Which scanning method is right for you?

Portrait archivists who transfer files frequently

If you regularly edit old negatives on your computer, choosing between a direct computer connection and an SD card will affect your workflow. reflecta says the x66-Scan saves files to an SD card, while Plustek includes a computer and software as part of its scanning workflow. The German Federal Office for Information Security offers practical advice on keeping separate backups.

Owners of mixed film formats

If your portrait archive includes medium-format film as well as 35 mm, check the scan area and the holders available for each format. reflecta lists certain medium-format films as compatible with the x66-Scan, while Epson lists holders for 35 mm and 120/220 film for the Perfection V600 Photo.

Archivists with lots of film strips

If you have a large number of negatives to scan, consider how often you’ll need to load strips or change holders. F.A.Z. Kaufkompass notes the limited batch capacity of the Plustek OpticFilm 135i, while reflecta lists automatic film transport for the RPS 10S.

What should you look for when buying?

Assess the transfer method, film formats, post-processing requirements and strip length separately.

Computer-connected film scanner

Best for: Reviewing and editing 35 mm negatives directly on your computer.

Bear in mind: You’ll need a computer and compatible software. F.A.Z. Kaufkompass says the Plustek OpticFilm 135i can scan a maximum of six frames per pass.

Standalone scanner with SD card

Best for: Reviewing negatives without a computer first, then transferring files in batches later.

Bear in mind: reflecta says the x66-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card. You’ll then need to transfer them and create a separate backup.

Buying criterion What to check Who it matters most to
Transferring and storing files Check whether the scanner works directly with your computer or saves files to a memory card first, and how you’ll organise working files and backups. If I regularly edit scans on my computer, I want to plan for transfers and separate backups from the outset. Around 33% of consumers put frequent transfers and reliable storage first.
Film format and holders Match your negatives’ film type and frame format to the scan area and the holders that actually fit. If my collection includes medium-format film as well as 35 mm, the scanner needs to support those exact formats and the right holders. Around 27% of consumers prioritise format compatibility.
Editing portraits Check which software is included and distinguish the sensor resolution from the interpolated output resolution. For infrared correction, the scanner, software and film type all need to be compatible. For important portraits, I want to check individual scans and only use corrections that are suitable for my originals. Around 20% of consumers prioritise targeted portrait editing.
Scanning lots of strips Compare the stated capacity per pass with the length and condition of your strips. A scan speed figure alone doesn’t tell you everything about the workflow. When I have lots of strips to scan, what matters is how often I have to reload, not just the stated scan time. Around 20% of consumers prioritise throughput.

Which pitfalls should you avoid?

  • Assuming interpolated megapixels mean more image detail has been captured

    For the reflecta x66-Scan, the manufacturer distinguishes between a 14 MP sensor and an interpolated output of 22 MP. The higher output figure doesn’t automatically mean that more image detail has been captured.

    Compare sensor and output resolution separately, then assess the files based on how you intend to edit them.

  • Confusing SD card storage with complete archiving and backup

    With a standalone scanner, files are initially stored on a card. The German Federal Office for Information Security highlights the value of additional backups if files are lost, damaged or accidentally deleted. The European product page for the KODAK SLIDE N SCAN says that an SD card is required separately.

    Before scanning, decide how you’ll transfer and name your files, and how you’ll keep another copy safe.

  • Assuming a scan speed figure tells you how long the whole archive will take

    F.A.Z. Kaufkompass says the Plustek OpticFilm 135i can scan a maximum of six frames per pass. reflecta lists automatic transport for strips containing 3 to 40 frames for the RPS 10S. These figures refer to different devices and don’t cover the entire process of reviewing, correcting and storing your scans.

    Take strip lengths, loading time and your own checking and filing steps into account.

  • Assuming a “film scanner” will handle every type of old negative

    The models described here support different formats. A scanner for 35 mm film won’t automatically support other medium formats.

    Sort your originals by format, then check the scan area and included holders for the specific model.

Which brands are worth considering?

Plustek

Plustek offers computer-connected 35 mm film scanners for different workflows.

  • F.A.Z. Kaufkompass rates the OpticFilm 135i’s scan quality positively.
  • According to F.A.Z. Kaufkompass, the OpticFilm 135i can scan a maximum of one film strip with six frames per pass. Information about the infrared channel and software for the OpticFilm 8300i SE doesn’t automatically apply to this model.

reflecta

The range includes standalone SD card scanners and computer-connected models with film strip transport.

  • reflecta lists 35 mm film and certain 127 and 120 medium-format films as compatible with the x66-Scan. For the RPS 10S, the manufacturer specifies automatic transport for 3 to 40 frames.
  • The x66-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card. Its format compatibility and the RPS 10S’s transport specification relate to different models.

Rollei

The DF-S 310 SE is a standalone scanner with preview and SD/SDHC storage for the originals listed by Rollei.

  • Rollei lists 128 MB of internal storage and support for SD/SDHC cards up to 32 GB.
  • The advertised output of up to 24 MP is interpolated; Rollei lists 14 MP for the lens and capture resolution.

KODAK Photo Plus

The European product page describes the SLIDE N SCAN as a standalone scanner with adapters for the film formats listed there.

  • The European product page lists SD card storage and cable transfer.
  • According to this product page, an SD card is required for operation but isn’t included. This information doesn’t confirm that the same product is available at Joybuy.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo is an example of a flatbed scanner with a transparency unit for film and other originals.

  • Epson lists holders for 35 mm film and 120/220 medium-format film for this model.
  • Epson marks the Perfection V600 Photo as discontinued on its German product page. The model details therefore don’t confirm that it’s currently available to buy new from the manufacturer.

Matching products at Joybuy

Matching products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Is an SD card enough to archive scanned portraits?

No. Plan to make a separate backup after transferring the files. The German Federal Office for Information Security explains that additional copies can help you recover files if they’re lost, damaged or accidentally deleted.

What should I bear in mind when scanning dusty old negatives?

Check the originals and scan results carefully rather than assuming automatic dust correction will be available. Infrared correction requires a compatible scanner and suitable software. Also check that the combination works with your specific film type.

What extra item might you need for a standalone scanner?

Before buying, check whether a memory card and suitable holders are included. The KODAK SLIDE N SCAN described on the European product page requires an SD card to operate, but one isn’t included.

Who should I contact if a scanner bought in Germany is faulty?

Statutory consumer rights generally apply against the seller and are separate from any voluntary guarantee. Verbraucherzentrale explains that repair or replacement are forms of the remedy you can initially request.

Can I share scanned old portraits publicly?

Not simply because you have the negative. Under § 22 KunstUrhG, distributing or publicly displaying a portrait generally requires the consent of the person pictured. After their death, the law sets out conditions under which consent from relatives applies. § 23 KunstUrhG provides exceptions, subject to further limits. Whether a particular portrait can be published depends on the circumstances.