For a large archive that you mainly store and only access occasionally, an external HDD is likely to be the better choice. In its comparison of tested portable 2.5-inch HDDs, COMPUTER BILD says they offer more storage for the same money than SSDs. If you often transfer RAW files or edit them directly from the drive, an SSD could work well as a working drive. Either way, keep important files on a separate backup that you can restore from.
Which option is right for you?
Collectors with large photo archives
If you mainly store scans and RAW files, and expect to add more photos, start by working out how much storage you already need and how much your collection is likely to grow. COMPUTER BILD says that tested portable HDDs offer more storage for the same money than SSDs.
Photographers with an active RAW workflow
If you often transfer large files or edit them directly from an external drive, consider an SSD as a working drive. Samsung says that both the host device and cable must support USB 3.2 Gen 2 to achieve the advertised maximum speed.
People with irreplaceable documents
If you need to keep important scans and photos safe, plan for a separate backup as well as the drive you use day to day. The German Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) recommends making sure you can restore your backed-up data, too.
What should you look for when buying?
External HDD
A good fit if: You mainly archive lots of scans and RAW files, and only access them occasionally.
The trade-off: In its comparison of tested portable 2.5-inch HDDs, COMPUTER BILD says they offer more storage for the same money than SSDs. Even so, consider how often you need to access your files and the capacity of the specific model.
External SSD
A good fit if: You often transfer RAW files, take your drive with you or edit directly from it.
The trade-off: Manufacturers’ maximum speed claims apply only when the stated connection requirements are met, so check your computer and cable.
| Priority |
What to look for when buying |
Who is this particularly important for? |
| Room for your whole collection |
Compare the amount of data you already have and expect to add with the capacity of the specific model. |
If I want to store scans and RAW files together and leave room for new photos, available storage is especially important. Around 34% of consumers put capacity first. |
| Separate backup |
Allow enough storage for an additional copy and test restoring selected files. |
If I don’t want important scans and photos to be my only copies, I need a separate backup that I can restore from. Around 33% of consumers give this priority. |
| Speed for your RAW workflow |
Compare HDDs and SSDs based on how you use them; check that your host connection and cable support the advertised speed. |
If you often transfer or edit large RAW files, the drive’s performance in your workflow matters most. Around 20% of consumers put working speed first. |
| Protection and device compatibility |
Check encryption options, as well as the file system, operating system and write access for the specific version. |
If your scans are confidential or you plan to use the drive with different devices, access protection and compatibility are important. Around 13% of consumers prioritise these factors. |
Common buying and usage mistakes
-
Relying on your only external drive as a complete backup
A drive can fail. If your files are stored only on that drive, you won’t have a separate copy to fall back on.
Plan for an additional backup and a restore test when choosing your drive.
You’ll also need to keep the separate copy up to date.
-
Assuming an SSD’s top speed is guaranteed on your computer
Samsung’s stated maximum speeds for the T7 Shield require a host device and cable with USB 3.2 Gen 2.
Check your computer’s USB capabilities and the type of cable you need, rather than comparing only the stated MB/s figure.
-
Assuming a pre-formatted file system offers write access on every device
Toshiba says the Canvio Advance uses NTFS and needs to be reformatted for use with Mac OS.
Check which operating systems you’ll use before transferring your files for the first time. Back up any files already on the drive before reformatting it.
Brands to consider
Toshiba
The Canvio Advance is a range of portable HDDs for storage and backups. Toshiba lists models with capacities of up to 4 TB, along with included backup and security software.
- Toshiba says it is powered via USB and features USB 3.2 Gen 1.
- Toshiba says the NTFS drive must be reformatted for the stated use with Mac. Software and password protection are no substitute for a second copy.
Western Digital
According to the manufacturer, the My Passport range includes a black 6 TB model, among other options, for larger collections.
- The manufacturer’s data sheet lists password protection, hardware encryption and backup software for the product range.
- The data sheet specifies a USB-A cable and notes that certain conditions apply to write access on macOS. Check the details for the specific model.
Samsung
The T7 Shield external SSD could be worth considering if you transfer files frequently. The specifications quoted here apply to the black 2 TB model MU-PE2T0S/EU.
- Samsung quotes read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1.000 MB/s, as well as an IP65 rating under controlled test conditions.
- The host device and cable must support USB 3.2 Gen 2 to reach maximum speeds. Samsung says liquid and dust damage is not covered by the warranty.
Kingston
The XS1000 is a compact external SSD range with 1 TB and 2 TB versions for accessing files on the go.
- Kingston quotes read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s and includes a USB-C-to-USB-A cable and an adapter.
- The listed capacities don’t necessarily make this range suitable for a particularly large collection.
Seagate
The One Touch HDD 4TB is another portable option for archiving.
- CHIP includes the 4 TB model in a selection of tested HDDs.
- This assessment doesn’t apply to every Seagate drive, and it doesn’t tell you whether 4 TB will be enough for your RAW collection.
Joybuy storage options
The Joybuy models below are external HDDs for storing scans and RAW files together. Compare capacities to find the right fit, and check the connections, file system and, for desktop models, power requirements.
No image available
WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C
A portable HDD option if you want to store scans and RAW files together.
5 TB; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 1; described as a portable 2.5-inch drive weighing 240 g.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Portable 6TB USB-C
The larger of the portable HDD options listed here could be a good choice for storing a sizeable collection in one place.
6 TB; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 1; described as a portable 2.5-inch drive weighing 240 g.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C
This portable HDD could be a good fit if your current data and expected additions will fit within 4 TB.
4 TB; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 1; described as a portable 2.5-inch drive weighing 240 g.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements 2TB Portable HDD, USB-C, exFAT
A compact storage option if your files will fit within 2 TB and you want to use the drive with different devices.
2 TB; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 1; exFAT; portable 2.5-inch drive. The product details say it works with Windows and macOS without reformatting.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Desktop 8TB, USB 3.0
This desktop drive could suit a large archive you plan to keep in one place, provided there’s room for an external power supply.
8 TB; USB 3.0; external power supply required. The product details list NTFS and say the drive needs to be reformatted for use with Mac.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is one external hard drive enough for scans and RAW files?
Not if it holds your only copy. Keep a separate backup and check that you can restore files from it. The BSI describes this as part of backing up your data, not as a legal requirement to have a particular number of drives.
Can I write to a drive set up for Windows without changing anything on a Mac?
It depends on the specific model and file system. Toshiba says the Canvio Advance uses NTFS and needs to be reformatted for Mac OS; Western Digital describes an NTFS driver or reformatting for the My Passport range. Check the details for your model before transferring files.
What should I check after setting up a backup?
Test whether you can actually restore selected files. The BSI points out that a backup must be restorable, too.
Do my personal scans and photos have to be stored on a particular type of hard drive?
Data protection rules don’t require every personal collection to be stored on a particular type of hard drive. The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information explains that the legal position depends on whether personal data is being processed and whether the activity remains exclusively personal or family-related. Encryption can protect personal information, but it isn’t a blanket requirement for a particular device.