Who is this guide for?

Commentators in a shared room

When there are other noises or voices in the room, clear voice transmission matters. A microphone boom you can position and a test in typical room conditions can help you choose. Manufacturer claims alone don’t show how well a microphone will screen out noise in your room.

Considerate flatmates

If you want to hear game audio through headphones rather than speakers, consider closed-back ear cups and the volume you use. Sidetone is a different feature: SteelSeries uses the term for feeding the microphone signal back into the ear cups so you can hear your own voice.

Commentators using multiple devices

If you switch between a PC and a console, check the audio connection and microphone operation for each device. HyperX lists several connection options for the Cloud III; some extra features, such as sidetone, may work differently depending on the model and platform.

What should you look for when buying?

First, test voice transmission against the noises you’re likely to hear in your shared bedroom. Then check game audio, how well you can hear your own voice, comfort and compatibility with the specific gaming device you use.

Buying priority What to look for Who is this especially important for?
Clear voice Position the microphone in front of your mouth and listen back to a test recording with typical room noise. If I want to comment clearly despite other voices in the background, I test the transmission in realistic conditions. Around 28 % of consumers put clear voice transmission first.
Less game audio in the room Check the closed-back ear cups and how much game audio can be heard outside them at your usual volume. If I want to minimise how much game audio disturbs the other person, I use headphones instead of speakers and check the volume. Around 22 % of consumers prioritise this.
Hearing your own voice Check whether sidetone is available and adjustable on the device you use. With isolating ear cups, I still want to hear my voice as I speak. Around 17 % of consumers put voice monitoring first.
Comfort during longer commentary sessions Consider the clamping force, ear cushions and weight of the specific model. If I’m commentating for longer, I want the headset to feel comfortable; replaceable parts subject to wear may also matter. Around 17 % of consumers put long-term comfort first.
Connection to your gaming device Check the connection, microphone operation and any software features you need for your PC or specific console. Especially if I switch between devices, the microphone needs to work with the gaming device I’m using. Around 16 % of consumers prioritise this compatibility.

Common misconceptions

  • Assuming ANC and microphone noise cancellation do the same thing

    ANC mainly affects the noises you hear while listening. Microphone noise cancellation, on the other hand, affects the signal that’s transmitted. Test the microphone to see whether other voices in the room can still be heard in chat.

    Test the two features separately and listen back to a recording with typical background voices.

  • Assuming a closed-back headset will keep noise from your flatmate

    Closed-back ear cups help isolate sound at your ears and mean you can use headphones instead of speakers. They won’t make your spoken voice quieter in the room.

    Check how much game audio can be heard outside the headset, and agree suitable times for commentary with the other person.

  • Assuming platform compatibility means every feature will work

    A connection or wireless mode alone doesn’t prove that the microphone and extra features will work the same way on every device. Sidetone, for example, may depend on specific software.

    Check connections, microphone operation and extra features individually for your gaming device.

Brands to consider

beyerdynamic

The MMX 300 PRO is a closed-back, analogue option for buyers who want to consider replaceable parts.

  • beyerdynamic lists replaceable ear pads, a headband and cable, along with a cardioid microphone.
  • COMPUTER BILD describes the microphone as sensitive to external noise. So check voice transmission in your own room.

Sony

The INZONE H9 II is a wireless option for buyers who want to assess listening isolation and a separate microphone feature.

  • Sony lists ANC for listening and separate noise cancellation on the boom microphone.
  • COMPUTER BILD describes the microphone sound on PS5 as tinny and thin. The platform and a listening test of your own are therefore important factors when choosing.

SteelSeries

Arctis models may suit buyers who want to compare sidetone or multiple audio sources as features to control.

  • SteelSeries describes adjustable sidetone for Arctis; for the Arctis Nova Elite, the manufacturer lists multiple inputs.
  • You may need PC or Mac software to adjust sidetone. Features listed for specific models don’t necessarily apply to the entire Arctis range.

HyperX

The Cloud III is a wired option if its listed connection options suit your device.

