Which switch is right for you?

Cluster builders with multiple nodes

If you want to connect nodes, a router and perhaps a NAS in a small space, the key considerations are the number of ports you need and whether to choose Gigabit or 2.5 Gbit/s. Model specifications from TP-Link Germany and NETGEAR can help you understand the differences.

Home lab users with VLANs

If you want to segment lab traffic, you need verifiable management features, not simply extra LAN ports. TP-Link Germany and Zyxel Networks document these features for certain managed models.

Users with a quiet desk setup

If the switch will be within earshot, check the fan specifications and dimensions of the exact variant as well as the number of ports. Product information from TP-Link Germany, NETGEAR and Zyxel Networks covers different models and designs.

What should you consider when choosing?

First decide whether a shared network will do or whether you need VLAN segmentation. Then check that the required port speeds and dimensions suit your devices and available space.

Consideration What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Ports and footprint Count every connection, including the uplink; check the dimensions and mounting options of the exact variant against the space available. If I need to fit nodes, an uplink and other devices into a small space, I don’t want to get the port count or footprint wrong. Around 29% of consumers prioritise having enough ports and suitable dimensions.
Speed Compare the interfaces on the nodes, NAS and required uplinks; consider both ends of every important connection. If I want more than Gigabit between nodes or to the NAS, the devices along each data path need to support it. Around 24% of consumers prioritise suitable speeds across these connections.
VLANs and management Check the type of VLAN you need, along with support from the switch, uplink and other devices involved. If I want to separate lab traffic from the rest of my network, I need the right VLAN features and compatible settings on the devices involved. Around 24% of consumers prioritise configurable segmentation.
Noise and placement Check the fan specifications and dimensions of the exact variant, and consider where you plan to place it. If the switch is going on my desk within earshot, I want to know whether its design will fit the space and whether it has a fan. Around 18% of consumers prioritise quiet operation and suitable dimensions.
PoE power Only if you plan to connect PoE devices, check that the standard, power per port and total budget meet their requirements. If I want to power additional devices through the switch, their PoE requirements need to match the power available per port and the total power budget. Around 5% of consumers prioritise PoE for the additional devices they plan to use.

Avoid common selection mistakes

  • Counting only the cluster nodes when working out how many ports you need

    The connection to the rest of your network uses a port too. Before choosing, map out every node, the uplink and any other connections you know you’ll need.

    If you run out of ports for the uplink, you may need another switch or to rethink your setup.

  • Assuming 2.5 Gbit/s guarantees that speed for every connection

    Connection speed also depends on the interface of the connected device. Check both ends of every important connection before choosing ports designed for higher speeds.

  • Assuming QoS means VLAN support

    The QoS specifications for the unmanaged TL-SG108-M2 are not the same as the VLAN features documented for the TL-SG108E. If you plan to use VLANs, check that the exact model supports the features and configuration you need.

  • Confusing the number of PoE ports with the total power available

    For the TL-SG1005P V5, TP-Link Germany specifies up to 30 W per PoE port and a total power budget of 65 W. Compare the requirements of all devices you’ll power at the same time with both the power per port and the total budget.

Key brands at a glance

TP-Link

The documented models range from unmanaged Gigabit switches to devices with 2.5 Gbit/s ports or VLAN features. These specifications apply to the individual models and are from TP-Link Germany.

  • TL-SG108: eight Gigabit ports for straightforward connections.
  • TL-SG108-M2: eight 2.5 Gbit/s ports.
  • TL-SG108E: VLAN features with Gigabit ports; the features of these three models are not interchangeable.

NETGEAR

NETGEAR describes the MS308E as a desktop switch with eight 2.5 Gbit/s ports and web management.

  • Fanless desktop housing, according to the manufacturer.
  • Before buying, check that the VLAN features of the version on offer and its firmware are right for your planned configuration.

Zyxel

According to Zyxel Networks, the XMG1915-10E combines 2.5 Gbit/s RJ45 ports with 10G SFP+ uplinks and smart-managed features.

  • The model is specified with eight 2.5 Gbit/s RJ45 ports and two 10G SFP+ ports.
  • The specifications state that the model has no PoE. SFP+ ports are not additional 10G RJ45 sockets, so you’ll need to plan separately for compatible devices and connection components.

