Which scanner is right for you?

Owners of hardback journals

If you want to capture text close to the spine without pressing the book flat, look for a book edge and a suitable lid. Plustek lists these features for the OpticBook 3800L; Canon says the LiDE 400 has a Z-hinge for thicker originals.

Collectors of photographs and keepsake pages

If your journals include photographs, drawings or colourful inserts, compare the colour and image options for the originals you plan to scan. Canon and Epson both list photo- or image-editing features for their respective models.

Owners of large-format travel journals

If open pages or glued-in maps are larger than A4, the scanning area should be big enough to accommodate them. Plustek lists a maximum scanning area of 297 × 431.8 mm for the OpticSlim 1180.

What should you look for when buying?

Compact A4 flatbed scanner

A good fit if: Your pages fit on the A4 scanning area and can lie sufficiently flat without pressing them down hard.

Trade-off: You have to reposition every bound page; a Z-hinge does not mean the scanner has a dedicated book-edge feature.

Book-edge scanner

A good fit if: You often scan tightly bound journals and want to capture text close to the spine. Plustek describes the OpticBook 3800L as having a 6 mm book edge.

Trade-off: Check the exact model version, software, operating system support and space required.

A3 flatbed scanner

A good fit if: Pages or inserts are too large for an A4 scanning area. According to the manufacturer, the European OpticSlim 1180 from Plustek has a maximum scanning area of 297 × 431.8 mm.

Trade-off: Plustek lists a footprint of 589 × 407 mm for this model; a larger scanning area alone will not solve the problem of scanning close to the spine.

Flatbed scanner with an automatic document feeder

A good fit if: You regularly scan loose sheets as well as your journal. HP combines a flatbed with a feeder in the ScanJet Pro 2600 f1.

Trade-off: Bound pages belong on the flatbed, not in the feeder; the extra feature may be unnecessary if you only scan journals.

Criterion What to check when buying Who will find this especially important?
Book spine and positioning Check for a book edge and how the lid moves with the journal you plan to scan; a Z-hinge is not the same as a book edge. If I scan tightly bound pages, I want to capture text close to the spine without putting too much pressure on it. Around 36% of consumers put the book spine first for this reason.
Colours and photographs Test colour scanning, output formats and image options using a representative page. If I want to preserve photographs, drawings and colourful entries, I look for suitable colour and image features. Around 29% of consumers prioritise colours and photographs.
Scanning area Measure the largest page or insert and compare it with the stated scanning area; according to the manufacturer, the Canon LiDE 400 offers 216 × 297 mm. If an open page or glued-in map is larger than A4, I want to capture as much of it as possible in one scan. Around 21% of consumers prioritise size for this reason.
Workflow Check multi-page PDF support, scan buttons, file formats and operating system support for the exact model; test OCR on handwriting yourself. If I have lots of pages as well as loose receipts to scan, I want to make the scans easier to organise and process. Around 14% of consumers focus on workflow.

Common buying misconceptions

  • Assuming a lift-up lid is the same as a book edge

    A lift-up lid creates space for thicker originals; a book edge is a separate design feature that helps you position a book close to the spine. They are not interchangeable.

    Check for both features separately and, if possible, test a representative page from your journal.

    Poor scans around the spine may mean rescanning or extra editing.

  • Taking the quoted scan speed as the time needed to scan a finished journal page

    Canon’s speed claim for the LiDE 400 is based on specified scanning conditions and does not include data transfer. It therefore does not reflect the complete process of scanning a bound journal.

    Compare the full process on a few typical pages, including positioning, turning and checking each page.

    You will also need to allow extra time to organise the files.

  • Assuming an A4 scanner can handle larger inserts

    According to Canon, the scanning area of the Canon LiDE 400 is 216 × 297 mm. The Plustek OpticSlim 1180 offers a larger area, but the manufacturer lists its footprint as 589 × 407 mm.

    Measure your largest original and the space available on your desk before choosing a scanner.

    If an original does not fit on the scanning area, you may need to scan it in sections and stitch the images together.

Key brands at a glance

Canon

The CanoScan LiDE 400 and LiDE 300 are A4 flatbed scanners for photographs and documents.

  • Canon lists USB power, a Z-hinge and a scanning area of 216 × 297 mm for the LiDE 400.
  • The Z-hinge makes it easier to scan thicker originals, but it does not mean the scanner has a dedicated book-edge feature; the A4 scanning area limits the size of inserts.

Epson

The Perfection V39II is designed for compact A4 scans of photographs and documents.

  • Epson lists USB power, an integrated stand and image-editing options for the V39II.
  • Details for the older V39 do not automatically apply to the V39II.

Plustek

OpticBook models are designed for bound originals, while the OpticSlim 1180 offers a larger scanning area for A3 originals.

  • Plustek describes the OpticBook 3800L as having a 6 mm book edge and software for book pages. For the European OpticSlim 1180, the manufacturer lists a maximum scanning area of 297 × 431.8 mm.
  • These features apply to the specific models listed. Plustek gives the OpticSlim 1180 a footprint of 589 × 407 mm.

HP

The ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 combines a flatbed for bound originals with a feeder for loose documents.

  • HP lists a flatbed and a 60-sheet feeder.
  • The feeder speed does not reflect the page-by-page process of scanning a bound journal.

Avision

The FB10 is a slim A4 flatbed option with a lift-up lid for thicker originals.

  • Avision lists USB power and a lift-up lid.
  • The European product page lists Windows versions up to Windows 10 under system requirements. Check compatibility with your specific system before installation.

Joybuy products for this selection

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Is a standard A4 flatbed scanner suitable for a bound travel journal?

Yes, if each page fits on the scanning area and can lie sufficiently flat without being pressed down hard. For text close to a tight spine, a dedicated book edge is a better fit; a lift-up lid alone does not provide this feature. Canon lists a Z-hinge for the LiDE 400, while Plustek describes the OpticBook 3800L as having a book edge.

How should I scan photographs, glued-in receipts and lots of pages?

First, measure your largest original and test colour scanning, output format and page sorting on a representative page. Scan bound pages on the flatbed; an automatic feeder is an extra option for suitable loose sheets, not pages in a book.

What should I look for in the software and when maintaining my scanner?

Check that drivers are available for your specific operating system and that the scanner supports the file formats you need. Keep the glass and originals clean for repeat scans, and do not rely on OCR for handwritten entries without testing it first.

What are my rights when shopping online in Germany?

According to information from the Verbraucherzentrale, online purchases generally come with a 14-day right to cancel from the date the contract is made or the ordered goods are received; you must notify the seller that you wish to cancel. If goods are faulty, the seller is generally responsible for the statutory guarantee, which is separate from any voluntary manufacturer’s warranty.

Can I scan a travel journal containing someone else’s copyrighted material and share the file?

Making a private copy does not automatically give you the right to share someone else’s copyrighted material. Section 53 of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) allows private copies only under the conditions set out there and generally prohibits their distribution or public communication; additional restrictions apply to copies of substantially complete books belonging to others. The wording of the Copyright Act is authoritative.