Who needs to make this decision?

Comparing games with a console signal

If you want to record console games on a separate computer while playing on your monitor, you’ll need to consider the right HDMI input, the recording mode and passthrough. The OBS Project describes a capture solution as one way to record console footage in OBS.

Recording with limited desk space

If you want to record a single HDMI source without installing anything inside your PC, an external card could be a good fit. As well as space for the card, plan for the USB and HDMI connections and the route to your monitor.

Comparing two video sources

If you want to connect two HDMI sources to the recording computer at the same time, the number of suitable inputs is crucial. AVerMedia specifies two HDMI inputs for its internal GC570D. You’ll also need to check that your PC has a compatible PCIe slot.

What should you look for when buying?

First, decide whether you want to capture a PC game directly in OBS or record an external HDMI signal. Then you can check the recording format, monitor connection and ports you’ll need.

What matters What to look for when buying Who is this especially important for?
Suitable recording mode Check the recording resolution and frame rate for the specific HDMI source and planned video. Don’t confuse recording with input or passthrough. If I want to create a gaming comparison in a specific video mode, I check the resolution and frame rate separately from the input signal. Around 33% of consumers prioritise having a suitable recording mode.
Space and connections Check the form factor and USB port required. Also plan the HDMI cable route and, if needed, the output to your monitor. With limited desk space, I want to be sure I can fit an external setup and its cables. Around 27% of consumers prioritise form factor and connections.
Signal to the gaming monitor Check the passthrough resolution and frame rate for the gaming mode you want. Only assume HDR or VRR support if it’s explicitly specified for the signal path. If I want to keep playing in my usual monitor mode while recording, that exact mode needs to be passed through. Around 20% of consumers prioritise the monitor signal.
Two video sources and audio Check the number and capabilities of the inputs individually. For your monitor and audio, find out which outputs and software connections are supported. If I want to compare two game signals at the same time, I need suitable separate inputs and a clear audio route. Around 20% of consumers prioritise multiple sources and how their audio is handled.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing 4K passthrough with 4K recording

    A 4K signal being passed through doesn’t automatically mean the card can record in 4K. NZXT explains that its Signal HD60 can read and pass through a 4K signal, but can’t send a 4K recording to the recording PC.

    Compare recording and passthrough separately with the resolution and frame rate of your planned setup.

  • Planning for just one input when using two HDMI sources

    Two signals connected at the same time require suitable separate inputs. The signal paths on the AVerMedia GC570D aren’t identical: according to the manufacturer, the HDMI passthrough output is assigned to input 1.

    Decide whether you’ll record the sources one after the other or at the same time, and check the inputs and passthrough for each source individually.

  • Focusing only on the size of the device

    Even a compact external card needs connections to the gaming source and recording computer. If you want to play on a separate monitor, you’ll also need the right signal path.

    Map out the connections on your desk and check the ports and cables you need against the specific model.

  • Taking advertised maximums at face value

    For the AVerMedia GC553G2, the manufacturer advertises 4K144 recording with Streaming Center on Windows using the MJPEG format. According to its technical specifications, HDR recording on the Elgato 4K S is currently limited to Windows and up to 1080p60.

    Check that the mode you want works with your computer and recording software, rather than relying on the biggest figure in the product listing.

Key brands at a glance

Elgato

External capture models for a range of recording formats.

  • Elgato says the 4K S is designed for 4K60 recording and 4K60 passthrough.
  • According to Elgato’s technical specifications, HDR recording on the 4K S is currently limited to Windows and up to 1080p60. Elgato Germany lists the HD60 X as no longer available.

AVerMedia

The range includes external Full HD and HDMI 2.1 cards, as well as an internal card with two HDMI inputs.

  • AVerMedia specifies up to 1080p60 recording and passthrough for the external GC311; the internal GC570D has two HDMI inputs.
  • According to the manufacturer, only input 1 on the GC570D is connected to HDMI passthrough. The GC553G2’s advertised 4K144 recording requires Streaming Center on Windows and MJPEG.

NZXT

The external Signal HD60 is designed for a single HDMI source and Full HD recording.

  • NZXT says the Signal HD60 can read and pass through a 4K signal.
  • According to NZXT, the card can’t send a 4K recording to the PC. The manual specifies a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 1 port.

Joybuy products

The external USB capture cards below are designed for recording games. For each model, compare the stated recording mode with the separate input or passthrough, and check that its connections and cables suit your setup.

4K video capture card with USB 3.0 and 5 ports

4K video capture card, USB 3.0, 5 ports

For a single HDMI gaming source, when you want to combine Full HD recording with a separate 4K monitor connection.

The specifications distinguish between 1080p60 recording and 4K/60Hz input and passthrough; 4K recording isn’t specified.

View at Joybuy
4K video capture card with 5 ports and HD converter

4K video capture card with 5 ports, HD converter

For a single gaming source when you want to record in Full HD and pass the picture through as well.

The specifications state 1080p60 recording and 4K@60Hz for input and loop-through; 4K recording isn’t specified.

View at Joybuy
4K HDMI capture card with USB 3.0

4K HDMI capture card, USB 3.0

For a single HDMI gaming source when Full HD recording and separate microphone and headphone connections suit your setup.

The specifications list an HDMI input of up to 4K 30Hz and 1080p60 recording; 4K recording isn’t specified.

View at Joybuy
4K USB 3.0 video capture card with 5 ports

4K USB 3.0 video capture card, 5 ports

For a single HDMI gaming source when you need Full HD recording and 4K passthrough to a separate monitor.

The specifications state 1080p recording; 4K refers to HDMI passthrough.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN 4K HDMI video capture card, USB 3.0

VIELLAN 4K HDMI video capture card, USB 3.0

For recording games via USB when Full HD recording and separate 4K passthrough suit your planned signal path.

The specifications state 1080p recording and 4K HDMI passthrough. Compatible systems listed are Windows, macOS and Linux.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a capture card to record two games on the same PC?

Not for that reason alone. For a game running on Windows, the OBS Project recommends trying the direct Game Capture source first. Capturing the HDMI signal from a separate console or second PC uses a different signal path and requires a video capture solution.

How do I connect an external card for playing and recording?

For a model with passthrough, connect HDMI from the gaming source to the card’s input, then connect the card’s output to the monitor. USB connects the card to the recording computer. In OBS, add the card as a Video Capture Device source. Check the actual connections and included cables for the model you choose.

Can a capture card record two consoles at the same time?

Only if the specific device has suitable separate inputs. AVerMedia specifies two HDMI inputs for the internal GC570D, each supporting recording at up to 1080p60. The HDMI passthrough output is connected to input 1.

Why is the picture from a PlayStation 5 black when using an Elgato HD60 X?

Elgato lists HDCP being enabled as a possible cause. For PS5 gameplay that can be recorded, it says to turn off the HDCP setting before connecting. This doesn’t make protected films or streaming content eligible for recording; circumventing effective protection measures for protected works is subject to section 95a of the German Copyright Act (UrhG).

Can I publish my gaming comparison in Germany?

The permission to make individual private copies under section 53 of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) doesn’t give you general permission to publish them. Whether you can publish footage from a particular game, music, voices or other content depends on the rights involved and the terms of use. Make sure you have permission for each of the items you use.