D-Link

The European data sheet for the DMS-108 describes an unmanaged desktop switch with eight 2.5 Gbit/s ports.

  • The European data sheet specifies fanless operation.
  • As an unmanaged model, the DMS-108 is not designed for configurable VLANs.

Switches at Joybuy

The range includes managed 2.5 Gbit/s and Gigabit switches, as well as unmanaged Gigabit models for connecting clusters at your desk. For the specific product listing, also check the CE mark, product and manufacturer identification, and any required accompanying information in German. The German Federal Network Agency lists these points in connection with market surveillance.

Ubiquiti UniFi Flex 2.5G PoE, 8-port managed switch with 10 GbE uplink

Ubiquiti UniFi Flex 2.5G PoE, 8-port, PoE++, managed, 10 GbE uplink, white

For several fast cluster devices and a planned 10 GbE uplink; the title specifies eight 2.5 GbE RJ45 ports, PoE++ and a managed model.

The AC/DC adapter is not included and is sold separately; a PoE+++ input is listed as an alternative power source. Check that you have the right power supply and compatible devices.

View at Joybuy
D-Link DGS-1210-10/E Smart Managed Gigabit switch with 8 RJ45 ports and 2 SFP slots

D-Link DGS-1210-10/E, 10-port smart managed Gigabit switch

For a managed Gigabit network, if eight RJ45 ports and two SFP slots suit the connections you have planned.

The product name specifies a switching capacity of 20 Gbit/s and a fanless design. Check that Gigabit ports are fast enough for your nodes and that the SFP connections are compatible with your devices.

View at Joybuy
TP-Link TL-SG1008P, unmanaged Gigabit switch with PoE

TP-Link TL-SG1008P, unmanaged Gigabit switch with PoE

For a shared Gigabit network with wired devices and planned PoE-powered equipment; the product name specifies an unmanaged switch.

As an unmanaged model, it does not offer comparable VLAN configuration. Check the specifications for the exact variant against the requirements of your planned PoE devices.

View at Joybuy
D-Link DGS-1008P/E, unmanaged Gigabit switch with PoE

D-Link DGS-1008P/E, unmanaged Gigabit switch with PoE

For wired Gigabit connections and planned PoE devices; the product name describes an unmanaged desktop model.

As an unmanaged model, it does not offer comparable VLAN configuration. Check the PoE specifications for the exact variant against your devices’ requirements.

View at Joybuy
D-Link DGS-1100-08PV2, managed L2/L3 Gigabit switch with PoE

D-Link DGS-1100-08PV2, managed L2/L3 Gigabit switch with PoE

For a managed Gigabit network with VLAN requirements and planned PoE-powered equipment; the product name specifies eight Gigabit ports.

For the stated total PoE budget of 64 W, the combined power requirements of connected devices must stay within the budget. Also check whether Gigabit is fast enough for your cluster connections.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I automatically need 2.5 Gbit/s for multiple cluster nodes?

No. Check the ports on your devices and the data path you need. According to TP-Link Germany, the 2.5 Gbit/s ports on the TL-SG108-M2 also negotiate at 1 Gbit/s or 100 Mbit/s with the device at the other end. If Gigabit is enough for your connections, a Gigabit switch is a perfectly valid option.

What should I look out for when setting up VLANs?

First, check whether your exact model supports the VLAN feature you need. TP-Link Germany documents, among other features, 802.1Q-based VLANs for the TL-SG108E. For connections to other devices, make sure their port and VLAN settings suit your planned network setup.

How can I avoid choosing the wrong PoE switch?

Note the standard and power requirements of every PoE device you plan to connect, then compare them with the power available per port and the total budget. For the TL-SG1005P V5, TP-Link Germany specifies four PoE+ ports, up to 30 W per port and 65 W in total; its data ports are Gigabit ports.

What should I know about faults and disposal in Germany?

For a consumer purchase, statutory rights against the seller are separate from a voluntary manufacturer’s warranty, as explained by the Verbraucherzentrale. Discarded electrical equipment must not go in household waste; the German Environment Agency lists local collection points among the available return options.