Who records garden stories?

Garden storytellers recording near a fan

You’ll usually be speaking on your own and want to check with a test recording that your voice is still clear with the fan running. Logitech describes the H390 as having microphone noise cancellation, while Audio-Technica specifies a directional dynamic microphone for the BPHS1. Neither claim replaces testing in the conditions where you’ll be recording.

Collectors of stories from several people

If different people will be telling stories, decide in advance whether a headset worn by one person will be enough for your planned recording, or whether each voice needs its own recording channel. The headset microphones described here are designed to pick up the voice of the person wearing them.

People recording in different locations

If you switch between a computer and a mobile recording setup, check that the specific connection type works with your device and recording app. Jabra notes that not all USB-C devices or apps support audio with the Evolve2 40 SE.

What should you look for when buying?

What you need What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Your voice clearly heard over fan noise Check the microphone position and make a test recording in your chosen location with the fan running. If I’m usually speaking on my own, I want my voice to come through clearly even with the fan running. This would be the main priority for around 36 % of consumers.
Clear recordings of several speakers Decide who will be speaking and whether each voice needs its own recording channel. If several members of the garden group are equally important, I don’t want to assume that a headset worn by one person will pick up everyone. Around 29 % of consumers would focus mainly on this.
Connection and recording location Check that the USB-A or USB-C version, or the microphone and headphone connectors, match your recording device. If I switch between devices or recording locations, the connection needs to work with both my device and app. Around 21 % of consumers would put device compatibility first.
Monitoring and awareness of your surroundings Try the headset on to check whether you can monitor the recording while still hearing important sounds around you. If I want to stay aware of my surroundings while recording, I also need to consider how the headset affects what I can hear. Around 14 % of consumers would prioritise this.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming microphone noise cancellation means you’ll hear less noise yourself

    Claims about microphone features and noise isolation from the ear cushions describe different things. A claim about microphone noise cancellation doesn’t show how quiet the headset will sound to you.

    Test the recording and your own listening experience separately in the conditions you plan to use it in.

  • Assuming one headset will be enough for a full interview

    The headset microphones described here are designed to pick up the voice of the person wearing them; this doesn’t mean they’ll record a group evenly.

    Before choosing your equipment, decide which voices will need their own recording channel.

    You may need extra microphones and suitable recording inputs for additional speakers.

  • Assuming a broadcast headset will plug straight in via USB

    The Audio-Technica BPHS1 has separate microphone and headphone connectors, including an XLR microphone connector and a 6.3 mm headphone plug.

    Check that both connectors are compatible with your recording device before you buy.

    Depending on your existing equipment, you may need a compatible audio interface or recording device.

Brands to consider

Audio-Technica

The BPHS1 is a broadcast headset for interviews and announcements, designed for setups with separate microphone and headphone connections.

  • Audio-Technica specifies a directional dynamic microphone, closed-back earcups and a cable with an XLR microphone connector and a 6.3 mm headphone plug for the BPHS1.
  • These specifications don’t confirm a direct USB connection or any measured reduction in fan noise.

Logitech

The H390 could be an option for recording your own voice on a compatible computer.

  • Logitech specifies microphone noise cancellation, an adjustable microphone boom and in-line controls.
  • USB-A and USB-C are different versions, so check which one you’re buying. The manufacturer’s claim isn’t an independent test with a fan running.

Jabra

The wired Evolve2 40 SE is a communications headset option where the connection type and recording the voice of one person wearing it are important considerations.

  • Jabra describes three microphones and passive noise isolation from the ear cushions.
  • The manual distinguishes between USB-A and USB-C and notes that not all USB-C mobile devices or apps support audio. This doesn’t mean it will work with every mobile recording app.

Poly

The Blackwire 5200 series includes wired communications headsets with different wearing styles and connection options.

  • HP specifies a directional microphone, passive noise isolation around the ears, USB-C with a USB-A adapter and a 3.5 mm connector for the series.
  • The series includes different models. Check the connectors and what’s included with the specific version; the series specifications aren’t an independent recording test with a fan running.

Joybuy products

This selection from Joybuy features gaming headsets with microphones designed to pick up the voice of the person wearing them. Check the specific connection type and make a test recording with the fan running; the product specifications don’t prove any measured reduction in this type of noise.

JBL Quantum 360P over-ear wireless gaming headset, white

JBL Quantum 360P over-ear wireless gaming headset, white

Could be suitable for recording one speaker, provided the connection is compatible with your recording device.

The product description specifies a directional boom microphone with echo cancellation, Bluetooth and a detachable 3.5 mm cable. This isn’t a measurement of recording performance with fan noise.

View at Joybuy
ONIKUMA GT889 wireless gaming headset

ONIKUMA GT889 wireless gaming headset

Could be tested for recording the wearer’s voice, provided one of the listed connection options is compatible with your recording device.

The product description specifies a flexible, detachable microphone, as well as 2.4 GHz wireless, Bluetooth and a wired connection. The stated noise cancellation doesn’t prove how well it works with a fan.

View at Joybuy
Razer Barracuda wireless multiplatform headset, black

Razer Barracuda wireless multiplatform headset, black

Could be suitable for one speaker, provided the connection works with your recording device and app.

The product description specifies built-in beamforming microphones and adjustable microphone noise cancellation. Razer HyperSpeed Wireless and Bluetooth are listed as wireless connections; this doesn’t prove how well it works with fan noise.

View at Joybuy
Razer Kraken Kitty V2 wired RGB headset, black

Razer Kraken Kitty V2 wired RGB headset, black

Could be tested for wired voice recording with a compatible USB-A device.

The product description specifies a flexibly adjustable microphone and a USB-A connection with a 2 m cable. The stated noise cancellation doesn’t prove how well it records with fan noise.

View at Joybuy
EDIFIER G2II USB gaming headset, white

EDIFIER G2II USB gaming headset, white

Could be suitable for recording one voice, provided the USB connection is compatible with your recording device.

The product description specifies a rotating, lockable microphone and compatibility with PC, PS4 and Mac. The stated noise cancellation doesn’t prove how well it works with a fan.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is “noise cancelling” enough to ensure a clear recording next to a fan?

No. It doesn’t prove that a headset is suitable for this specific situation. Logitech describes the H390 as having microphone noise cancellation, while Audio-Technica says the BPHS1 picks up less sound outside the microphone’s main axis. Record your own voice with the fan actually running to see how it sounds.

Can I use a USB-C headset to record on any smartphone?

No. Jabra notes that not all USB-C devices or apps support the Evolve2 40 SE’s audio connection. Check your specific device and recording app.

What extra equipment do I need for the Audio-Technica BPHS1?

The BPHS1 is specified with a 3-pin XLR plug for the microphone and a 6.3 mm plug for the headphones. Check whether your recording device has both connections, or what compatible audio equipment you’ll need.

Who is responsible for the statutory guarantee if a headset is faulty?

For a consumer purchase in the EU, statutory rights against the seller are separate from a voluntary manufacturer’s guarantee. The European Union’s consumer information explains that, in the event of qualifying faults, you can get a repair or replacement free of charge, and that the statutory minimum period is two years.

Can I record conversations with other members of the garden group without asking?

Don’t start recording until you’ve checked that you’re allowed to do so. Under § 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB), unauthorised recording of another person’s non-public spoken words is covered by the law; the German Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice explain this provision. Whether a particular conversation is non-public, and what other requirements apply to processing or publishing it, depends on the circumstances.