Which type of scanner is right for you?

For anyone caring for fragile books

If you want to capture bound or fragile originals, first check how far the particular book can be opened and whether an overhead scan would be better for its condition. CZUR describes its ET range as capturing images without putting pressure on the spine.

For anyone creating searchable sources

If you want to find names and passages again for your school project, you’ll need suitable text recognition as well as an image of each page. The German Research Foundation points to possible recognition errors with columns and marginal notes, so check recognised text against the image.

For project groups working with different materials

If you also need to capture larger pages, photos or documents, compare the area you actually need to scan with the size of your materials. A3 or A4 specifications apply to particular models, such as those from VIISAN, IRIS or Epson.

What should you look for when choosing?

Overhead scanner for bound books

A good fit if: you need to capture many pages from a bound book without pressing them against a glass surface to scan them.

Things to consider: Check the available area with the book open, and test the crease correction and OCR on sample pages. Also find out how far the original can be opened.

Book-edge flatbed scanner

A good fit if: the book is sturdy enough to lie flat and you want to scan one page at a time using a specially designed book edge.

Things to consider: Plustek lists a 2-mm book edge for the OpticBook 4800; its stated scanning area is smaller than an A3 double-page spread.

General-purpose A4 flatbed scanner

A good fit if: you only need to capture a few suitable loose items, or additional photos and unbound documents.

Things to consider: A general-purpose A4 model won’t necessarily offer a book edge or page-curvature correction. Its scanning area needs to suit the material you’re scanning.

For your school project, the key priorities will depend on the book’s condition, whether you need searchable text, the format and the equipment you already have.

What matters What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Handling the original with care Capture method and book mode; first check how far the particular book can be opened. If I’m capturing a bound or fragile original, I don’t want to press it against a glass surface to scan it. Consumers who prioritise protecting the book are estimated to make up around 33%.
Searchable text Check the OCR function and output formats for the exact model; test the crease, small print and marginal notes on sample pages. For my research, I want to find names and references again using text search, then check recognised passages against the page image. Consumers whose main priority is searchable text are estimated to make up around 27%.
A suitable scanning area Measure the largest book when open and compare it with the stated area for the exact model; check the difference between single-page and double-page modes. If the size of my books or inserts determines which device I choose, I want to be sure beforehand that they’ll fit in the scanning area. Consumers whose main priority is a suitable format are estimated to make up around 20%.
Time and equipment available Check the operating system, software, capture method and output formats for the exact model against the school computer. For a limited-scope project, I want to know whether I can manage scanning and file organisation with the equipment I already have. Consumers who prioritise a practical workflow are estimated to make up around 20%.

Common mistakes when choosing

  • Assuming OCR produces a flawless transcript

    Columns or marginal notes in historical materials can disrupt the recognised reading order. The German Research Foundation describes these as potential sources of error when recognising text in historical printed works.

    Keep the page images and compare recognised passages from typical book pages against the images.

    Allow time to check and correct the recognised text.

  • Comparing megapixels or dpi alone

    Scanning area, sensor resolution and interpolated software resolution are different specifications. An A4 flatbed scanner and an A3 overhead scanner don’t solve the same format requirements.

    Measure the book when open and compare its dimensions with the scanning area of the exact model. Test the crease and image edges using a sample page.

    If the format or crease isn’t captured well enough, you may need to scan it again.

  • Assuming a school project automatically gives you permission to publish

    The rules for use in teaching and public sharing are different. Section 60a of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) sets out limits and exceptions for certain uses in teaching.

    Consider the purpose and intended audience separately, and check the rights to the specific work before sharing or publishing scans. The applicable legal requirements will depend on the circumstances.

Key brands at a glance

CZUR

The ET range includes overhead scanners for bound books. These details apply to this product range, not every model from the brand.

  • CZUR describes the ET range as offering contact-free capture, page-curvature correction and OCR.
  • Check the features and correction results on the specific model and sample pages; these functions don’t guarantee error-free capture of fragile originals.

VIISAN

The VK16 is marketed as an A3 book scanner and document camera.

  • VIISAN lists a 16-MP sensor, page splitting and OCR output for the VK16.
  • The manufacturer recommends checking image edges and legibility before saving; these specifications don’t necessarily apply to other VIISAN devices.

IRIS

According to IRIS, the IRIScan Desk 7 Pro combines A3 capture with OCR output and document camera functions.

  • IRIS’s model overview lists capture and export features for the Desk 7 Pro.
  • Distinguish sensor resolution from interpolated software resolution, and check the specifications for the exact version.

Plustek

The OpticBook 4800 is a book-edge flatbed alternative for books that can be placed on the scanner one page at a time.

  • Plustek lists a 2-mm book edge for this model.
  • The specifications list Windows operating systems and a scanning area smaller than an A3 double-page spread; check that both suit your project.

Epson

The Perfection V39II is a general-purpose A4 flatbed scanner for suitable loose items and additional photos or documents.

  • Epson Deutschland lists A4, 4.800 dpi and one-touch buttons for this model.
  • This model isn’t described as an overhead or book-edge solution; a high dpi specification alone won’t solve the problem of a tight book crease.

Suitable products on Joybuy

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Which scanning method is best for a fragile local history book?

If the book shouldn’t be laid flat, an overhead scanner is a sensible option. You’ll need to check separately whether, and how far, the particular original can be opened. Image correction can’t replace an assessment of the book’s condition.

How can I check whether the files will work for my school project?

Start by creating sample scans featuring the book crease, small print and any marginal notes. Check the image edges, page order and legibility in the page images, then compare recognised text against them. Historical layouts can still lead to an incorrect reading order, even when OCR is used.

What software and system requirements should I check before buying?

Check which scanning software and output formats are intended for the specific model, and whether they’ll work with your school computer. Also make sure the operating system specifications match the system you’ll actually be using.

Can a school project digitise entire local history books and publish them online?

There’s no blanket yes-or-no answer. Under the conditions set out in Section 60a of the German Copyright Act (UrhG), up to 15 per cent of a published work may generally be reproduced for non-commercial teaching purposes at educational institutions; subsections 2 and 3 set out exceptions and exclusions. Other rules may apply to certain institutions if the relevant conditions are met, such as Section 60f in conjunction with Section 60e of the UrhG. This doesn’t automatically allow you to publish complete books that are still protected by copyright. Check the work, rights, purpose and intended audience before sharing it. Source: Gesetze im Internet, Federal Republic of Germany.

Is an old or out-of-print book automatically free to use?

No. A book’s age or lack of availability for purchase doesn’t in itself mean you’re free to use it. The German Digital Library describes specific conditions for cultural heritage institutions wishing to use certain unavailable works that are still protected by copyright. Check the rights to the specific work and the requirements for your intended use.