Editors working with 35 mm negatives
You want to scan selected landscape photos on your computer, keep a master scan and make changes only to working copies.
Choose a film scanner based first on the negative format, image width and compatible holder: a 35 mm scanner won’t automatically handle 120 film or wide panoramas. For separate working copies, file format and computer workflow matter too. The Library of Congress recommends keeping a suitable master file unchanged and making edits to a copy. A standalone device such as the reflecta x66-Scan offers less flexibility for this, as reflecta specifies JPEG output, than a workflow with a suitable master file.
You want to scan selected landscape photos on your computer, keep a master scan and make changes only to working copies.
First, check that the scanner and holder can capture the entire negative. Only then is it worth comparing scan and file features.
If you want to spend less time reloading, compare the supported strip length and the file workflow that follows.
| What you need | What to check before buying | Who it matters most to |
|---|---|---|
| Master scans and working copies | File formats and settings in the supplied software; separate storage and backups after importing. | If I want to edit landscape photos, I want to keep the master scan and save changes only to a copy. Around 36% of consumers have this as their main priority. |
| Capturing the entire negative | Check the film type, image dimensions and supplied holder; for panoramas, check the maximum image width. | If my negative is in 120/220 format or is a wide panorama, the entire image area must be captured. Around 29% of consumers prioritise format compatibility above all else. |
| Scanning lots of film strips | Compare the number of frames supported per strip and the capacity per pass with your own film collection. | If I have lots of compatible 35 mm strips, I want to reload less often. Around 21% of consumers have throughput as their main priority. |
| Working without a computer for scanning | Check the storage medium and file output; for megapixel figures, distinguish sensor values from interpolated ones. | If I want to view negatives without a computer connected, a straightforward standalone workflow matters to me. Around 14% of consumers prioritise standalone operation above all else. |
For the reflecta x66-Scan, reflecta lists 14 MP and an interpolated 22 MP output separately. The higher interpolated figure alone does not indicate extra sensor detail.
Check the file type and native sensor data for the exact model. Store the master file separately from the working copy.
If the file produced isn’t suitable for future editing, you may need to scan again.
Scan areas and holders vary between models. A general claim that a scanner is suitable for 35 mm film doesn’t tell you whether it can capture the whole of a 120 negative or a wide panorama.
Compare your negative’s film type and dimensions with the scan area and the holder actually supplied.
Depending on the listing, you may need a different scanner or an additional compatible holder.
According to reflecta, the RPS 10S is designed for compatible 35 mm strips containing 3 to 40 frames. Automatic feeding doesn’t replace checking individual scans or organising your files.
Count the strips and frames in your collection, and allow time for checking, naming and backing up files as well as feeding them into the scanner.
Even with automatic feeding, you’ll still need to set aside time for managing your files afterwards.
The OpticFilm models mentioned here support different film formats, so check the full model name and the software included with the specific listing.
The RPS 10S and x66-Scan offer different workflows: computer-connected feeding and standalone scanning, respectively.
The Perfection V850 Pro is an example of a flatbed scanner to consider if you already own one or have checked a specific second-hand listing.
After importing, save the master scan as an unchanged file, create a separate copy for editing and back up important files to separate storage media too. The Library of Congress recommends keeping important files on at least two different storage media; this isn’t an automatic feature on every scanner.
Not necessarily. Check the actual image width and the compatible holder. For the Plustek OpticFilm 135i, SilverFast lists an optional panoramic holder, which you shouldn’t assume is included just because of the model name.
Check the holder, as well as the operating system and software requirements for the exact model. Set up separate storage locations for master scans and working copies. Dust on the negative or scanning surface may show up in the digital image.
Don’t assume it will work with conventional silver-based black-and-white film. LaserSoft Imaging explains that its emulsion doesn’t let through the infrared light used by iSRD in the same way as colour film. Check the film type and the correction method intended for it.
According to consumer information from the European Union, you’re generally entitled to a statutory guarantee against faulty goods from the seller for at least two years; a voluntary manufacturer’s warranty doesn’t replace it. For a distance purchase from a retailer, you generally have a 14-day right to cancel, subject to the relevant exceptions.