Which film scanner is right for you?

Portrait archive with working copies

If you want to edit old scans later, keep an unchanged original file and create separate working copies from it. The Library of Congress recommends saving edited digital photos in two versions.

Owners of mixed film formats

If you have other film sizes as well as 35 mm portraits, check that the format and holders actually supplied are suitable for the specific device. Manufacturer information from Plustek, reflecta, KODAK Photo Plus and Epson Deutschland lists different supported formats.

Owners of large collections of old film strips

For larger collections, the number of images each holder can accommodate may affect your workflow. Plustek says the OpticFilm 135i can handle up to six strip images per pass; the F.A.Z. Kaufkompass also notes this capacity limit.

What should you look for when buying?

Buying consideration What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Original files and working copies Check the output format and software for the specific version. Plan to keep an unchanged file, create working copies from it and make additional backups. If I want to edit portraits later, I want to keep the original scan file separate. Around 36% of consumers say file versions are their top buying consideration.
Film format and holder Compare the film type and image size with the scan area and what’s included with the exact model. If my archive contains different film sizes, I need suitable holders rather than just a resolution figure. Film compatibility is the top priority for around 29% of consumers.
Throughput for large numbers of images Check how many suitable images fit in a single holder pass. Also allow for loading, checking and organising files. If I have a lot of strips to process, I want to minimise repeated handling without assuming that the total time needed to archive them is the same as the scan time per image. Around 21% of consumers prioritise throughput.
Film condition and correction Take the film type and condition into account, and test correction features on a representative image. If my originals are delicate or visibly damaged, I want to handle them carefully and assess potential corrections for the specific film material. Around 14% of consumers put film condition first.

Common misconceptions when buying a film scanner

  • A higher megapixel count automatically means more image detail

    For the reflecta x66-Scan, reflecta distinguishes between a 14 MP sensor and an interpolated 22 MP output. The higher output figure alone therefore doesn’t prove that the sensor has captured more image detail.

    Compare sensor or optical specifications separately from interpolated output figures, and consider the film format and how you plan to use the scans.

  • JPEG on an SD card is the same as a TIFF master created directly by the scanner

    The Library of Congress recommends keeping a master and a working copy of edited digital photos. A documented JPEG output to an SD card isn’t automatically a TIFF scan of the original.

    Decide which original file format you need before buying, and check the scanning workflow for the exact device configuration. If you need a TIFF scan of the original, you may need an additional scanning or archiving step.

  • Multi-format advertising means the right holder is included

    The devices mentioned support different film sizes; the format information alone doesn’t tell you which holders are included.

    Compare an original negative with the stated scan area, and check which holders are included or need to be bought separately. If you need an additional holder, you’ll have another purchase to make.

  • An older product specification confirms that a product is currently available

    Epson Deutschland marks the Perfection V850 Pro as “No longer available”, even though technical product information is still available.

    Use the specification to assess the flatbed option, but check any specific listing and the accessories included separately.

Key brands at a glance

Plustek

The OpticFilm 135i is a computer-connected option for 35 mm strips and slides.

  • Plustek specifies an infrared channel and capacity for up to six strip images or four mounted slides per holder pass.
  • The F.A.Z. Kaufkompass rates the scan quality of the 135i it tested positively, but notes limitations with very large collections and that some scans can look rather flat. This assessment doesn’t automatically apply to other OpticFilm models.

reflecta

The x66-Scan is a stand-alone option for certain 35 mm, 120 and 127 formats.

  • According to reflecta, the device saves JPEG files directly to an SD card and is supplied with several film holders.
  • reflecta distinguishes between a 14 MP sensor and interpolated 22 MP files; direct TIFF output isn’t confirmed.

KODAK Photo Plus

The European 5-inch version of the SLIDE N SCAN is designed for simple, stand-alone viewing of certain small film formats.

  • The European product page lists adapters for 135, 110 and 126 film, as well as storage on an SD card.
  • An SD card is required but not included. The formats listed don’t confirm support for 120 roll film, and similarly named display versions aren’t necessarily identical.

Epson

The Perfection V850 Pro is a documented example of a flatbed film scanner with holders for 35 mm film and larger originals.

  • Epson Deutschland lists TIFF output and holders for 120/220 film up to 6 × 20 cm.
  • Epson Deutschland lists the model as “No longer available”, so the technical information doesn’t confirm that it can currently be bought.

Suitable products on Joybuy

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

How do I create an original file and separate working copies?

Save the first scan unchanged and edit only a file created from it. For edited digital photos, the Library of Congress recommends keeping a TIFF master and a JPEG working copy. This is an archiving recommendation, not a legal requirement for scanners. Also back up important files to different storage media and in separate locations.

Can infrared automatically remove dust from silver-based black-and-white portraits?

Don’t assume that it can: according to LaserSoft Imaging, infrared light doesn’t pass through the emulsion of silver-based black-and-white film in the same way as it does with suitable colour film. Software-based correction and careful handling of the film are other options to consider.

What accessories and ongoing costs should I check?

Check which film holders are included and how much storage you’ll need. The required SD card isn’t included with the European KODAK SLIDE N SCAN with a 5-inch display; the reflecta x66-Scan is designed to save files to an SD card. You’ll also need suitable storage media of your own for separate backups.

Can I publish scanned old portraits in Germany?

Making a private working copy isn’t the same as publishing an image. Under § 22 KunstUrhG, portraits may generally only be distributed or publicly displayed with the consent of the person depicted. After that person’s death, consent from relatives is relevant under the conditions set out in the law. Whether exceptions, other rights or data protection rules apply in a specific case depends, among other things, on the image and how you plan to use it.