  • HyperX lists a 10 mm microphone, a mute indicator, and 3.5 mm and USB connections.
  • Manufacturer information about microphone features doesn’t prove that another person’s voice in the room will be filtered out of chat.

Razer

The BlackShark V2 X is a closed-back option with a flexible cardioid microphone.

  • Razer describes an adjustable microphone and passive isolation from the closed-back ear cups.
  • The manufacturer’s claim that it picks up less sound from the sides doesn’t guarantee that conversations in the room will be inaudible in chat.

Joybuy products

The models below include wired and wireless gaming headsets with microphones for commentary in a shared room.

Razer BlackShark V2 X Quartz gaming headset

Razer BlackShark V2 X Quartz

A wired option if you want to use a positionable microphone and headphones rather than speakers while commentating.

  • Closed-back ear cups
  • Flexible cardioid microphone
  • 3.5 mm connection
View at Joybuy
SteelSeries Arctis Nova Pro Wireless gaming headset, white

SteelSeries Arctis Nova Pro Wireless Gaming Headset White

A wireless option if you want to assess ANC for listening and a detachable microphone separately for your needs.

  • Closed-back ear cups and ANC
  • Detachable noise-cancelling microphone
  • Wireless base station for PC or console; Bluetooth for mobile devices
  • Weight: 516 g
  • Wireless use requires charging.
View at Joybuy
JBL Quantum 360P over-ear wireless gaming headset, white

JBL Quantum 360P Over-Ear Wireless Gaming Headset, White

A wireless option if you want to use a boom microphone and test how it performs with the noises in your room.

  • Directional boom microphone with echo cancellation
  • ANC for listening
  • Bluetooth and detachable 3.5 mm cable connection
  • Listed battery life: up to 22 hours
  • Wireless use requires charging.
View at Joybuy
JBL Quantum 120 wired over-ear gaming headphones, purple

JBL Quantum 120 Gaming Headphone, Wired Over-Ear, Purple

A wired option if you’re looking for a detachable directional microphone and a 3.5 mm connection.

  • Detachable 6 mm cardioid boom microphone
  • 3.5 mm connection
  • PC software for noise reduction and microphone settings via QuantumENGINE
  • The product description says a Y-splitter is required for a PC with separate headphone and microphone sockets; it isn’t included.
View at Joybuy
JBL Quantum 250 wired over-ear gaming headset, light teal and orange

JBL Quantum 250 Gaming-Wired Over-Ear Headset, Light Teal and Orange

A wired option if you want a boom microphone and the 3.5 mm connection is compatible with your gaming device.

  • Detachable cardioid boom microphone
  • 3.5 mm audio connection
  • Breathable ear cushions
  • Listed as compatible with PC, Mac, PlayStation, Xbox and Nintendo Switch
View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will a headset make my spoken match commentary inaudible to the other person in the room?

No. Ear cups affect game audio and the sounds you hear yourself; a microphone feature affects the signal that’s transmitted. They won’t mute your voice in the room. If you need to keep things quiet, agree speaking times and volume levels with the other person.

How should I set up my headset before commentating?

Position the microphone boom close to your mouth and select the correct microphone input on your gaming device. Make a test recording with typical room noises, then check the mute function and, where available, sidetone on the exact platform you’ll be using.

Does ANC also block other people’s voices from voice chat?

Not automatically. ANC mainly affects what the wearer hears, while a microphone feature processes the signal that’s transmitted. Test the two features separately and listen back to a test recording made in your room.

What should I bear in mind during longer commentary sessions?

Choose a comfortable fit and keep playback volume moderate. The World Health Organization notes that both volume and listening time affect exposure to loud sounds. Also check whether the ear cushions or cable can be replaced on the specific model.

Can I record a conversation with the other person in the bedroom?

Recording can raise legal questions: Section 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) covers, among other things, the unauthorised recording of another person’s non-public speech and certain uses of such a recording. Whether the law applies in a particular case depends on the circumstances. Avoid recording accidentally, and get consent before you record.