If you share your desk
If you share your desk with someone else and want to put the stick away after flying, compare desktop models and how much space they take up. A compact design alone doesn’t tell you how noisy the controls are.
If you regularly need to clear your desk in a shared bedroom, a single desktop stick with a throttle control is a space-saving place to start. If you often make throttle adjustments with both hands, a HOTAS with a separate throttle may suit the way you play better. Before buying, check platform compatibility, your simulator’s control assignments and whether you have room for both units. The information available about the models mentioned here isn’t enough to reliably determine which one is quieter.
If you share your desk with someone else and want to put the stick away after flying, compare desktop models and how much space they take up. A compact design alone doesn’t tell you how noisy the controls are.
If you want to map pitch, roll and rudder controls accurately for simulated mountain routes, check which axes are available and how they can be assigned in your simulator. The Microsoft Flight Simulator team says hardware choice depends on factors including the space you have and your simulation needs.
If you want to control the throttle with your other hand, compare what’s included and how much space a HOTAS needs against a standalone stick. The Thrustmaster T.16000M FCS and T.16000M FCS HOTAS models differ in this respect, too: the latter includes a throttle control.
A good fit if: you have limited desk space or want to put the device away after flying.
The trade-off: Throttle control is on the stick or its base rather than on a separate lever.
A good fit if: you often want to operate the stick and throttle with both hands, and have room for two units.
The trade-off: You’ll need extra desk space for the stick and throttle while playing.
A good fit if: you want to choose the mechanism and grip to suit your preferences.
The trade-off: The VIRPIL WarBRD-D is a base on its own, so you’ll need to buy a compatible grip separately.
The Microsoft Flight Simulator team cites available space and simulation needs as factors in choosing hardware. Manufacturer specifications show that the models use different control layouts, but don’t establish which is quieter.
| What matters to you | What to check before buying | Who is this important to? |
|---|---|---|
| Desk space and consideration for others | Measure the space on your desk and think about where you’ll put the stick and cables when you’ve finished playing. Don’t assume that the design tells you how noisy the controls are. | If I share my desk with someone, I want to be able to set the device up and put it away easily. Around 31% of consumers put desk space and consideration for others first. |
| Controllable axes | Check the rudder’s twist axis, centring and the assignment options in your simulator. | If I want precise control of pitch, roll and rudder on winding routes, I pay particular attention to the axes and how they can be assigned. Around 25% of consumers prioritise axis control. |
| Throttle control | Compare a throttle wheel on the stick with a separate lever, and check exactly what’s included in the box. | If I want to operate the throttle with my other hand, I’m happy to make room for an extra unit on my desk if needed. Around 25% of consumers prioritise a separate throttle. |
| Platform compatibility | Check the exact console or PC, game and model version you’ll be using. | If I’m looking for a stick for my current setup, I want to confirm it supports my specific platform before buying. Around 19% of consumers put platform compatibility first. |
The Thrustmaster T.16000M FCS and T.16000M FCS HOTAS are different bundles. According to Thrustmaster, the HOTAS includes a TWCS throttle.
Check the full list of what’s included rather than relying on the shared part of the model name.
If you need a separate throttle, make sure it’s included in the bundle you choose.
Information about sensors or mechanisms isn’t the same as comparable measurements of clicking, spring or lever noise in a bedroom.
If noise is a deciding factor for the person you share a room with, try out the specific device in person before buying, if you can.
A model listed for PC isn’t automatically compatible with every console.
Before buying, check the exact model version, your platform and the simulator you use.
The VIRPIL WarBRD-D is sold as a base; its compatible grip is a separate component.
Before comparing modular and complete sets, check which compatible parts you’ll need for a fully functioning input device.
You’ll also need a compatible grip for the WarBRD-D base.
The models worth comparing are the standalone T.16000M FCS, the T.16000M FCS HOTAS with TWCS throttle, and the T.Flight Hotas One.
The Gladiator NXT EVO Space Combat Edition is a desktop stick supplied with a base and grip.
The X52 H.O.T.A.S. is a stick-and-throttle option for buyers who want to use two control units.
The WarBRD-D base is for buyers who want to put together a modular stick with an adjustable centring feel.
This selection features a HOTAS with a throttle for two-handed control, with a layout that can be arranged more compactly.
No image available
A good fit if you want to operate the stick and throttle with both hands.
According to Thrustmaster, the detachable throttle can be attached to the stick for a more compact layout.
Yes, as long as its axes and controls suit your flying style and simulator. A separate throttle is an extra control option; Microsoft Flight Simulator supports different hardware configurations.
Once the game has started, check the control settings and the assignments for your detected device. According to Microsoft Flight Simulator Support, you’ll need to assign functions manually for devices without an automatically configured profile. Profiles can also apply to aircraft types or individual aircraft.
Check the full contents of the box: a standalone stick doesn’t automatically include a separate throttle, and the VIRPIL WarBRD-D base requires a compatible grip. For cleaning and maintenance, follow the instructions for the specific model.
For a qualifying online purchase from a business seller, you generally have a 14-day right to cancel from the date of delivery; some exceptions apply, and you should check who pays the return costs. The Verbraucherzentrale distinguishes this statutory right from a voluntary guarantee. You can’t assume you have a right to cancel when buying from a private seller.