Who is this comparison for?

Online listeners in a social setting

You listen to the book club through a device while other conversations are going on nearby. The key is to try the headphones with spoken audio and realistic background conversations.

Active online participants

You want to do more than just listen; you want to contribute too. That means the microphone, connection and meeting software you use should all factor into your buying decision. Jabra describes the Evolve2 65 Flex as a headset for calls.

Listeners who want to stay connected to the room

You want to listen to audio while still being aware of people nearby, or switch between listening and talking in person. Sennheiser and Shokz describe open designs as a way to stay connected to your surroundings.

What should you look for when buying?

First, work out whether the book club discussion will be streamed or whether everyone will be in the same room. This will help you decide how much noise isolation you need, as well as what kind of microphone and connection to look for and how much you want to stay aware of your surroundings.

What you need What to look for Who it matters most to
Understand streamed speech Try a closed fit, passive noise isolation and ANC with speech and realistic background conversations. If I want to follow the streamed discussion despite conversations nearby, I don’t want the voices to compete with each other. Around 36% of consumers prioritise understanding speech despite background conversations.
Make sure others can hear me Check the microphone, connection option and meeting software together; test how your voice sounds in the environment where you’ll actually use it. If I regularly join in online, the other participants need to be able to understand me. Around 29% of consumers make transmitting their own speech their main priority.
Stay connected to the room Consider whether an open design, an easily accessible transparency mode or listening without headphones would suit the session. If people are in the same room, I want to stay approachable and be aware of them. Around 21% of consumers prioritise staying connected to their surroundings.
Listen comfortably during long sessions Check the pressure, fit and controls over the length of a typical session. Don’t simply turn up the volume when there’s background noise. If a session runs long, I want to listen comfortably without continually turning up the volume to compete with other conversations. Around 14% of consumers put comfortable listening during longer sessions first.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming ANC selectively filters out other people’s voices

    Conversations nearby are not the same as steady background noise. The BAuA’s measurements of headphones from 2019 and 2020 do not support a blanket claim that they suppress background speech.

    Try the headphones with streamed speech and realistic background conversations, and pay attention to passive noise isolation too.

  • Confusing microphone noise filtering with noise isolation for your own ears

    During an online conversation, what you hear and what your microphone transmits are two separate considerations. Jabra’s claims about filtering background noise relate to call transmission and come from the manufacturer.

    Test the microphone and what you hear separately using the software you plan to use.

  • Choosing maximum noise isolation for an in-person book club

    If the people whose voices matter most are in the same room, strong noise isolation could make it harder to hear them.

    First, check whether the audio will be streamed. If you want to stay aware of the room, consider an open design or listening without headphones.

Relevant brands at a glance

Sony

The WH-1000XM6 is a closed-back over-ear headphone with switchable ambient sound control.

  • Sony lists Speak-to-Chat and Multipoint for this model. Speak-to-Chat pauses playback when you start speaking.
  • This feature doesn’t prove that other people’s background conversations are filtered out.

Sennheiser

ACCENTUM Wireless is a closed-back headphone with ANC and a transparency mode. ACCENTUM Open is a separate option for staying aware of your surroundings.

  • Sennheiser lists a podcast mode among the features of ACCENTUM Wireless.
  • Manufacturer claims about features and battery life are not an independent assessment of speech intelligibility. The open version won’t isolate you from background conversations in the same way as closed-back headphones.

Jabra

The Evolve2 65 Flex is designed for people who want to speak during online meetings.

  • Jabra lists ANC and ClearVoice microphone technology.
  • Claims about filtering background noise come from the manufacturer. When choosing, make sure you select the right USB or meeting-specific variant.

Shokz

OpenFit 2 is an open-ear headphone for situations where you want to listen to audio while remaining aware of people in the room.

  • Shokz lists an open design and physical buttons.
  • Staying aware of your surroundings can be a drawback if you want to minimise distractions from nearby conversations.

Bose

The 2nd-generation QuietComfort Ultra Headphones are another closed-back ANC option.

  • Bose lists adjustable noise cancellation and removable ear cushions.
  • The manufacturer’s claims about noise cancellation don’t prove that book club voices will disappear.

Joybuy products for streamed book club discussions

This selection features closed-back over-ear headphones with ANC for streamed book club discussions. Even so, check how well you can understand speech in the kind of noise you’ll be listening in.

Bose QuietComfort Headphones (2nd Gen), Eucalyptus Green

Bose QuietComfort Headphones (2nd Gen), Eucalyptus Green

For streamed book club discussions, with the option to switch between Quiet and Aware modes. This is no substitute for testing them with background conversations.

Product details list ANC, Bluetooth 5.4 and up to 24 hours of battery life.

View at Joybuy
Sennheiser Momentum 5 Wireless over-ear headphones

Sennheiser Momentum 5 Wireless

The closed-back over-ear design and ANC may suit streamed discussions, but try them for yourself to see whether they block enough background noise.

Product details list up to 57 hours of battery life with ANC and Bluetooth 5.4.

View at Joybuy
Sennheiser ACCENTUM Plus Wireless, Black

Sennheiser ACCENTUM Plus Wireless, Black

Closed-back headphones with ANC for streamed book club discussions. Check how well they block conversations nearby in the environment where you’ll be listening.

Product details list Multipoint, Bluetooth 5.2 with aptX and up to 50 hours of battery life.

View at Joybuy
Apple AirPods Max, Blue

Apple AirPods Max, Blue

ANC and transparency mode offer different settings for streamed audio and staying aware of your surroundings.

Product details list up to 20 hours of battery life with ANC, USB-C charging and three microphones for voice pickup. Compatible devices listed include iPhone, iPad and Mac.

View at Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Ultra 2 Gen, Driftwood Sand

Bose QuietComfort Ultra 2 Gen, Driftwood Sand

Closed-back over-ear headphones with ANC for streamed book club discussions. ANC alone doesn’t prove that background speech is selectively suppressed.

Product details list Multipoint and up to 30 hours of battery life. Bluetooth and wired playback are listed; the headphones weigh 250 g.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can ANC block out other conversations while I listen to an online book club?

Don’t rely on it alone: the BAuA found no particular potential for selectively suppressing background speech in the headphones it examined in 2019 and 2020. This finding doesn’t cover every model available today, so test the fit and how well you can understand speech in your own surroundings.

What should I set up before my first online session?

Connect the headset to the device you’ll actually use and check the input and output devices in your meeting software. If you want to switch between devices, make sure the version you choose supports the connection you need. A test call will show you which microphone is actually being used.

Should I simply turn up the volume to drown out background conversations?

No, don’t just keep turning it up. The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends well-fitting headphones and, where appropriate, noise-cancelling headphones to reduce the need to raise the volume in noisy surroundings.

What are my rights when shopping online in Germany?

For a qualifying distance purchase from a trader in the EU, you generally have 14 days from receiving the goods to cancel the contract. Exceptions and return costs depend on the circumstances. Faulty goods are also covered by a statutory guarantee of at least two years from receipt. This is separate from any voluntary manufacturer’s warranty.