Who each option is for

Groups with a growing video archive

If you mainly back up lots of recordings in one place, make sure the capacity also allows for the additional backup versions you plan to keep.

People responsible for backups

If you create and store copies, you need clear responsibilities and should regularly check that files can be restored. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends disconnecting the backup medium from the device when a backup is not in progress.

Teams working in different locations

When handing files between team members, portability, compatible connections and enough capacity for a complete backup all matter. Transfer speeds may also be worth considering if you regularly move large amounts of data.

What to consider when choosing

Start by working out how much data you have and how you plan to back it up. Then you can decide whether a permanent backup location, frequent handovers or regular large transfers matter most.

What matters What to check before buying Who it's important to
Capacity for your archive and its growth Check the space currently used, planned backup versions and expected growth; compare these with the capacity of the specific model. As our video archive grows, we want enough room for what we have now and for future backup versions. Around 36% of consumers would prioritise capacity when making this choice.
Restoring files and storing copies separately Agree who is responsible, how often backups are made, where the separate copy is stored and when to test a restore. When several people are responsible for keeping copies, we need a process that works when files have to be restored. Around 29% of consumers would prioritise organisation and the ability to restore files.
Portability and connections Make a note of the computers, USB ports, operating systems and capacity needed for a complete backup. When we hand a backup over between locations, it needs to be portable and compatible with the computers involved. Around 21% of consumers would prioritise portability and connections.
Transfer speeds for frequent backups Check the size and frequency of transfers, along with the USB standard supported by the computers you use. Don't assume manufacturers' maximum speeds guarantee a particular backup time. When we regularly transfer large video files, we want to avoid unnecessary waiting and need to check that the connections are compatible too. Around 14% of consumers would prioritise transfer speeds.

Common selection mistakes

  • Leaving the backup drive connected all the time

    If your copy stays connected to the computer or in the same place, it could be affected by a problem that also impacts your working device or shared location.

    Decide who connects the drive, runs the backup, disconnects it afterwards and stores the copy separately. Also check that files can be restored.

  • Choosing a portable SSD based on its advertised speed alone

    Kingston says the XS2000 is available in capacities up to 4 TB and offers speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s over USB 3.2 Gen 2x2. These figures aren't guaranteed for every computer or a complete backup.

    First, work out how much data a complete backup will contain and check the connection you need. Then weigh up speed, portability and capacity.

    If your backup won't fit on the model you choose, you may need another drive or one with a larger capacity.

  • Assuming a drive will work with a Mac straight away

    For its Canvio Advance range, Toshiba specifies NTFS and says the drive needs to be reformatted for macOS.

    Check the file system of the specific model before using it. If the drive contains files, don't reformat it until you've backed them up elsewhere.

    Reformatting takes time and may mean you need a temporary alternative copy.

Brands to consider

Seagate

The Expansion Desktop range includes desktop drives that may suit a backup kept in one place.

  • COMPUTER BILD ranked the 16 TB and 20 TB Expansion Desktop Drive models first and third in its test of external 3.5-inch hard drives.
  • These test results apply to the models tested, not to every Seagate drive. Seagate lists a power supply as included for one Expansion Desktop specification sheet; check what's included with the specific generation you're considering.

Western Digital

The Black D10 Game Drive and My Book desktop models tested offer different capacities and features for a permanent backup location.

  • COMPUTER BILD notes that the Black D10 it tested has two additional USB ports.
  • COMPUTER BILD doesn't list any special extras for the My Book models it tested. The manufacturer's website lists the 14 TB version as WDBBGB0140HBK-EESN; check the exact model number before matching it to a version with a different name.

Toshiba

The portable Canvio Advance range may suit groups that move backups between locations and can manage with the available capacities.

  • Toshiba Storage Solutions for the EMEA region describes the range as USB-powered and lists downloadable backup and security software.
  • The manufacturer's EMEA website lists NTFS and says the drive needs to be reformatted for macOS. Check the file system and features of the specific model before using it.

Kingston

The external XS2000 SSD may suit frequent mobile file transfers if the amount of data you need to back up is within the available capacity.

  • Kingston lists USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 and speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s for the XS2000.
  • The stated maximum speed isn't a measured result for every computer or backup. Check the connections on the computers involved and make sure the supplied USB-C-to-USB-C cable is suitable.

Joybuy products for group backups

Depending on how you back up your files, these drives may suit mobile handovers or a permanent backup location.

WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C

For backing up videos on the go, if the drive has enough capacity for the data you need.

5 TB; USB-C; portable design.

A compatible USB-C connection is required.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 6TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 6TB USB-C

For handing over a backup on the go, if this portable drive has enough capacity for the complete backup.

6 TB; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 1; portable design.

A compatible USB-C connection is required.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements 8TB Desktop External Hard Drive

WD Elements 8TB Desktop External Hard Drive

For a backup kept in one place, if the stated capacity is right for your archive and planned backup versions.

8 TB; 3.5-inch form factor; USB 3.0.

An external power supply is required, so allow for a permanent spot near a power socket. According to the product information, the NTFS drive must be reformatted for the described use with macOS.

View at Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7, 2 TB, USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2, Titanium Grey

Samsung Portable SSD T7, 2 TB, Titanium Grey

For a mobile backup, if the 2 TB version described here has enough capacity for your needs.

2 TB; USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2.

According to the product information, hardware encryption must be set up using software and a password.

View at Joybuy
Samsung MU-PG2T0B, 2 TB, USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2

Samsung MU-PG2T0B, 2 TB, USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2

For storing and transferring video files on the go, if 2 TB is enough for the backup you need.

2 TB; USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 (3.1 Gen 2).

Check that the computers involved have compatible connections before handing the drive over.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is it enough to copy videos to an external drive once?

No, not if that copy is your only backup. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends making regular backups, disconnecting the medium when a backup isn't in progress and checking that data can be restored. Set a schedule that works for your group.

Does a portable hard drive need to be prepared for Mac computers?

That depends on the file system of the specific model. For the Toshiba Canvio Advance described here, Toshiba Storage Solutions for the EMEA region lists NTFS and says the drive needs to be reformatted for macOS. Back up any existing files elsewhere before reformatting a drive.

What should a group check about power supplies, warranties and data recovery?

For a desktop drive, check what's included, including the power supply. Check warranty terms and any data recovery services for the specific model and regional version; neither is a substitute for an additional backup copy.

Do data protection rules apply to a group's videos?

If identifiable people appear in the videos and your group processes their personal data, you should check whether the GDPR applies. The European Union's guidance sets out requirements for organisations handling personal data. The appropriate safeguards in each case depend on the recordings and how they are used. The European Data Protection Board's guidelines link safeguards to the level of risk involved.