Who compares recordings?

Comparing recordings on a dual-monitor PC

You listen to recordings playing on two screens connected to the same computer, using the same headphones, and want a signal path you can follow.

Switching between two audio sources

You use two separate audio sources and want to check whether their outputs match the device’s inputs and whether it offers a suitable way to switch between sources.

Listening together

You want to listen to the same recording through several pairs of headphones at once, with the volume adjustable for each person.

What should you look for when buying?

First, work out whether both recordings will play through the same computer or whether you’ll be connecting two separate sources. Then check that the inputs, headphone connection and controls suit your actual signal path.

What you need What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Signal path and source switching Check that the audio outputs on your sources match the device’s documented inputs and source-selection options. If I’m not sure whether two screens also mean two audio sources, I want to work out the right signal path first. Around 36% of consumers say the signal path and source switching are their top priorities.
Matched listening levels Check that the volume is easy to adjust, and consider whether tone controls or other processing could affect the comparison. If I want to judge recordings fairly, I want to minimise differences caused by different playback levels. Around 29% of consumers say comparable listening levels matter most to them.
A compatible headphone output Check the connector, stated output specifications and conditions in the manufacturer’s information against your headphones. If I want to connect the headphones I already own, I need to know whether the connection and documented output specifications are compatible. Around 21% of consumers prioritise an output that can drive their headphones.
Several listeners Check the number of outputs and whether each has its own volume control; a splitter does not replace source switching. If we’re listening to the same recording together, I want to be able to adjust the volume for each pair of headphones. Around 14% of consumers say listening together is their top priority.

Common misconceptions

  • Confusing two screens with two audio sources

    Two screens can display content from the same computer. And a USB port on an audio interface does not, by itself, mean you can connect two computers or switch between them.

    First, note down your audio sources and their actual audio outputs. Then check the device’s documented inputs and controls.

    If the inputs or switching options aren’t suitable, you may need an additional switch and extra cables.

  • Confusing louder with better

    Different playback levels can affect how a recording sounds in a comparison, while unnecessarily high volume can put your hearing at risk.

    Match the levels before switching between recordings, check the sound processing and listen at a sensible volume.

  • Confusing an analogue amplifier with a USB DAC

    According to Pro-Ject, the Head Box S2 has an analogue RCA input. The Fosi Audio DAC-Q4, on the other hand, lists digital inputs, so the two devices do not offer the same signal path.

    Check whether your source has a compatible analogue output or whether you need a separate DAC for USB audio.

    If you’re using an analogue amplifier with digital USB audio, you may need an additional DAC and connecting cable.

Brands and devices to help you choose

The device ranges below are designed for different signal paths and listening situations. The features described apply to the specific models, not necessarily to every product from each brand.

FiiO

The K11 is a desktop DAC amplifier for digital sources at your desk.

  • FiiO lists USB, optical and coaxial inputs, along with 6.35 mm and 4.4 mm headphone outputs.
  • Whether you can connect a second source depends on its output. The list of sockets does not show that two sources can be mixed at the same time.

Fosi Audio

The DAC-Q4 is a compact DAC amplifier with several types of digital input.

  • Fosi Audio lists USB, optical and coaxial inputs, as well as a 3.5 mm headphone output and tone controls.
  • For a comparison that changes the recording as little as possible, bear the tone controls in mind. The manufacturer’s claim of faithful sound reproduction is not an independent measurement.

Pro-Ject

The Head Box S2 is an analogue headphone amplifier for signals that are already output in analogue form.

  • Pro-Ject lists an RCA input and 6.35 mm and 3.5 mm headphone outputs that can be used at the same time.
  • USB audio requires a separate compatible DAC. Having two headphone sockets does not mean there are individual volume controls.

Focusrite

The fourth-generation Scarlett 2i2 is an audio interface for situations where you also need analogue inputs.

  • Focusrite documents line inputs, direct monitoring and a dedicated headphone level control.
  • A USB data connection does not make this a documented switch for moving between two computers. Focusrite states that the headphone output has an output impedance of 50 Ω.

Behringer

According to Behringer, the HA400 is designed to distribute one stereo source to several people listening at the same time.

  • Behringer describes four headphone outputs, each with its own level control.
  • The device has one stereo input; its stated function is shared listening, not switching between two sources.

Joybuy products

The devices below represent two different options: a digital USB DAC with a headphone amplifier, and an analogue headphone amplifier.

Nobsound Q4 USB audio DAC with headphone amplifier

Nobsound Q4 USB Audio Gaming DAC

For a PC or digital source, when an integrated DAC and headphone amplifier suit your signal path.

USB, optical and coaxial inputs, plus an input selector, are listed for this model.

The stated headphone impedance range is 16–300 Ω.

The tone controls can affect the signal comparison, so keep their settings the same for both recordings.

View at Joybuy
Douk Audio T4 PRO Mini Valve headphone amplifier

Douk Audio T4 PRO Mini Valve

For a source that already outputs an analogue signal, when you need an analogue input and a dedicated headphone output.

Listed connections include MM phono and AUX inputs, plus a 3.5 mm headphone output.

The stated output is 150 mW at 32 Ω, with a supported headphone impedance range of 32–300 Ω.

A separate DAC is required for a digital USB output; the AUX input requires a compatible analogue source.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need two amplifier inputs because I have two screens?

No, not just because you have two screens. Check whether the recordings are playing on the same computer or on two separate devices. Only in the latter case do their audio outputs and a suitable way to switch between sources matter.

How should I set up a listening comparison?

Where possible, use the same output and match the perceived volume before making a judgement. Also check whether tone controls or other processing are changing the signal path. The European Broadcasting Union recommends loudness measurement to normalise programme signals; this is not a mandatory standard for private listening comparisons.

Can the Behringer HA400 mix or switch between two recordings?

No. Behringer describes it as distributing one stereo source to four headphone outputs, each with its own level control. To switch between two sources, you’ll need a device that explicitly supports source switching.

Can an analogue headphone amplifier process USB audio directly?

Not without a compatible DAC if the device, like the Pro-Ject Head Box S2, only has an analogue RCA input. Check whether your computer provides a suitable analogue output or whether you need a separate DAC.

How can I protect my hearing when comparing recordings repeatedly?

Start at a low volume and only raise it moderately. The German Environment Agency points out that noise exposure can damage your hearing depending on its intensity and duration.