Which scanning option is right for you?

Students with loose A3 maps

If you want to capture a loose map in one go as completely as possible, and also print study materials, compare its dimensions with the flatbed scanning area. Brother lists a flatbed size of up to 297 × 431.8 mm for the MFC-J6955DW.

Students with delicate originals

For fragile, folded or bound maps, first check whether they can be handled safely. The Library of Congress recommends assessing an item’s condition and potential risk of damage before digitising it.

Students short on space

If you mainly scan smaller originals and need a printer, an A4 model could be an option. Canon lists the PIXMA TS7650i as measuring 374 × 350 × 168 mm with its trays retracted. These figures do not include the extra space needed when using it.

What should you look for when buying?

Consideration What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Map size and flatbed area Compare your map’s dimensions with the stated maximum flatbed size; check the print size and ADF size separately. If you want to capture a loose map as completely as possible in one go, the actual flatbed area matters. Around 26% of consumers prioritise map size.
Protecting the original Consider its condition, tears, folds and binding; for maps at risk of damage, check which scanning method is suitable. If I have a delicate original, I don’t want to rely on the document feeder alone to handle it safely. Around 26% of consumers put protecting the original first.
Clarity of fine details Choose a scan resolution that suits the original size and intended use; check small labels by viewing a cropped section. If I need to read small place names or fine lines, the digital copy should be suitable for its intended use. Around 21% of consumers focus on making fine details legible.
Space at home Check the printer’s dimensions, as well as the room needed to open the lid and position the map where you plan to use it. If space is limited, I want to know whether the printer and its usable flatbed will fit in my workspace. Around 16% of consumers prioritise the space available.
Consumables and printing costs Consider your own print volume, compatible ink or cartridges, and the paper you’ll need. If I print regularly as well as scan, I want to choose consumables that suit how I use the printer. Around 11% of consumers focus on ongoing printing costs.

Which mistakes should you avoid?

  • Assuming A3 printing means A3 scanning

    A printer may handle A3 printing but only scan up to A4. The Brother MFC-J5740DW is limited to A4 for scanning and copying.

    Before choosing a model, check the flatbed specifications for that particular printer and compare them with your map.

    If the map doesn’t fit on the flatbed, you’ll need another scanning solution.

  • Assuming the automatic document feeder is gentle enough

    An ADF is no guarantee that fragile or folded historical maps can be fed through safely.

    Check the condition and stability of the original. If it’s at risk of damage, find out in advance which scanning method is suitable.

  • Turning page yields straight into the cost of printing a map

    Advertised yields don’t automatically tell you how much ink and paper your particular prints will use. The HP OfficeJet Pro 9730 may use dynamic security measures to block cartridges with a non-HP chip.

    Compare consumables and paper based on how you plan to use the printer, and check cartridge compatibility for the HP model.

Key brands at a glance

Brother

Brother offers both A3 scanning options and A3 printers with a smaller scan size.

  • Brother lists a flatbed size of up to 297 × 431.8 mm for the MFC-J6955DW.
  • The MFC-J5740DW also prints in A3, but Brother says it only scans up to A4. The flatbed size alone doesn’t tell you whether a delicate original can be placed on it safely.

HP

According to HP, the OfficeJet Pro 9730 combines an A3/Tabloid flatbed scanner with A3 printing.

  • The A3/Tabloid flatbed size is a useful specification for maps that fit on the designated area.
  • HP notes that dynamic security measures may block cartridges with a non-HP chip. This says nothing about the quality of scans of historical maps.

Epson

According to Epson, the EcoTank ET-16605 offers A3 scanning and A3+ printing, with refillable ink tanks.

  • The ink tank system may suit students who print regularly as well as scan.
  • Stated page yields don’t predict the individual cost of printing maps.

Canon

According to Canon, the PIXMA TS7650i is an A4 option for smaller originals and study materials.

  • Canon lists the printer’s dimensions as 374 × 350 × 168 mm with its trays retracted.
  • The printer is designed for A4 scanning, so it isn’t suitable for capturing a larger map in its entirety. The stated dimensions don’t include the extra space needed when it’s in use.

Plustek

The OpticSlim 1180 is a standalone A3 flatbed scanner for situations where digitising matters more than having an integrated printer.

  • Plustek lists a maximum original size of 29.7 × 43.1 cm.
  • The device doesn’t replace a printer, and it doesn’t automatically resolve whether an oversized or particularly delicate original can be placed on it safely.

Joybuy products for suitable scanning tasks

The multifunction printers below are designed for flatbed scanning. Before buying, check that your particular map fits on the stated scanning area.

PANTUM BM2300NW A4 mono laser multifunction printer

PANTUM BM2300NW A4 mono laser multifunction printer

This A4 multifunction printer may suit smaller maps that fit on the flatbed, as well as additional printing tasks. Check the scanning area of the specific model against your map.

The product name specifies mono laser printing, 22 ppm, dual-band Wi-Fi and Ethernet. The A4 designation in the product name doesn’t confirm the exact dimensions of the flatbed.

View at Joybuy
HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3302sdwg colour laser multifunction printer

HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3302sdwg

As a multifunction printer with a flatbed scanner, it may suit loose maps, provided they fit on the scanning area. Check the dimensions before choosing.

The product name identifies this model as a colour laser multifunction printer.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is a printer with A3 printing suitable for A3 maps?

No. You need to check the print and scan sizes separately. Brother lists the MFC-J5740DW as printing in A3, but only scanning and copying up to A4. If you want to capture a map in its entirety, the flatbed area is what matters.

Should I feed an old map through the automatic document feeder?

Not simply because the printer has an ADF. First assess the map’s condition and the risk of damage. The Library of Congress recommends checking that it can be handled safely and choosing a suitable scanning method in advance.

What resolution do I need for small place names?

Choose a scan resolution that suits the original size and the size at which you plan to view or print it. The German Federal Archives generally digitises at 400 ppi based on the original size, and distinguishes scan ppi from print dpi. This is an example of practice, not a universal minimum requirement for every personal scanning project.

How do I compare ongoing printing costs?

Compare cartridges or ink bottles, and the paper you’ll need, with your expected print volume. Advertised page yields aren’t a reliable way to calculate the cost of maps with large printed areas. Also check that the consumables you plan to use are compatible.

Can I upload private scans of maps for everyone to see?

Not just because private copying is permitted. Under certain conditions, § 53 UrhG allows individual copies for private use, but also states that these copies must not be distributed or used for public display. You’ll need to check separately whether other rights or permissions apply to a particular map.