Which scanners are right for different needs?

Preserving delicate letters

If letters are folded, torn or otherwise delicate, how the original is handled should be the main consideration when choosing a scanner. The Library of Congress recommends checking that originals can be handled safely before starting a digitisation process.

Family archive with hard-to-read handwriting

If you want to check handwriting and faint contrast on screen later, choose scan settings to suit both the original and how you plan to use it. The Federal Archives points out that the intended use is key when choosing a resolution.

Home office with limited space or lots of documents

If space is limited, consider the footprint, connection and set-up on your computer. If you also have lots of sturdy, standard-sized sheets to scan, an automatic document feeder may be worth considering. Assess family letters separately, based on their condition.

What should you look for when buying?

Compact USB flatbed scanner

Suitable if: You scan individual letters and have a small workspace. The Canon CanoScan LiDE 300 and LiDE 400, as well as the Epson Perfection V39II, are examples of this type of scanner.

Trade-off: Each page has to be placed on the scanner individually and may need turning over. Manufacturer scan times don’t reflect the whole process.

Flatbed for different types of original

Suitable if: Your collection includes originals of varying thicknesses that can be placed safely on the scanner. According to the manufacturer, the lid on the Avision FB10 can be raised.

Trade-off: A movable lid doesn’t remove the need to check whether a delicate or damaged original can be handled safely.

Flatbed with automatic document feeder

Suitable if: As well as family letters, you regularly scan lots of sturdy sheets that are suitable for the feeder. The HP ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 combines a flatbed with a 60-sheet feeder.

Trade-off: The feeder is designed for suitable stacks of paper – it’s not a reason to feed fragile letters through it.

What matters What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Capturing originals with care Check the condition, folds and size of the letters, as well as the scanning area and lid movement on the specific model. If letters are delicate or torn, I want to place them on the scanner as carefully as possible. Around 36% of consumers who prioritise gentle handling are likely to share this concern.
Saving handwriting so it’s easy to read Distinguish between optical resolution and the scan setting you choose. Test a page with fine handwriting in the view you plan to use. If I want to read faint writing and small details later, I need settings that suit my original. Around 29% of consumers say readability is their top priority.
Time needed for lots of pages Consider the number and condition of the pages separately. Compare speed figures only when you also know the scan mode and test conditions. If I have lots of pages, I want to allow time for positioning, turning over and checking each one. Around 21% of consumers prioritise the time and effort involved.
Space and computer connection Check the footprint, including when the lid is open, the connection type and support for your operating system. If desk space is tight, I want to know whether the scanner and connection will work in my workspace. Around 14% of consumers say fitting a scanner into their workspace is their top priority.

The percentages indicate which consideration is the main priority for consumers choosing a scanner for family letters. They offer a rough guide for this particular use case.

Which common mistakes should you avoid?

  • Treating the highest dpi figure as the only proof of quality

    A scanner’s optical resolution, the resolution you choose for a scan and how you plan to use it are all different things. A high resolution figure in the specifications doesn’t guarantee that fine writing will be easier to read on every original.

    Scan a typical letter using your intended settings, then check the writing in the view you’ll use for the file later.

    Unsuitable settings can mean having to scan again and ending up with unnecessarily large files.

  • Confusing manufacturer scan times with the time it takes to create a finished letter archive

    A stated scan time refers to a particular scanning operation. It doesn’t automatically include positioning, turning over, checking and naming the files.

    Try the whole process with a few different letters rather than comparing seconds alone.

    You’ll also need to allow time for positioning, turning over, checking and naming the files.

  • Feeding old letters through the scanner just because it can scan a stack quickly

    An automatic document feeder isn’t suitable for every original. Handling can be crucial when documents are fragile, torn or awkwardly folded.

    Assess delicate items individually and use the feeder only for suitable, sturdy documents.

Which brands are worth considering?

Canon

The CanoScan LiDE 300 and LiDE 400 are compact A4 flatbed scanners for individual documents and photos.

  • Canon Germany lists USB-C, a stand and an optical resolution of 4,800 × 4,800 dpi for the LiDE 400; the LiDE 300 is listed with USB Mini-B and 2,400 × 2,400 dpi.
  • The stated scan times apply under specific conditions and don’t tell you how long it takes to capture a family letter from start to finish.

Epson

The Perfection V39II is an A4 flatbed scanner for documents and photos, with an integrated stand.

  • Epson lists USB power, a space-saving design and software features for image correction.
  • You’ll need to decide whether the stand and automatic corrections are right for a particular historical original.

Avision

The FB10 is a slim A4 flatbed scanner with a lid that can be raised.

  • Avision lists an optical resolution of 1,200 dpi, USB power and software for cropping several small originals.
  • Manufacturer claims about speed and quality aren’t an independent assessment using old letters. A raised lid doesn’t prove that damaged originals can be scanned safely.

HP

The ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 combines an automatic document feeder with a flatbed.

  • HP says the feeder holds 60 sheets. The stated maximum optical resolution is 600 dpi with the feeder and 1,200 dpi on the flatbed.
  • The feeder isn’t a reason to put fragile letters through it. Assess whether each original is suitable separately.

Joybuy products

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Should I always use the highest available resolution for family letters?

No. Choose a setting based on the size of the original and how you’ll use it later, and check a test page. The Federal Archives gives 400 ppi as a general guideline for digitisation projects it commissions, not as a mandatory setting for private family letters. Also distinguish between optical resolution and resolutions that are merely selectable.

Can I put old letters through an automatic document feeder to scan them faster?

Not in every case. Check the condition of each original. For fragile, torn or awkwardly folded items, handling them with care should come first. A feeder is mainly intended for sturdy sheets that are suitable for it.

What should I check when setting up and using my scanner?

On the manufacturer’s support page, select the operating system you actually use and check which software and drivers are available for it. After scanning, check that the front and back are legible, correctly aligned and complete before saving the files.

Do I have to throw away paper letters after scanning them?

No. In the context of public authorities, the Federal Archives distinguishes between supplementary and replacement scanning. These rules aren’t instructions to dispose of private family letters. If an original is unique, don’t treat digitising it as a substitute for keeping it.

Does the GDPR apply as soon as I scan family letters for personal use?

The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information describes an exception to the GDPR for processing personal data solely in a personal or family context. This doesn’t automatically apply if you later publish the letters online, as other people’s rights may also be relevant.