Joybuy Insights

Choosing food supplements: ingredients, dosage and suitable products compared

Anyone looking to buy food supplements online will find products for almost every aspect of everyday life: melatonin as a sleep aid, omega-3 capsules, collagen for skin and connective tissue, biotin for hair, vitamins and minerals for daily nutritional support, and electrolytes after physical exertion. However, the wide choice can make comparisons difficult.

As a Joybuy Product Recommendation Officer, I filter market information according to transparent criteria. What matters is not attention-grabbing advertising claims, but the exact composition, the recommended daily serving and the information provided on the label.

Common pitfalls when buying food supplements

1. The quantity of active ingredients is confused with the quantity of the product

“1,000 mg fish oil” does not automatically mean 1,000 mg of EPA and DHA. When comparing omega-3 capsules, you should therefore check the actual amount of each fatty acid. For Doppelherz Sea Fish Oil Omega 3 1000mg 80 Caps, the product description states 180.76 mg of EPA and 120.51 mg of DHA per serving. These figures are more relevant for comparison than the “1000 mg” figure alone.

The serving size is also important with collagen. A product may advertise a large pack size but provide only a small daily serving. The relevant information is therefore the amount per stick, ampoule or capsule.

2. Combination products can lead to an unclear cumulative intake

A multivitamin product often already contains biotin, zinc, vitamin D, magnesium or selenium. Anyone who also uses a food supplement for skin and hair, a product for women or a food supplement for men may consume some nutrients twice.

The reference values under EU Regulation No. 1169/2011 can help put quantities into perspective. However, they are not a personal recommendation for taking supplements. Particularly with high-dose vitamin D, zinc or biotin, you should take other products and your own diet into account.

3. The form of administration and allergens are underestimated

Capsules, tablets, liquid sticks, sprays and chewable products differ in how they are used and in their ingredients. Fish oil capsules often contain gelatine; collagen may come from fish or pork. For example, ORIHIRO Chewable Supplement Collagen+Placenta 45g lists fish, gelatine and pork as allergens or animal-derived ingredients. The ingredients list is therefore essential for vegetarians, vegans and people with certain intolerances.

Parameters to check before buying

Focus on the active ingredient profile, not the product name

For each intended use, you should first establish which ingredient you are actually looking for:

  • Sleep and jet lag: Check the amount of melatonin per serving, directions for use and age recommendation.
  • Skin and hair: Compare the collagen content, biotin, zinc, vitamin C and any potential allergens.
  • Joints and connective tissue: Consider collagen, chondroitin, vitamin C, vitamin D and manganese separately.
  • Eyes: For products containing lutein and zeaxanthin, check the amounts per capsule as well as the vitamin A and zinc content.
  • Concentration: With ginkgo, look at the declared quantity, any additional B vitamins and the warnings.
  • Fluid and mineral support: With electrolytes, sodium, potassium, magnesium, chloride and the preparation volume are all relevant.

Daily serving and pack duration

A pack containing 30 capsules will last around 30 days when taking one capsule a day. For products requiring two sachets a day, the pack will last correspondingly less time. This has a greater effect on the actual cost per use than the pack price.

For sanotact Electrolytes Plus 20 Sachets, the product description recommends two sachets a day, each dissolved in 250 ml of water. At this dosage, the pack therefore provides ten days’ use.

Warnings and storage

Food supplements should not be used as a substitute for a varied diet and a healthy lifestyle. The recommended daily dose must not be exceeded. Pregnant and breastfeeding people, children, people with chronic conditions and anyone taking medication should consult a doctor about using these products where appropriate.

Some warnings are particularly useful in practice: biotin may affect certain laboratory tests. Ginkgo products are not suitable for people with an increased tendency to bleed or those taking anticoagulants unless they have consulted a healthcare professional beforehand. With products containing vitamin D or several sources of zinc, you should not automatically add another supplement.

Product selection for different user profiles

Suitable for: Budget-conscious beginners
Doppelherz A-Z Depot Tablets, 40 tablets

Doppelherz A-Z Depot Tablets, 40 Tablets

Why this product suits this profile: One tablet a day combines vitamins, minerals, trace elements and 1,500 µg of lutein. This makes it suitable for people looking for broad nutritional support in a single daily serving.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The composition and amounts per tablet are clearly listed. The product also advises against combining it with additional zinc or biotin supplements.

Main benefit & strengths

40 tablets, once-daily use and detailed information about the nutrients included.

Suitable for: Quality-focused shoppers
Doppelherz Sea Fish Oil Omega 3 1000mg 80 capsules

Doppelherz Sea Fish Oil Omega 3 1000mg 80 Caps

Why this product suits this profile: The declaration distinguishes fish oil from EPA and DHA. One capsule a day and 80 capsules per pack make it easier to plan your routine.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The individual omega-3 fatty acids are not hidden behind a general fish oil figure. Gelatine and fish-derived ingredients are clearly identifiable in the ingredients list.

Main benefit & strengths

Declared EPA and DHA amounts, plus vitamin E per serving.

Suitable for: Specific uses & frequent users
sanotact Electrolytes Plus 20 sachets

sanotact Electrolytes Plus 20 Sachets

Why this product suits this profile: The sachets are easy to portion when you are out and about, after heavy sweating or while travelling, and are prepared with water.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The recommended preparation specifies both the number of sachets and the amount of water. This makes it possible to calculate the daily duration of use realistically.

Main benefit & strengths

20 sachets, a combination of glucose and electrolytes, and a product declaration stating that it is gluten- and lactose-free.

Suitable for: Skin and hair supplements
Doppelherz Collagen 5000 Liquid 14 ampoules

Doppelherz Collagen 5000 Liquid 14 Ampoules

Why this product suits this profile: According to the product information, the liquid stick format provides 5,000 mg of hydrolysed collagen and 80 mg of chondroitin sulphate per serving, supplemented with vitamins C, D and E, plus manganese.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The amounts of the key ingredients are stated per stick. Age restrictions and specific information about vitamin D are also provided.

Main benefit & strengths

14 portioned liquid sticks, no additional water needed and a clearly stated collagen content.

Looking for more options?

We have put together a complete, regularly updated list of products that fully meet these strict selection criteria and the safety regulations applicable in the EU.

Frequently asked questions about food supplements

How long do food supplements last?

The best-before date is printed on the packaging. Once opened, additional instructions may apply, such as storing the product in a cool place or using it within a certain period. Products should be stored in a dry place, protected from light and out of children’s reach.

Can you take several supplements at the same time?

This depends on the nutrients they contain, the dosage and your personal circumstances. You should take particular care to check for duplicate intake of vitamin D, zinc, biotin, iron and fat-soluble vitamins. Compare the ingredients lists and daily servings before combining products.

Are food supplements for women and men different?

Some products are designed for specific stages of life or user groups, such as a food supplement for women going through the menopause or a food supplement for men containing zinc, selenium and B vitamins. However, the specific ingredients, dosage and your personal dietary habits remain the key considerations.