Which solution is right for you?

Photographers creating multiple edits

If you want to reuse a landscape scan for different crops and edits, it’s important to be able to save an original scan. VueScan and LaserSoft Imaging describe workflows that let you edit saved raw data again.

Detail-focused landscape photographers

If you value control over scan settings and tones more than a quick, ready-made result, check the features offered by the specific software and scanner combination. Plustek lists SilverFast SE Plus 9 and QuickScan Plus as included software with the OpticFilm 8300i SE.

Photographers with a negative archive

If you have lots of strips or different film formats, the transport mechanism and compatible holders can affect how much work is involved. reflecta lists automatic film transport for the RPS 10S; according to the manufacturer, the x66-Scan also supports 120 roll film.

What to look for when buying

First decide whether you need a reusable original scan. Then consider tonal range, the number of negatives you have, film format and the type of output you want.

Priority What to check Who is it important to?
Multiple edit versions Check whether you can save a raw scan and edit it again later using the software you plan to use. If I want to use the same landscape scan for different crops and edits, I need a reusable original file. Around 33% of consumers put multiple image versions first.
Tones and detail Check the available settings and support for your preferred film format; advertised dpi figures are not independent proof of image sharpness. If I want control over image information in both the highlights and shadows of a landscape, I look for suitable settings rather than relying solely on a simple, ready-made result. Around 27% of consumers prioritise tones and detail.
Lots of negatives reflecta lists the RPS 10S as handling 3 to 40 frames per strip; according to Plustek, the Plustek OpticFilm 135i automatically processes up to six frames on a strip. With a larger archive, I want to process strips quickly and reload as infrequently as possible. Around 20% of consumers say the work involved in scanning lots of negatives is their main concern.
The right film format Identify your negative format and check which holders are included. According to reflecta, the reflecta x66-Scan supports 120 formats from 6 × 4,5 to 6 × 9 cm. If my archive contains different film formats, the scanner needs to support them with compatible holders. Around 13% of consumers put format compatibility first.
Easy viewing without a PC Check the output format and storage requirements: the reflecta x33-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card; according to the supplier, the KODAK SLIDE N SCAN requires an SD card, which is not included. If I want to view negatives easily without a computer to start with, a file I can view straight away is useful. Around 7% of consumers prioritise simple, ready-made output.

Avoiding buying mistakes

  • Assuming a higher advertised pixel count means more image detail

    KODAK Photo Plus distinguishes between the 14-MP sensor in the SLIDE N SCAN and its interpolated 22-MP output. The higher output figure does not automatically mean the sensor has a higher resolution.

    Compare sensor specifications and output files separately rather than focusing solely on the highest pixel count.

  • Assuming the included scanning software is a complete archiving and editing package

    Plustek lists SilverFast SE Plus 9 and QuickScan Plus for the OpticFilm 8300i SE. This does not confirm that the separate SilverFast Archive Suite is included; what you get depends on the specific licence.

    Before buying, check which software licence and raw-data features are included with the scanner package.

    If the package you choose doesn’t include the editing features you need, you may have to budget for an additional software licence.

  • Treating JPEG previews and a flexible, editable original scan as the same workflow

    reflecta describes the x33-Scan as saving files directly in JPEG format. If you want to create significantly different edits later, check whether this output will be good enough.

    Before buying, decide whether you prioritise simple preview files or a reusable original scan.

    If the file you have isn’t suitable for a new edit, you may need to scan the negative again.

Key brands at a glance

Plustek

The OpticFilm models cater for different 35 mm workflows: software-assisted editing of individual frames with the 8300i SE, and automatic processing of smaller batches with the 135i.

  • Plustek lists SilverFast SE Plus 9 and QuickScan Plus as included software with the OpticFilm 8300i SE.
  • According to Plustek, the OpticFilm 135i automatically processes up to six frames on a film strip.
  • A panoramic film holder for the 135i is optional. For larger collections, the small batch size means you’ll need to reload more often.

reflecta

The range includes everything from the RPS 10S, with film transport and DNG output, to standalone scanners that save files directly to an SD card.

  • reflecta lists automatic strip transport for the RPS 10S, handling strips with 3 to 40 frames, as well as DNG output.
  • According to reflecta, the x66-Scan also supports 120 roll film from 6 × 4,5 to 6 × 9 cm.
  • According to reflecta, the x33-Scan and x66-Scan save JPEG files. This is not the same workflow as saving a raw scan for repeated editing.

KODAK

The SLIDE N SCAN is a standalone option for viewing negatives and slides in the film formats specified by the supplier.

  • KODAK Photo Plus lists a 14-MP sensor and storage on an SD card.
  • According to the supplier, an SD card is required for operation but is not included. The advertised 22-MP output is interpolated.
  • The specifications provided do not confirm an equivalent raw-scan workflow for creating several significantly different edits.

Joybuy products

Similar products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

How can I create multiple edit versions without scanning the negative again?

Save an original scan first, then create separate edited exports from it. VueScan explains how to reprocess saved raw scans; LaserSoft Imaging describes an HDRi RAW workflow, availability of which depends on the scanner and software package.

Does an infrared channel remove dust from black-and-white negatives too?

Don’t rely on infrared dust removal for silver-based black-and-white film. VueScan’s documentation distinguishes between the feature’s use with colour film and black-and-white film; LaserSoft Imaging offers SRDx as a different, software-based way to correct dust and scratches.

What should I check before loading the negatives?

Check the film format, the right holder and the software you plan to use. Handle negatives with care and check them for dust before scanning; not every defect can be removed using infrared.

What extra parts or software should I budget for?

According to KODAK Photo Plus, the KODAK SLIDE N SCAN requires an SD card, which is not included. A panoramic holder is available as an optional extra for the Plustek OpticFilm 135i. Also check which raw-data features are covered by the specific scanner and software licence.

Can I scan someone else’s landscape negatives to create personal edits?

Section 53(1) of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) allows individuals to make individual copies for private use under the conditions set out there, particularly where there is no direct or indirect commercial purpose. This does not automatically give you the right to publish an edit or use it commercially.