Which scanner is right for you?

For those preserving delicate originals

If you’re digitising old letters, photos or bound keepsakes, first check whether they can lie flat without being pressed down. The U.S. National Archives and Records Administration warns against feeding fragile or valuable papers through an automatic document feeder.

For teachers with limited desk space

When scanning individual items in a small room, consider not only the scanner’s footprint but also the space needed to open the lid and whether the connection works with your computer. Epson says the Perfection V39II can be set up using its built-in stand, which may save desk space.

For those creating searchable family archives

If you want to find documents quickly later, check in advance that the file format and text recognition fit your workflow. For personal documents, you should also decide where the files will be stored and who will have access to them.

What should you look for?

Start by deciding what you’ll actually be scanning and how much space the scanner, document and open lid will take up together.

Priority What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Protect delicate originals Check the usable scanning area and how the document sits on it; don’t force bound items to lie flat. If I’m scanning old letters, photos or bound keepsakes, I want to be able to place them on the scanner without pressing them down. Around 29% of consumers put protecting delicate originals first.
Space and connection Check the footprint, how the lid opens, the USB connection and whether drivers are available for your computer. If you work in a small classroom, you need room for both the scanner and the documents, as well as a connection that works with your computer. Around 24% of consumers put space and connectivity first.
Find documents again Check that the supported file formats and text recognition work with your operating system; try a sample scan. If I’m building a family archive, I want to be able to find files later by searching their contents. Around 18% of consumers prioritise being able to find files again.
Keep personal data under control Decide where files will be stored and who will receive them; if a school is processing them, check the relevant requirements. If you’re digitising personal documents, you’ll want to decide in advance who receives the files and where they’re stored. Around 18% of consumers make controlling how data is shared their top priority.
Scan suitable stacks of paper Consider how often you’ll scan loose sheets and what condition they’re in; check the feeder capacity of the specific model. If you regularly have large numbers of sturdy loose sheets to scan, a feeder can save you from placing each one on the scanner individually. Around 11% of consumers put batch scanning first.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Assuming an automatic document feeder is suitable for all family papers

    Fragile, creased or valuable sheets can be damaged in a feeder. The U.S. National Archives and Records Administration warns that such papers may jam or tear.

    Check each original individually. Separate suitable loose sheets from delicate items that need to be handled carefully on the flatbed.

  • Assuming a lift-up lid means every album can be scanned safely

    A lift-up lid doesn’t automatically increase the usable glass area or allow a book to be opened without putting pressure on its binding.

    Check the document against the scanning area. Don’t force a fragile bound item to lie flat.

  • Choosing a scanner based only on its highest advertised dpi figure

    The resolution figure alone won’t tell you whether the scanner is suitable for your document, the output you want or your software. The German Federal Archives also distinguishes between ppi as a scanning resolution and dpi in the context of printing.

    First decide what you need the scan for, check that the software is suitable and review a sample page before choosing a setting.

  • Sending scans to cloud or shared locations without a plan

    Family papers may contain personal information or images of identifiable people. A convenient send function doesn’t, by itself, mean that sharing a particular file is permitted.

    Decide where the files will be stored and who will receive them in advance. If a school or another organisation is processing the data, check the requirements that apply to your situation.

Key brands at a glance

Canon

Canon describes the CanoScan LiDE 400 as an A4 flatbed scanner for individual documents and photos.

  • Canon lists a scanning area of 216 × 297 mm, USB-C power, PDF buttons and a Z-lid design.
  • Check that your specific document fits on the scanner and that the open lid will fit in your available space.

Epson

The Perfection V39II is an A4 flatbed scanner for photos and documents. Epson also describes a space-saving setup using its stand.

  • Epson lists USB power and four buttons.
  • A high dpi figure alone won’t tell you whether your document will sit properly on the scanner or whether the software will work with your classroom computer.

Avision

The FB10 is an A4 flatbed scanner. Its lift-up lid may be worth considering for suitable, sturdy, thicker documents.

  • Avision lists a scanning area of 210 × 297 mm and USB power.
  • A lift-up lid doesn’t automatically make fragile items or bindings that are difficult to open suitable for scanning on a flatbed.

HP

HP says the ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 combines a flatbed with an automatic document feeder for suitable loose sheets.

  • HP lists a 60-sheet feeder, double-sided scanning and OCR features.
  • The feeder isn’t designed for fragile or valuable papers; the U.S. National Archives and Records Administration warns that such documents may be damaged.

Joybuy products for this task

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Is an A4 scanning area large enough for family papers?

Only if the entire document fits on the usable scanning area. Canon lists the LiDE 400 at 216 × 297 mm, while Avision lists the FB10 at 210 × 297 mm. Remember to allow for any margins you want to keep, and don’t press delicate parts that stick out under the lid.

Can I press an old photo album flat to scan it?

Not if that would put strain on the binding or pages. The U.S. National Archives and Records Administration recommends photographing books from above using a suitable support, rather than forcing them flat to use a flatbed scanner. A flatbed may be suitable for sturdy documents that can lie reasonably flat.

How can I check the setup and ongoing workload?

Before buying, check the manufacturer’s downloads for the operating system you’ll actually be using, and allow time for naming files, checking the results and backing them up. Canon and Epson have support pages for specific models. With Epson Support, you need to select your operating system manually.

Can personal family papers be scanned and shared in the classroom?

Having a scanner doesn’t in itself give you permission to process or publish personal information. If a school or another organisation responsible for the data processes personal information, it needs an applicable legal basis. Consent is one option, but it isn’t automatically the only one. If photos show identifiable people, digitising them and publishing them later should be considered separately. Further requirements may depend on the organisation responsible, the location and the details of the classroom project.