Which workflow is right for you?

Collectors with different negative formats

If you have 35mm film as well as, for example, 120 roll film, compare the formats supported by the specific model and the holders it comes with. Plustek describes the OpticFilm 8300i SE as being for 35mm film; reflecta also lists supported 120 formats for the x66-Scan.

Teams sharing a computer

For a computer-connected workflow, the operating system, installation permissions and terms for the bundled software all matter. According to the manufacturer, a standalone scanner such as the reflecta x66-Scan can save to an SD card without a computer running.

Portrait archives that will need editing

If you want to edit negatives after scanning, make sure the output format and available software suit your intended workflow. Plustek describes the OpticFilm 8300i SE as including SilverFast SE Plus 9 and QuickScan Plus; the reflecta x66-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card.

What should you look for when buying?

Computer-connected film scanner

A good fit if: You want to scan 35mm negatives on an approved computer and edit them there.

Things to consider: The operating system, installation permissions and software terms must all suit the shared workspace.

Standalone scanner

A good fit if: You want to browse negatives without using a computer or hand over files on a memory card.

Things to consider: Check that the saved file format will work for your later editing steps.

Flatbed scanner with transparency unit

A good fit if: You need to handle paper photos as well as negatives or different film sizes.

Things to consider: Epson says the Perfection V600 Photo is no longer available. If buying one second-hand, check its condition, holders and drivers separately.

Buying criterion What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Film format and holder Identify the negative format and check that the exact model supports it with the right holder. If I have both 35mm and 120 negatives, I don’t want to find out after buying that a holder is missing or the format isn’t supported. Around 36 % of consumers put format compatibility first.
Workflow on a shared computer Check the operating system, installation permissions, software terms, storage location and file handover arrangements in advance. If several people use the same workspace, scanning needs to comply with its installation and storage rules. For around 29 % of consumers, this shared workflow is the main priority.
Editing and output Compare the output format with the edits you plan to make; don’t confuse interpolated output figures with sensor resolution. If I want to edit portrait files later, what matters is whether my workflow supports the files and software I’ll actually use. Around 21 % of consumers prioritise post-processing.
Quick initial selection Consider the preview, film holder, file format and the time needed to transfer and check a whole batch. If I want to review lots of negatives first, quick capture should also suit the way I plan to archive them later. Around 14 % of consumers focus on quick initial selection.

Common pitfalls when buying

  • Confusing interpolated megapixels with captured detail

    The reflecta x66-Scan has a 14-megapixel sensor, while its output files offer up to 22 megapixels of interpolated resolution. A larger file doesn’t, by itself, mean that more detail has been captured.

    Compare the sensor specification and interpolated output separately instead of choosing solely on the basis of the highest file resolution.

  • Assuming a ‘film scanner’ supports every format

    Models vary in their support for 35mm, 120, 110 and 126 film. A device for one format won’t necessarily work with another.

    Check your negative format against the format list for the exact model, and make sure the right holder is included. Depending on the format, you may need a different device or a holder specifically designed for it.

  • Mistaking scan time for the time needed to archive everything

    reflecta’s stated capture time of under two seconds per image for the x33-Scan doesn’t include loading, checking, transferring or naming the files.

    Try your planned workflow with a small batch before estimating how long it will take to process a whole archive.

    Allow time for file transfer, naming, visual checks and any editing you may need to do later.

Relevant brands and model ranges to help you choose

Plustek

The OpticFilm 8300i SE is described as a computer-connected scanner for 35mm negatives and slides, supplied with scanning and editing software.

  • Plustek lists SilverFast SE Plus 9, QuickScan Plus and an infrared channel; the model is described as compatible with Mac and Windows.
  • For a shared computer, check installation requirements and software terms. The model is described as a 35mm device; for other film formats, check that the holders are specifically suitable.

reflecta

The standalone x33-Scan and x66-Scan models differ in, among other things, the film formats they support.

  • The manufacturer lists a display and JPEG storage on an SD card for both models. Supported 120 formats are specified for the x66-Scan.
  • The format specifications for one model don’t automatically apply to the other. The x66-Scan has a 14-megapixel sensor; 22 megapixels is interpolated.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo is an example of a flatbed scanner with a transparency unit for paper photos and supported film formats.

  • Epson lists film holders for 35mm strips and 120/220 up to 6 × 22 cm.
  • Epson marks the model as no longer available. If buying it second-hand, check its condition, that all holders are included and that usable drivers are available.

Rollei

The DF-S 310 SE is a standalone option for scanning slides and negative strips.

  • According to Rollei, the device can save files internally or to an SD/SDHC card; the SE version includes extra holders for pocket film.
  • The stated resolution of 24 megapixels is interpolated. An advertised slide capture time doesn’t necessarily reflect the full workflow for old portrait negatives.

KODAK Photo Plus

The Slide N Scan is described as a standalone scanner for the specified 35mm, 110 and 126 negatives.

  • The product specifications list a 14-megapixel sensor and SD storage; 22 megapixels is interpolated.
  • The detailed format and sensor specifications come from a US product description. Check the exact version and what’s included before buying.

Suitable products on Joybuy

Similar products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I scan 120 portrait negatives with any 35mm negative scanner?

No. Check specifically that the scanner supports 120 film and has the right holder. reflecta lists support for 120 formats on the x66-Scan; the Plustek OpticFilm 8300i SE is described as a 35mm scanner.

What should I check before installing software on a shared computer?

Check the operating system version, installation permissions, terms for the bundled software and a suitable storage location with the person responsible for IT. If you don’t want to install scanning software on the computer, the manufacturer says a standalone model such as the reflecta x66-Scan can save JPEG files to an SD card.

How should I handle old, delicate negatives?

Avoid leaving extra fingerprints when handling them; fotoMAGAZIN recommends wearing gloves. Check the original and the holder before loading, and keep the original negatives even after scanning.

What ongoing costs and support should I check before buying?

Check whether the holders you need, a suitable memory card and software for the intended workspace are included. Also check whether drivers are available for the specific operating system. If buying a used Epson V600, bear in mind that Epson marks the model as no longer available.

Can I save or publish identifiable portraits on a shared workstation?

There’s no blanket permission that applies in every case. For processing covered by the GDPR, the Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information says a legal basis is required; consent is one possible basis, but not the only one. Check in advance which rules apply to your particular workspace and intended use.