Which scanning methods are right for you?

Family photo editors

If you want to edit negatives on your own computer and store them in an organised way, check film compatibility, the file formats actually offered and the software included in the package. Plustek documents the use of SilverFast with the OpticFilm 8200i SE; the Library of Congress lists TIFF and DNG as formats for digital photographs.

Owners of mixed film collections

If you have 35 mm and medium-format negatives, or additional paper photos, check the film formats and holders carefully before buying. Epson lists holders for 35 mm and 120/220 film for the Perfection V600 Photo; according to Epson Germany, this model is no longer available.

Anyone digitising lots of film strips

If you have lots of continuous 35 mm negatives to scan, transport and the number of frames handled per pass are important things to check. reflecta specifies automatic transport for strips with 3 to 40 frames on the RPS 10S. A review of the Plustek OpticFilm 135i by F.A.Z. Kaufkompass describes scanning a strip of up to six frames per pass.

What should you look for when buying?

Prioritise your options according to what matters most for your collection: file format, film holders, loading effort or defect correction.

Requirement What to check before buying Who is this most relevant to?
Editable archive files Check the output formats supported by the specific device and software package, whether files can be imported into your editing software, and how to back up your original files separately. If I want to edit negatives on my computer later and keep them organised, I need a suitable file format and a reliable way to import them. Around 36% of consumers prioritise editable archive files.
Film formats and holders Make sure your film formats match the scan area and holders supplied with the exact model. If I have a collection in different film formats, I want to be sure the scanner and holders suit my originals. Around 29% of consumers put format and holder compatibility first.
Loading effort for lots of strips Compare the stated capacity per pass and check whether the transport system is suitable for your continuous strips. If I’m digitising lots of 35 mm strips, how often I have to load the film by hand matters to me. Around 21% of consumers prioritise easy loading.
Dust, scratches and image detail Check the film type, whether an infrared channel is available and which software features are supported. Also assess a sample scan rather than relying on the stated dpi figure alone. With old negatives, I want to understand how much work visible defects will involve, without assuming that a high resolution figure guarantees more detail. Around 14% of consumers prioritise spending less time correcting defects.

Which buying mistakes should you avoid?

  • Assuming the highest dpi figure means the best usable image quality

    A high resolution figure from the manufacturer alone doesn’t show how much detail the scan actually contains. The Library of Congress notes that resolution is just one of several criteria to consider when digitising.

    Compare sample scans of the negatives you’re likely to use and distinguish manufacturer claims from independently measured results.

  • Assuming a JPEG scanner also offers TIFF or DNG output

    reflecta documents JPEG saving to an SD card for the x22-Scan and DNG output for the RPS 10S. These models use different file workflows.

    Decide which output format you need for your editing before buying, and check that your software can import it.

    If you later need a different output format, you may have to scan your negatives again.

  • Assuming availability and supplied accessories from an older model description

    Epson lists the Perfection V600 Photo as no longer available in Germany. The documented features therefore don’t confirm that it’s currently available.

    If you’re considering a specific listing, check the condition of the scanner and which holders and usable software are included.

    A scanner offered elsewhere may be missing the holders or compatible software you need.

  • Keeping scans on just one card or hard drive

    If your only storage device is lost or damaged, your digitised family photos could be lost too. The Federal Office for Information Security and the Library of Congress recommend backing up personal files.

    Keep your unedited original files and separate backup copies.

Which brands are worth considering?

Plustek

Plustek describes the OpticFilm 8200i SE as a computer-connected option for scanning 35 mm film, and the 135i as a different model for 35 mm negatives.

  • For the OpticFilm 8200i SE, Plustek specifies an optical resolution of 7,200 dpi and iSRD, which uses the integrated infrared channel as part of the supplied software workflow.
  • F.A.Z. Kaufkompass describes the tested OpticFilm 135i as processing a strip of up to six frames per pass.
  • The features of the 8200i SE and 135i are specific to each model and can’t be assumed to apply to the other. The 8200i SE’s resolution is a manufacturer’s claim, not an independent measurement.

reflecta

reflecta documents different workflows: the computer-connected RPS 10S for 35 mm film strips and the standalone x22-Scan, which saves files to an SD card.

  • For the RPS 10S, reflecta specifies automatic transport for 3 to 40 frames and DNG output.
  • For the x22-Scan, reflecta documents direct saving of 35 mm negatives as JPEG files to an SD card.
  • The models differ in their file and scanning workflows; the manufacturer’s claims aren’t an independent comparison of image quality. Check which formats your software supports.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo is a documented flatbed example for different types of originals and TIFF output.

  • For this model, Epson lists holders for 35 mm and 120/220 film, as well as TIFF files.
  • Epson Germany lists the Perfection V600 Photo specifically as no longer available. This doesn’t confirm that new units are currently available.

Rollei

According to Rollei, the DF-S 310 SE is a standalone slide and negative scanner with a display, internal memory and an SD card slot.

  • Rollei specifies image capture at 14 MP and output interpolated to up to 24 MP. According to the manufacturer, the SE version includes extra holders for Pocket film.
  • Interpolation doesn’t add any extra image information to the original capture. If you want to edit scans on your computer, check the output format for the specific model.

Related products on Joybuy

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Is JPEG enough if I want to edit my scans on a computer later?

You can edit JPEG files on a computer. If you need a different output format for later editing, specifically check for TIFF or DNG output and make sure your software can import it. The Library of Congress lists TIFF and DNG as preferred formats for digital photographs and JPEG as an acceptable format. This guidance isn’t a requirement for private households.

What should I bear in mind when setting up the scanner and handling old negatives?

Check the film holders, computer connection and supported operating system for the specific model. Keep negatives and scanning surfaces as dust-free as possible, and start with test scans. The Library of Congress notes that dust and fingerprints can be captured in the scan.

What do I need to do to back up my files after scanning?

Allow enough storage space for your original files and separate backup copies. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends backing up personal data, for example on external storage devices. The Library of Congress advises keeping copies on at least two different types of media in separate locations.

Can I publish digitised family photos?

Scanning photos for personal use doesn’t automatically give you permission to publish them. According to the Berlin Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information, the GDPR exemption applies when images are intended exclusively for personal or family use and remain within the private sphere. Under § 22 KunstUrhG, consent from the person pictured is generally required to distribute or publicly display an image; the exceptions in § 23 must be assessed on a case-by-case basis.