People recording detailed comparisons
You want to assess differences in the recorded gameplay and compare recording resolution, frame rate and, where relevant, HDR separately from the signal sent to your monitor.
If your game and recording software run on the same PC, first check whether you can record directly in OBS. For an HDMI signal from a console or a second PC, a compatible capture card is the obvious choice. What matters is the recording format you want and the monitor mode you actually use – 4K passthrough doesn’t automatically mean 4K recording. Also check the operating system, software, USB port and audio setup for your particular configuration.
You want to assess differences in the recorded gameplay and compare recording resolution, frame rate and, where relevant, HDR separately from the signal sent to your monitor.
You want to keep using your usual monitor mode while recording, so you check whether the HDMI passthrough supports the exact resolution and frame rate you need.
You’re setting up a console or second PC, a recording PC and audio in a spare room, and need a practical way to connect everything and route the cables.
| What matters | What to check before buying | Who is it important to? |
|---|---|---|
| Recording format | Check the resolution, frame rate and HDR requirements for the exact model and software you’ll use. | If I want to spot subtle differences in a recorded comparison video, the recording format matters. This is the top priority for around 33% of consumers concerned most about recording quality. |
| Monitor mode | Compare your monitor’s resolution and frame rate with the supported HDMI passthrough modes. | If I want to keep my usual monitor mode while gaming, the passthrough needs to support it. Around 25% of consumers put monitor mode first. |
| Setting up in a spare room | Check the signal source, connections, USB port, operating system and required cables together. | When space is limited, I want to plan a tidy route from the console or second PC to the recording PC. Around 25% of consumers prioritise a straightforward setup. |
| Game audio and commentary | Decide in advance whether you want to record game audio, microphone audio and chat; then check the audio connections and software setup. | If I want game audio and commentary to come through separately or together in the comparison, the right audio setup is essential. Around 17% of consumers prioritise audio routing. |
Elgato lists passthrough up to 2160p60 for the Game Capture Neo, but the manufacturer says recording goes up to 1080p60. For recorded comparison clips, it’s the recording format that matters – not just the HDMI mode sent to your monitor.
Compare the recording and passthrough specifications separately with your target video and monitor mode.
If you need 4K video files, you may need a different recording device.
Elgato specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2 at 10 Gbit/s for the 4K X. AVerMedia’s advertised recording up to 4K144 requires Streaming Center on Windows and MJPEG, so you can’t assume this mode will work with other systems or software.
Check that your USB port, operating system and chosen recording software support the exact mode you want.
Some recording modes may require a compatible USB port.
Elgato says that the Game Capture Neo doesn’t come with an HDMI cable and that Elgato cards can’t capture HDCP-protected HDMI signals.
Plan your cable route in advance. For recording gameplay from a PlayStation, Elgato explains how to disable HDCP in the system settings; this doesn’t make protected films or app content recordable as gameplay.
You may need to buy an HDMI cable separately for the Game Capture Neo.
The Elgato models covered here range from 1080p60 recording on the Game Capture Neo to recording and passthrough up to 2160p60 on the 4K S, according to the manufacturer.
The Live Gamer ULTRA 2.1 (GC553G2) is an external option to consider if you want to check support for high monitor modes or particular audio setups.
The Ripsaw HD offers another combination: 1080p60 recording and 4K60 passthrough, according to historical information from the manufacturer.
This selection is for recording HDMI signals from consoles or other sources on a separate recording PC. Before buying, check that the input, passthrough and recording mode suit your setup.
No image available
For external recording from a console, check that the HDMI and USB connections work with your recording PC.
Described as a 4K video capture card with five ports.
No image available
This card may suit console recording with separate commentary; check that its connections fit your audio setup and recording PC.
The HDMI input is specified up to 4K30, while recording is supported up to 1080p60. If you need to pass a 4K60 signal through the card, the listed input mode won’t be suitable.
Connect the console’s unprotected HDMI output to the capture card’s input, then connect the card to your recording PC. If you also want to connect a monitor, you can use the card’s HDMI output. Add the card to OBS as a video capture device and choose a supported format.
If HDCP protection is enabled, it can prevent Elgato devices from capturing the HDMI signal. For gameplay, Elgato explains how to turn off HDCP in the HDMI settings under ‘Settings’ and ‘System’. This doesn’t make protected films or app content recordable as gameplay.
Check which HDMI cables you’ll need and which USB port is available on your recording PC. Elgato says the Game Capture Neo doesn’t include an HDMI cable; for the 4K X, the manufacturer specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2 at 10 Gbit/s.
Making a private recording and sharing it publicly are not legally the same thing. Section 53 of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) covers copies for private use, subject to certain conditions. Whether a particular clip containing gameplay and music can be published depends on the content involved and the relevant usage rights, so there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The provisions of the Copyright Act also distinguish between making copies and making content available to the public.
For your statutory rights relating to faulty goods, contact the seller; these rights are separate from any voluntary manufacturer’s guarantee. The Verbraucherzentrale also explains that online purchases generally come with a right to cancel, although there are exceptions. In most cases, you have 14 days from receiving the goods.