistakes should you avoid?

  • Assuming an ‘Arcade Stick’ is compatible with PlayStation

    Similar product names don’t mean the models support the same consoles. 8BitDo says its Arcade Stick doesn’t support PS4 or PS5, while HORI lists PlayStation support for certain other models.

    Before buying, check the manufacturer’s information against the full model name and the platform you need.

  • Thinking leverless is a substitute for joystick practice

    A joystick and individual direction buttons require different hand movements. Practising on a different layout won’t automatically train the inputs you’ll want to use on a joystick later.

    Choose the design that matches the inputs you actually want to practise.

  • Assuming RGB or matte buttons mean glare-free gaming

    Screen reflections depend on the screen’s finish and the light in the room; you can’t tell whether your screen will reflect light from the controller’s finish or lighting.

    Check your screen’s position and the light in your gaming area separately from the controller’s finish.

  • Confusing programmable buttons with tournament approval

    Rules may distinguish between button mappings set in the game and inputs programmed into the hardware. The Evo rules prohibit certain hardware-programmed inputs; this isn’t a universal rule for every event.

    If you’re planning to enter a tournament, check its current rules on controllers, macros and input modes. This doesn’t mean there’s a general ban on using them for private practice.

Which brands and model ranges are worth considering?

HORI

HORI offers the Fighting Stick α as a joystick model and the NOLVA REACTOR as a separate all-button model.

  • HORI lists a HAYABUSA joystick and matte HAYABUSA buttons for the Fighting Stick α. For the NOLVA REACTOR, the manufacturer describes dampened, replaceable switches.
  • These details apply to the respective models. Check the platform and variant rather than assuming the same features apply to other HORI products.

8BitDo

The Arcade Stick is a joystick option, while the Arcade Controller is a flat, all-button option. Platform compatibility varies by model.

  • 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C for the Arcade Stick. For the Arcade Controller, the manufacturer describes a glass front and replaceable switches.
  • According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Stick doesn’t support PS4 or PS5. In bright light, also check for reflections from the controller’s surface in your gaming area.

Razer

Razer describes the Kitsune as a leverless controller for PS5 and PC.

  • Features listed by the manufacturer include optical switches, a removable aluminium top plate, RGB and several SOCD modes.
  • The manufacturer’s details don’t provide independent evidence of improved precision. Assess the lighting and finish in the conditions where you play.

Victrix

The Pro-KO range is available as an adaptable leverless controller; the PlayStation and Xbox versions are separate models.

  • Turtle Beach lists repositionable buttons, hot-swappable switches and adjustable RGB light rings for the range.
  • These model features don’t guarantee combo success or mean that every variant is compatible with every platform.

Qanba

Qanba offers the Obsidian 2 as a joystick model and the Sapphire S1 as a separate leverless range.

  • Qanba lists a Sanwa joystick, Sanwa buttons and a tournament lock for the Obsidian 2. For the Sapphire S1, the manufacturer describes customisable buttons.
  • These details come from Qanba’s product overview. Don’t assume that features or compatibility carry over from one model range to the other.

Joybuy controllers for combo practice

This selection includes a leverless controller for practising with direction buttons. It suits this input style, but not focused joystick practice.

BIGBIG WON Fight Master leverless controller

BIGBIG WON Fight Master Leverless Controller

The all-button design is a good choice if you want to practise entering directions using individual buttons instead of a joystick.

The product title lists Switch 2, Switch, PC, iOS and Android as compatible platforms. It also lists Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and wired connections, as well as hot-swappable mechanical switches.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will a different arcade controller get rid of reflections on my gaming screen?

No. Screen reflections and the controller’s finish are two separate issues. First check the light in the room and the position of your screen; a matte controller button doesn’t mean the screen is anti-glare. BenQ explains the difference between focused reflections on glossy screens and scattered reflections on matte screens.

How can I practise combos with a new layout?

According to Capcom, in Street Fighter 6 you can record and play back actions for the training character in Training Mode. Set the button mapping to suit your controller and game; Capcom also documents the input history display.

Does the 8BitDo Arcade Stick work with PS5?

No. According to 8BitDo’s product-specific FAQ, this Arcade Stick doesn’t support PS4 or PS5. This doesn’t automatically apply to other 8BitDo models or to variants from other brands specifically sold as PlayStation-compatible.

Are macros or SOCD modes allowed in tournaments?

It depends on the rules of the event. The Evo rules prohibit hardware-programmed macros but allow certain button mappings available through the game menu; this doesn’t mean every SOCD mode is automatically permitted, or that the same rules apply to other tournaments. Check the current event rules before you enter.

What should I do if the controller is faulty or I don’t like the layout after buying it online?

If a product is faulty, statutory consumer rights against the seller are separate from any voluntary guarantee. For online purchases by consumers, there’s usually a 14-day right to cancel, although exceptions may apply. The Verbraucherzentrale recommends checking the applicable terms and notifying the seller that you wish to cancel.