City walkers who like to stay alert
You listen to directions near junctions and want to remain aware of your surroundings. An open-ear design is one option, but it doesn’t guarantee that you’ll hear every traffic sound.
For listening to an audio guide on footpaths, open-ear headphones or sealed in-ear headphones with an easy-to-access ambient mode are both options. With either, you’ll need to pay close attention to the recording and traffic conditions. If quiet speech is hard to make out, a well-fitting sealed in-ear headphone may help, but it will reduce your awareness of your surroundings. If you’d rather not charge a headphone battery, consider a wired model, provided its connection and cable are suitable for your playback device and route.
You listen to directions near junctions and want to remain aware of your surroundings. An open-ear design is one option, but it doesn’t guarantee that you’ll hear every traffic sound.
You want to understand spoken passages and be able to switch between noise isolation and awareness of your surroundings. Fit, volume and how easy it is to control the mode all play a part.
You’d prefer headphones without their own battery and can check before buying whether your playback device has a suitable wired connection.
A good fit if: You want to stay aware of your surroundings while listening on footpaths, and speech is clear at your usual listening volume.
The trade-off: Ambient noise can also reach your ears and drown out quiet passages.
A good fit if: You want to switch between greater isolation for the recording and an ambient mode; Sony lists these features for the WF-C710N.
The trade-off: Isolation can affect your awareness of traffic; an ambient mode is no guarantee of safety.
A good fit if: Your playback device has a suitable 3.5-mm output, or you’ve already checked that a compatible adapter will work, and you don’t want to charge a headphone battery.
The trade-off: The connection and cable need to work with your device and suit you when walking; the Sennheiser IE 200 isn’t specifically marketed as an accessory for audio guides.
| What matters | What to check before buying | Who is this important to? |
|---|---|---|
| Being aware of your surroundings while walking | Check for an open-ear design or an accessible ambient mode, and see whether speech is clear at a low volume on your usual route. | If I want to stay aware of my surroundings at junctions while listening, I look for an open-ear design or an easy-to-use ambient mode. Around 36% of consumers put awareness of their surroundings first. |
| Understanding speech amid ambient noise | Check the fit, speech clarity and how easy it is to pause or change modes; don’t simply turn the volume up to overcome distracting noise. | If I want to understand quiet directions even when ambient noise changes, I check the fit and controls in advance. Around 29% of consumers prioritise speech clarity. |
| A comfortable fit on longer walks | For ear-hook headphones, check their position; for in-ear headphones, check the available tip sizes. Try them on while moving your head. | If I’m out for a longer walk, I want a comfortable fit that stays in place as I move. Around 21% of consumers prioritise comfort while wearing and moving. |
| Listening without a headphone battery | Check that you have a suitable audio output or adapter, and consider how the cable will sit while you walk. | If I don’t want to worry about my headphone battery on a longer route, I might choose a wired model. Around 14% of consumers prioritise listening without a headphone battery. |
An open-ear design lets ambient sound reach your ears, but it can’t guarantee that you’ll stay alert or hear every signal.
Keep the recording quiet and pause it when you need to assess traffic or cross a road. Germany’s Road Traffic Regulations require care and consideration; the Federal Ministry of Justice’s Laws on the Internet explains this in sections 1 and 25 of the StVO.
Noise isolation and awareness of your surroundings are useful in different situations. Listening at a high volume for long periods can also damage your hearing.
Before setting off, check how to change modes and pause the recording. Don’t rely on noise isolation instead of assessing traffic for yourself.
The Sennheiser IE 200 has a 3.5-mm plug, which won’t necessarily fit every playback device.
Before buying, check the audio output, whether any adapter you need will work, and how the cable sits while you walk.
Sony offers the LinkBuds Open, with an open ring design, and the WF-C710N, sealed in-ear headphones with noise cancelling and Ambient Sound.
The OpenFit 2 are open-ear headphones with ear hooks, for anyone who doesn’t want a sealed fit in the ear canal.
The AeroFit 2 are open-ear headphones with adjustable ear-hook positions, which you can try to find the right fit for your ears.
The IE 200 are wired, sealed in-ear monitors for use with a playback device that has a suitable 3.5-mm connection.
The products listed here are open-ear headphones for anyone who wants to stay aware of ambient noise while listening on footpaths. Open-ear doesn’t mean you’ll hear every traffic sound.
No image available
The open clip-on design is an option if you want to stay aware of ambient noise while listening to a recording.
The product description lists three listening modes and a Vocal Boost mode for spoken content.
No image available
The open-ear design is one way to avoid completely blocking out your surroundings while listening.
The product description lists Bluetooth 5.4 and up to 7.5 hours of playback per charge.
No image available
The open ring design is worth considering if you want to stay aware of your surroundings while listening on footpaths.
No image available
The open-ear design and adjustable ear hooks are an option if you want to stay aware of your surroundings and adjust the fit.
The product description lists Bluetooth 5.4 and up to 10 hours of playback per charge.
No image available
The open ring design could be a good fit if you want to stay aware of ambient noise while listening to a recording.
The product description lists Bluetooth 5.3 and up to 8 hours of playback per charge.
The audio guide needs to be available on your playback device or in the app you’re using; the headphones play the recording. Before setting off, test a passage without an internet connection and check that pause and resume work.
Check the fit while moving your head. For the soundcore AeroFit 2, the manufacturer describes four ear-hook positions and recommends wiping the headphones and charging case dry after use, as well as carefully cleaning any dirty charging contacts.
Check whether your device needs an adapter for 3.5-mm headphones, and whether replacement parts or tips are available for the model you want. A voluntary manufacturer’s warranty is not the same as your statutory consumer rights against the seller; if a product is faulty, the first step is for the seller to provide a remedy.
The sections of the StVO reviewed, 1 and 25, do not impose a blanket ban on people listening through headphones while walking. The Federal Ministry of Justice’s Laws on the Internet explains the duty to take care and show consideration, as well as the need to watch for vehicle traffic when crossing. Section 23(1) of the StVO concerns impaired hearing while driving a vehicle; it is not a specific rule about pedestrians wearing headphones. Pause the recording when crossing if you can’t otherwise assess the traffic conditions adequately.