Who archives genealogical records?

Collectors with large scan libraries

If you’re digitising lots of certificates and photos, plan for both your current collection and future growth. The German Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) points out that the lifespan of storage media cannot be predicted precisely.

Researchers using several computers

If you regularly transfer files, make sure the connectors, cables and file system are compatible with the computers you plan to use. Samsung lists USB-C and USB-A cables for the portable SSD T7; still, check which connectors your devices actually have.

Those archiving confidential family records

If you’re storing information about people who are still alive or keeping a copy elsewhere, you may want to prioritise access protection in case the drive is lost. The BSI recommends keeping recovery information for encrypted data in a safe place.

What should you look for when buying?

External HDD

A good fit if: You mainly store lots of scans and photos, and only add to them occasionally.

The trade-off: A portable SSD may suit your workflow better if you transfer files or carry the drive around frequently. An HDD also needs an additional backup copy.

Portable SSD

A good fit if: You regularly transfer large collections of files between workstations or often take the drive with you.

The trade-off: Advertised transfer speeds depend on having a compatible connector; an SSD also doesn’t replace a separate backup copy.

For a cloud-free family history archive, recoverability, sufficient storage, access protection and compatibility with your devices are all different priorities to consider when buying.

Priority What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Recoverability Plan for a second local copy, ideally kept in a separate location, and regularly test that you can read and restore your files. The consumer advice centre recommends using at least two storage media for private archival records. If I don’t want to lose irreplaceable scans, I’ll keep a separate copy and check that I can open the files again. Around 36% of consumers would put recoverability first.
Space for a growing collection Take into account the size of your existing folders, planned additions and backup versions; check the capacity of the specific model. If my collection of photos and scans keeps growing, I want enough spare capacity so I don’t have to add another drive soon. Around 29% of consumers would prioritise available storage above all else.
Access protection Check how to enable encryption and unlock the drive, and how to store a recovery key securely without using the cloud. The BSI points out that losing the key could prevent you from accessing your own data. If I’m carrying confidential family information with me or storing a copy elsewhere, I want to restrict access if the drive is lost, while still being able to find the key. Around 21% of consumers would prioritise access protection.
Connectors and devices Check that the USB connector, cable, file system and operating systems are compatible. Toshiba says Canvio Basics is preformatted as NTFS and needs to be reformatted for macOS. If I use the same files on several computers, I want to be able to connect the drive and open them on each one. Around 14% of consumers would put device compatibility first.

Common buying and archiving mistakes

  • Confusing a large drive with a long-term archiving strategy

    The BSI points out that the lifespan of individual storage media cannot be predicted precisely. If your only copy fails, you could lose the records stored on it.

    Before moving your files, plan for at least one additional local copy. Keep it separately if possible, and regularly test that you can restore your files.

  • Assuming the USB rating is the transfer speed you’ll get

    Manufacturer figures depend, among other things, on whether your computer’s connector is compatible. So when comparing HDDs and SSDs, consider how they’ll perform as part of your actual workflow.

    Check the connectors on your devices and think about how often, and on which computers, you’ll transfer large collections of scans.

  • Choosing encryption without planning how to unlock the drive and store the key

    Access protection can be useful if a drive is lost, but it may make it harder to recover your files later. For the Executive Fingerprint Secure #53652 model, Verbatim recommends installing a security update.

    Set up the protection, test unlocking the drive on the devices you plan to use, and keep your recovery information somewhere safe without using the cloud.

Brands to consider

Toshiba

The Canvio Basics range is worth considering for collections stored locally. The key factors are the specific capacity and the operating system you use.

  • Toshiba says Canvio Basics works with Windows without any additional installation and is powered via USB.
  • The model mentioned is formatted as NTFS; Toshiba says it needs to be reformatted for macOS. Back up any existing files before changing the format.

Samsung

The portable SSD T7 is an option for frequent local transfers and a range of USB connectors.

  • Samsung Germany lists speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s for the T7 with USB 3.2 Gen 2, and includes USB-C and USB-A cables.
  • The stated maximum speed isn’t guaranteed on your computer. An SSD also needs additional backup copies.

Verbatim

The 1 TB Executive Fingerprint Secure #53652 is aimed at users who want an extra layer of access protection.

  • Verbatim lists AES-256 hardware encryption and fingerprint access for this model.
  • Verbatim recommends installing a security update. A manufacturer’s statement about GDPR compliance isn’t general proof of legal compliance.

Western Digital

For the My Passport range, check the full model number and the specific features of the version you’re considering.

  • Western Digital lists a black 2 TB version of My Passport under model number WDBYVG0020BBK-WESN.
  • This model information doesn’t apply to other My Passport versions.

Seagate

The One Touch range is another line of external HDDs. Check which local features you need on the specific model you’re considering.

  • Seagate describes the One Touch range as having a USB 3.0 connector and offering manual or scheduled backups.
  • The additional services described aren’t automatically required for local, cloud-free storage.

Joybuy products for a local archive

This Joybuy selection includes external HDDs for storing genealogical files locally, plus a portable SSD for transferring files locally.

WD Elements Portable, 5 TB, USB-C

WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C

An external HDD option for local storage when you need plenty of space.

5 TB; USB-C; 2.5 inches; 240 g.

View on Joybuy
WD Elements Portable, 4 TB, USB-C

WD Elements Portable 4 TB USB-C

An external HDD option for documents, photos and other files stored locally.

4 TB; USB-C; 131 g; listed as compatible with Windows and macOS.

View on Joybuy
WD Elements, portable external hard drive, 2 TB, USB-C

WD Elements 2 TB Portable External Hard Drive USB-C

A portable HDD option if you want to store scans and photos locally.

2 TB; USB-C; 2.5 inches; exFAT; listed as compatible with Windows and macOS.

View on Joybuy
WD Elements Desktop external hard drive, 8 TB, USB 3.0

WD Elements 8 TB Desktop External Hard Drive

A desktop HDD option for large local collections, if you have a permanent place to keep it.

8 TB; USB 3.0; 3.5 inches; requires an external power supply. The product description says the NTFS file system needs to be reformatted for macOS.

View on Joybuy
KEXIN external SSD, 256 GB, USB 3.1 Type-C

KEXIN External SSD 256 GB USB 3.1 Type-C

A portable SSD option for local storage and frequent transfers, provided 256 GB is enough for your archive.

256 GB; USB 3.1 Type-C; listed in the product name as reaching speeds of up to 500 MB/s.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one external drive enough for a family archive?

No. You should plan for an additional copy of irreplaceable family records. In its guidance on private archival records, the consumer advice centre recommends using at least two storage media, ideally kept in separate locations. Also check regularly that you can still open the files.

Should I choose an HDD or SSD for a family history archive?

An external HDD is generally better suited to a collection that’s mainly stored and only occasionally updated; a portable SSD may work better if you often transfer files or carry the drive around. For either type, check the capacity and connectors on your devices, and plan for an additional backup copy.

What should I test before moving my files?

Check the connector and file system, and test a small file restore before transferring your entire collection. Toshiba says Canvio Basics is preformatted as NTFS and needs to be reformatted for macOS; back up any existing files before changing the file system.

Do old scans need to be converted to PDF/A for long-term storage?

Not necessarily. The German Federal Archives doesn’t generally require conversion before long-term storage in its archival context. For a private family archive, it’s therefore important not to delete the original files just to convert them.

What’s especially important with an encrypted drive?

Before buying, check how you’ll unlock the specific drive and restore access. The BSI points out that a recovery password can be essential for encrypted data; keep it somewhere safe without using the cloud, and test that you can restore your files.