Which film scanner is right for you?

Portrait archivists

If you want to create several versions of a scan for different projects, keep a master separate from your working copies. The Library of Congress recommends a TIFF master and a JPEG working copy; whether a particular scanner can output these formats depends on the model.

Owners of mixed film formats

If you want to digitise roll film or prints as well as 35mm film, make sure the scanner’s supported formats, holders and scanning method suit your collection. reflecta lists formats 120, 127 and 135 for the x66-Scan; Rollei also describes a reflective scanning mode for paper photographs on the PDF-S 240 SE.

Owners of large collections of older film

If you have lots of strips, the feed per pass can affect your workflow: Plustek says the OpticFilm 135i can scan up to six frames from a 35mm strip, while reflecta says the RPS 10S feeds longer strips automatically. The right way to correct visible marks also depends on the film type.

What should you look for when choosing?

What you need What to check before buying Who should pay particular attention?
Master file and project versions Check the output format and software for the specific combination of scanner and software. The Library of Congress recommends a TIFF master and a JPEG working copy; DNG is not automatically equivalent to TIFF. If I want to create several colour, contrast or crop versions from one original scan, I want to keep the master separate. Around 36% of consumers put this versioning workflow first.
Film format and holder Check the film type, frame dimensions and required holders against the model. Plustek lists the OpticFilm 135i for 35mm film; reflecta lists formats 120, 127 and 135 for the x66-Scan. If you own roll film as well as 35mm film, check compatibility before buying. Around 29% of consumers give the greatest importance to compatible film formats and holders.
Dust, scratches and film type Identify the film type and test the correction method with a sample scan. SilverFast advises against infrared-based dust and scratch correction on silver-based black-and-white negatives. If visible marks on old portraits bother me, I want to know which correction method is suitable for the material. Around 21% of consumers prioritise removing this kind of damage.
Time needed for a large collection Compare the maximum strip length, number of frames per pass and any manual steps. reflecta says the RPS 10S automatically feeds strips with up to 40 frames; Plustek describes a batch mode for up to six frames from a 35mm strip or four slides on the OpticFilm 135i. If I have a large collection, I want to get a good idea of how often I’ll need to reload the scanner. Around 14% of consumers put throughput first.

What pitfalls should you watch out for?

  • Confusing interpolated pixel counts with extra captured detail

    For the reflecta x66-Scan, the manufacturer distinguishes between a 14-megapixel sensor and an interpolated output of 22 megapixels. The higher output pixel count does not mean the sensor captures proportionally more image information.

    Check the sensor or optical specifications separately from interpolated output figures. Also check the film format and the file format you need.

  • Assuming infrared correction works with every old film

    SilverFast advises against using the infrared function on silver-based black-and-white negatives. Automatic correction is therefore not suitable for every type of film, and manual retouching may be needed.

    Check the film type and test the appropriate correction method on a sample.

  • Assuming support for different formats means support for master files

    According to the manufacturer, the reflecta x66-Scan supports several film formats but saves directly as JPEG. That alone doesn’t prove it can support the master-file workflow you want.

    If you want to edit several versions later, check the output format and required software separately from the scanner’s format compatibility.

Key brands at a glance

Plustek

The OpticFilm 135i is a dedicated scanner for 35mm film.

  • Plustek says it can scan up to six frames from a film strip or four slides per pass.
  • 120 film is not listed as compatible with this model; according to the manufacturer, a holder for panoramic film is available as an optional extra.

reflecta

The RPS 10S and x66-Scan cater for different film formats and workflows.

  • For the RPS 10S, reflecta lists automatic feed for 35mm strips with up to 40 frames and DNG output. The x66-Scan supports film formats 120, 127 and 135.
  • According to the manufacturer, the x66-Scan saves directly as JPEG; its stated 22-megapixel output is interpolated.

Rollei

According to Rollei, the PDF-S 240 SE scans slides and negatives, and also has a mode for paper photographs.

  • The product description says it can scan without a computer and has a reflective scanning mode for photographs up to 13 × 18 cm.
  • The pixel count details on the product page are inconsistent; confirm the resolution for the specific version of the scanner before buying.

Epson

The Perfection V850 Pro is a point of comparison for flatbed scanners with film holders, including for medium format.

  • Epson lists holders for 35mm and 120/220 film, as well as TIFF output, for this model.
  • Epson marks the Perfection V850 Pro as discontinued, so it is not a confirmed recommendation for a new scanner currently available to buy.

Joybuy products

Relevant products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

How do I create several versions of the same portrait?

Keep a master separate from your working copies and create project versions from copies. The Library of Congress recommends a TIFF master and a JPEG working copy; check separately whether your chosen scanner can output these formats directly.

Can I use infrared dust removal on old black-and-white negatives?

SilverFast advises against using it on silver-based black-and-white negatives. Check the film type and, instead, try suitable software or manual retouching on a sample scan.

What should I check for panoramic film strips with the Plustek OpticFilm 135i?

Plustek lists an optional holder for panoramic film. Check whether you need one for your originals and whether it’s included in the specific offer.

What legal guarantee applies when buying from a business seller?

According to consumer information from the European Union, you’re entitled to a legal guarantee of at least two years from the date you receive the goods. This is separate from any additional manufacturer’s guarantee; the same rules do not apply in the same way to purchases from private individuals.

Can I publish scanned portraits in Germany?

Scanning a portrait for private use and displaying it publicly are two different matters. Under § 22 KunstUrhG, the consent of the person shown is generally required to distribute or publicly display a portrait. Whether an exception or another legal basis applies in a particular case depends on how you plan to use it.