Who are the different film scanners for?

Landscape photographers with 35 mm negatives

If you want to view and edit selected 35 mm shots on your home computer, compare the file workflow and the level of detail you can actually use. Plustek lists the OpticFilm 8300i SE as a scanner for 35 mm film.

Photographers with a mix of film formats

If your archive includes 120 landscape negatives as well as 35 mm film, check that the specific format and the right holder are supported before comparing resolution figures. Plustek lists certain 120 formats for the OpticFilm 120 Pro; Epson also describes a holder for 120/220 film for the V600 Photo, although the model is listed as no longer available in Germany.

Photographers with lots of film strips

If you want to scan large numbers of compatible negatives, weigh up automatic film transport against a simpler JPEG and SD card workflow. reflecta describes these features across different models.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start with the film format and the right holder. Then consider your preferred file workflow, how much scope you need for editing and the effort involved when scanning larger quantities.

What matters What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Detail and editing Check the file formats and software for the specific model. Also find out whether the resolution figure is interpolated or calculated on a different basis. If I want to carefully edit selected landscape shots on my computer, I need a file and software workflow that’s up to the job. Around 36% of consumers prioritise detail and editing flexibility.
Negative format and holder Compare the format and dimensions of your negatives with the formats explicitly supported by the exact model and its compatible holder. If my archive contains negatives in different formats, I want to be sure that each one is supported and that I have the right holder. Around 29% of consumers place the greatest importance on format compatibility.
From negative to file Check direct saving, the output format, the storage medium required and how files are transferred. For a PC model, also check the computer and software requirements. If a simple way to create files that I can view and transfer matters more to me than extensive editing, I look for direct output. Around 21% of consumers consider a straightforward file workflow their top priority.
Effort involved with lots of negatives Check for automatic film transport and the supported strip length. The manufacturer’s scan time refers to the scanning process, not necessarily the entire workflow. If I have lots of film strips, I want to minimise manual feeding and keep the overall workload in mind. Around 14% of consumers prioritise throughput.

Which mistakes should you avoid?

  • Assuming interpolated pixels represent captured detail

    For the x44-Scan, reflecta distinguishes between an image resolution of 4.920 × 3.280 pixels and an interpolated resolution of 6.000 × 4.000 pixels. The higher figure is therefore based on a different method.

    Compare how the resolution is stated and consider whether the output suits your intended use, rather than focusing only on the largest figure.

  • Assuming “film scanner” means it supports medium format

    The documented models support different types of film: the OpticFilm 8300i SE is specified for 35 mm film, while Plustek lists certain 120 formats as supported by the OpticFilm 120 Pro too.

    Identify the dimensions of your negatives and check them against the formats supported by the specific model and its holder.

  • Assuming JPEG capture is the same as a DNG workflow

    reflecta lists JPEG saving to an SD card for the x44-Scan, while the RPS 10S is specified as offering DNG output. These are different documented file workflows.

    Before you buy, decide whether simple files for viewing are enough or whether you want files you can edit later.

  • Assuming infrared dust correction works with all black-and-white film

    ILFORD explains that Digital ICE does not work with conventional black-and-white film. ILFORD names XP2S, a black-and-white film processed using a colour process, as an exception that can use infrared correction.

    Identify your film type. For conventional black-and-white film, plan a scanning workflow without infrared correction; you may need to remove dust manually.

Key brands at a glance

Plustek

Plustek lists the OpticFilm 8300i SE for computer-connected 35 mm scanning and the OpticFilm 120 Pro as a separate model for 35 mm and certain 120 formats.

  • Supported formats, software and resolution specifications vary by model. For the OpticFilm 120 Pro, Plustek lists 120 formats from 6 × 4,5 to 6 × 12 cm.
  • Manufacturer claims about quality and speed are not independent test results. For the 8300i SE, Plustek quotes a scan time of around 20 seconds at 3.600 dpi without infrared scanning, and 40 seconds with it.

reflecta

For the RPS 10S, reflecta describes a computer-connected 35 mm workflow with film transport and DNG output. The x44-Scan and x33-Scan are standalone models with 35 mm and JPEG workflows.

  • For the RPS 10S, reflecta lists transport for strips containing 3 to 40 frames. The x44-Scan is described as saving JPEGs to an SD card and transferring them via USB.
  • The advertised interpolated resolution of the x44-Scan should not be confused with its stated image resolution. Features vary between models and are not interchangeable.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo is a flatbed model for which Epson Germany documents holders for 35 mm and 120/220 film.

  • The model specifications list TIFF output and Digital ICE.
  • Epson Germany lists the V600 Photo as no longer available. Information about this model does not confirm current availability or show whether other Epson scanners are suitable for film.

KODAK

The KODAK website describes the SLIDE N SCAN product range for the film formats listed there: 135, 110 and 126.

  • The website lists different display options and identifies C+A Global as the manufacturer and seller under licence.
  • According to KODAK, the products are not available in every country. The listed formats do not confirm support for 120 film.

Matching products on Joybuy

Related products will be available soon.

Film scanner FAQs

Should I identify the size of my negatives before buying?

Yes, because supported formats vary by model. The OpticFilm 8300i SE is specified for 35 mm film, while according to Plustek, the OpticFilm 120 Pro also supports certain 120 formats. Make sure the holder is suitable for your negatives too.

Can I use infrared dust correction with conventional black-and-white negatives?

ILFORD explains that Digital ICE does not work with conventional black-and-white film, so plan a workflow without infrared correction for this film type. ILFORD names XP2S, a black-and-white film processed using a colour process, as an exception that can use infrared correction.

What should I check when setting up a PC scanner?

Check the operating system, USB connection, storage space and supplied software against the requirements for the exact model. Plustek lists these requirements explicitly for the OpticFilm 8300i SE.

What should I check about film holders, software and support?

Check that the film holders you need and the recommended scanning software are suitable for the specific model and your workflow. Also look at the support information for that model and check which storage media or archiving steps you’ll need for your scans.