Joybuy Insights

Buying ice cube trays: Which shape suits your drinks, freezer and everyday needs?

An ice cube tray should freeze water reliably and allow you to remove the cubes without unnecessary effort. In practice, however, the differences often only become apparent after several uses. Rigid trays can break when the cubes are released, small recesses can be difficult to clean, and poorly sealing ice cube containers can absorb odours from the freezer.

It is therefore worth considering the material, format and intended use before buying. Whether you are looking for a silicone ice cube tray, crushed ice tray, ice ball mould or stackable ice cube box, not every option is suitable for every household.

Common misconceptions when buying ice cube trays

1. Flexible materials are marketed as universally better

A flexible ice cube tray can usually be twisted more easily than a hard plastic tray. That does not mean, however, that every flexible material is equally suitable. The specific material, the stability of the rim and the cleaning instructions are all important. For example, the 5Five ICE CUBE + TRAY TPE 32 ASR lists TPE, TPR and ABS. The tray is designed to stand flat in the freezer and must not be emptied using sharp objects.

2. Larger quantities require more space than expected

An ice cube tray with many compartments may seem practical on paper. In the freezer, however, long trays take up a specific amount of space and need to stand level. Anyone who wants to store several batches will also need an ice cube container or ice cube box. A set with a storage box and inserts can be more organised than several open trays.

3. “Leak-proof” does not automatically apply in every situation

A standard ice cube tray can be difficult to transport in the freezer. Liquid may leak out if the tray is tilted. Sealed freezer containers are not suitable for every application either: water expands when it freezes, so a container should not be filled to the brim. With meal prep boxes, you should also check the information on microwave use and the temperature range.

These buying parameters are key

Material and food contact

Ice cube trays are made from materials including silicone, TPE, TPR, PP and ABS. Important factors include:

  • Food suitability: The supplier should state that the material is suitable for contact with food.
  • Temperature information: For use in the freezer, the relevant suitability must be specified.
  • Odour absorption: Ice cubes stored in the open can absorb aromas from the freezer. A sealable box is useful for longer-term storage.
  • Cleaning: Dishwasher suitability can reduce the effort required for care, but this should be stated explicitly in the product description.

For storage containers, additional information such as BPA-free, leak-proof or airtight may also be relevant. These properties should be understood as specific product specifications, not as general statements applying to every box made from the same type of material.

Shape and ice size

Small cubes or crushed ice cool drinks quickly, but generally melt faster because of their larger surface area. Large cubes and whisky ice cubes are suitable for users who prefer their drinks to dilute more slowly. An ice ball mould, on the other hand, requires sufficient height in the freezer and should be sealed securely.

Before buying, you should check:

  1. How many portions of ice are produced per batch?
  2. Will the length and width fit on an available freezer shelf?
  3. Is separate storage required?
  4. Is the tray intended for water, fruit juice or other liquids?
  5. Is there information about expansion, cleaning and releasing the ice?

Storage and stackability

For households with limited freezer space, stackable freezer boxes are worth considering. Transparent containers make it easier to check the contents. For example, a 0.75-litre box is also suitable for prepared portions and leftovers. Larger containers with dividers are practical for meal prep when different foods need to be kept separate. However, runny foods may seep between compartments if the dividing walls are not fully sealed.

Our selection by user profile

Suitable for: Budget-conscious beginners
5Five ICE CUBE + TRAY TPE 32 ASR

5Five ICE CUBE + TRAY TPE 32 ASR

Why this product suits the profile: The tray is designed for classic ice cubes and measures 33.4 × 18.5 × 3.5 cm according to the product information. It is suitable for drinks and for making flavour-infused ice cubes with herbs or fruit.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The instructions specify that it should be placed on a level surface, allow sufficient room for expansion and must not be emptied using sharp objects.

Key benefit & strengths

TPE/TPR/ABS according to the product description; dishwasher-safe according to the supplier; slim format for freezer storage.

Suitable for: Buyers with high quality standards
LocknLock Classic Ice Cube Container with Tray 3.4L

LocknLock Classic Ice Cube Container with Tray 3.4L

Why this product suits the profile: This set combines three inserts with a 3.4-litre storage box. It is designed for households that want to store ice cubes neatly and make structured use of their freezer space.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The closed box reduces contact between the ice cubes and their surroundings. Before use, check the box, lid and inserts for cracks.

Key benefit & strengths

BPA-free plastic according to the product information; three inserts; stackable, transparent box; dishwasher- and freezer-safe according to the supplier.

Suitable for: Special uses & frequent users
Excellent Houseware Crushed Ice Tray Maker

Excellent Houseware Crushed Ice Tray Maker

Why this product suits the profile: According to the product description, this crushed ice tray creates small pieces of ice for cocktails, smoothies or chilled food. It is therefore designed for specialist drink applications.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The recommended level position in the freezer and the stated maximum fill weight of 0.5 kg help to prevent overfilling and deformation.

Key benefit & strengths

Small pieces of ice for specialist uses; flexible material and stackable format according to the product description.

Suitable for: Whisky and cocktail lovers
BJ Ice Ball Mould Set of 2

BJ Ice Ball Mould Set of 2 - Whisky Ice Cube Tray

Why this product suits the profile: According to the product description, the two moulds create balls measuring approximately 6.5 cm in diameter. The format is designed for spirits and larger glasses.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The spherical design is clearly intended for large portions of ice. Before buying, check whether the balls will fit in your existing glass.

Key benefit & strengths

Set of two moulds; flexible silicone according to the product description; spherical format for whisky, bourbon and similar drinks.

Looking for more options?

We have put together a complete, regularly updated list of products that fully meet these strict selection criteria and the safety regulations applicable in the EU.

Additional solutions for food storage and meal prep

Not every freezer solution needs to make ice. The Set of 4 Fresh & Freeze Rectangular PE Boxes 0.75l includes four transparent PE containers with a capacity of 0.75 litres. According to the product description, they are stackable and suitable for the freezer, microwave and dishwasher; they are not intended for use in the oven.

For smaller portions, the LocknLock FREEZERFIT-450ML with a capacity of 450 ml may be a good option. According to the supplier, it is made from BPA-free PP, is stackable and suitable for the freezer. The lid must be removed before heating. For separate meals, the LocknLock 3-Compartment Meal Tray with a capacity of 1.5 litres and three compartments is a practical choice. According to the product information, the dividers are not completely liquid-tight.

FAQ about ice cube trays

How long do ice cube trays last?

Their lifespan depends on the material, cleaning and handling. Trays should not be emptied using knives or other sharp objects. Cracks, brittle areas or damaged lids are all reasons to stop using the tray or box.

How can you prevent ice cubes from absorbing odours from the freezer?

Once fully frozen, open ice cubes should be transferred to a sealable ice cube container. A separate box with a tight-fitting lid limits contact with the air in the freezer. Before use, make sure that all components are clean and completely dry.

Which ice cube tray is suitable for cocktails?

Standard cubes or a crushed ice tray are suitable for classic cocktails. Large balls are better suited to whisky and other spirits. If you regularly entertain, it is also worth choosing a box in which already frozen portions can be stored neatly and space-efficiently.