Which option is right for you?

Retouching portraits on your existing monitor

If you work on masks, skin details and subtle transitions on your current screen, a screenless pen tablet is worth considering. Adobe explains how you can use pen pressure in Photoshop to control brush size or opacity.

Retouching directly on the image

If you want to use your pen directly on the image on screen, a pen display could be a good fit. Make sure you have enough desk space, the right connections and, if needed, an additional power connection.

Assessing shadows, midtones and highlights

If tonal gradations are central to your black-and-white portraits, assess them on the screen you actually use for your work. Adobe recommends keeping an eye on tonal distribution and possible loss of detail in shadows, midtones and highlights.

What should you look for when buying?

Screenless pen tablet

A good fit if: You already work on a suitable monitor and don’t want to add another screen to your desk.

The trade-off: Your hand moves in one place while you look at the image somewhere else.

Pen display

A good fit if: You want to use your pen directly on the portrait displayed on screen.

The trade-off: You’ll need desk space and will need to consider the video connection, power supply and tonal settings of the additional display.

What matters What to check when buying Who is this important for?
Precise masking and retouching Check the pen feel, pressure settings and driver. In Photoshop, pressure control must be set up for the brush property you want to adjust. If I want to work carefully on masks and skin details, pressure sensitivity needs to suit the way I use my brushes; around 36% of consumers say precise pen retouching is a priority.
Black-and-white tones Think about which screen you’ll use to assess the result. With a pen display, its screen settings are part of your workflow. If I want to assess shadows, midtones and highlights carefully, I need to factor the display into my decision; around 29% of consumers prioritise tonal assessment.
Desk space Measure the space available, including room for the necessary cables. Compare the device’s overall dimensions and active area separately. If there’s little room beside my monitor and keyboard, I want to know how the device will fit into my workspace; around 21% of consumers prioritise the space available on their desk.
Connection and set-up Check the exact model against your operating system, drivers, video and data connections, power supply and the cables included. If I want to connect the device without unexpected set-up hassles, I’ll check my computer’s requirements in advance; around 14% of consumers say an easy set-up is a priority.

Pitfalls to avoid when buying a graphics tablet

  • Assuming more pressure levels mean better retouching

    Whether pressure controls brush size or opacity also depends on the settings in the software you use.

    Check that the brush workflow and pen settings suit the way you work, rather than comparing just one specification.

  • Assuming a pen display and tonal assessment are the same decision

    Drawing directly on the image doesn’t, by itself, tell you how shadows and highlights will appear on the display.

    Decide whether you want to work on your existing monitor or an additional screen, and assess tonal values on the display you’ll actually use.

    An additional screen takes up desk space and adds another step when setting up and assessing the display.

  • Assuming similarly named model generations and connections are interchangeable

    The Wacom Cintiq 16 DTK1660K0B is marked as a previous generation. XPPen lists the Artist Pro 16 and Artist Pro 16 (Gen 2) separately; according to the manual, the Artist 15.6 Pro V2 may need an additional power supply.

    Check the full model number, what’s included and the connection guide for the specific device. Depending on the model, you may need additional compatible cables.

Key brands at a glance

Wacom

The Intuos Pro Medium is a screenless pen tablet, while the Cintiq 16 is a pen display. They offer different ways of working; this doesn’t mean one will deliver better retouching results than the other.

  • According to Wacom, the current Intuos Pro Medium has an active area of 263 × 148 mm and connects via USB and Bluetooth.
  • Wacom marks the Cintiq 16 DTK1660K0B as a previous generation. Its specifications can’t automatically be applied to the current DTK168K0B.

XPPen

The Artist 15.6 Pro V2 and Artist Pro 16 are pen displays, while the Deco Pro (Gen 2) series is a screenless pen tablet.

  • XPPen lists a 15.4-inch display and shortcut keys for the Artist 15.6 Pro V2.
  • According to the manual, the Artist 15.6 Pro V2 may need an additional power connection. Specifications for the Artist Pro 16 don’t automatically apply to the Gen 2 version.

Huion

The Inspiroy 2 M is a pen tablet with controls, while the Kamvas Pro 19 is a larger pen display that requires more space.

  • Huion lists programmable keys and a scroll wheel for the Inspiroy 2 M, and an 18.4-inch 4K display for the Kamvas Pro 19.
  • These manufacturer specifications are specific to each model and aren’t an independent assessment of retouching performance or tonal accuracy.

Xencelabs

The Pen Tablet Medium Bundle v2 is an option if you’re considering a screenless pen tablet with a separate shortcut remote and two pens.

  • The German Xencelabs shop lists Quick Keys and two v2 pens as included.
  • Pens from the original Pen Tablet series aren’t interchangeable with the v2 series. Make sure you choose the right version when buying replacement pens.

Suitable products at Joybuy

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will more pressure levels automatically improve black-and-white portraits?

No. More pressure levels alone don’t mean better retouching. In Photoshop, pressure control must be set up for the brush property you want to adjust. Then check that the pen and settings work well for your masks and edits.

What should I check before connecting a pen display?

Check the specific model’s video signal, data connection, power supply, included cables and drivers. According to the XPPen Artist 15.6 Pro V2 manual, an additional power connection is required if the display doesn’t light up when connected via USB-C.

How should I assess tones when retouching portraits?

Assess shadows, midtones and highlights on the display you actually use, and choose suitable adjustment tools for any changes you want to make. Adobe describes Curves as a way to adjust specific tonal ranges independently. If you use a pen display, its screen settings are also part of your workflow.

What rights apply to private online purchases in Germany?

In Germany, online purchases of goods generally come with a 14-day right to cancel, starting from the day you receive the goods; statutory exceptions and proper notification of this right should be taken into account. The Baden-Württemberg consumer portal distinguishes this right from statutory rights relating to faulty goods, which are claims against the seller, and from a voluntary guarantee.