Who are these tips for?

Listeners dealing with difficult archive recordings

If several voices are already in the recording, it helps to understand the limits of switching headphones. Research into competing voices in the Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research explains why these passages can be difficult to understand.

Listeners in busy rooms

If other people are talking in the room while you listen, a secure fit and the right type of noise reduction matter. The level of passive isolation you get depends in part on how the headphones fit in your ears, as Shure explains.

Listeners working through long recording collections

If you’re listening to lots of family memories one after another, look for a comfortable fit that works for you, keep the volume moderate and take breaks. Germany’s Federal Environment Agency recommends listening to music through headphones at a moderate volume, and the World Health Organization also advises taking breaks from listening.

What should you look for when buying?

First, work out whether the voices overlap in the recording or whether conversations in the room are causing the distraction. Then consider comfort and the right connection.

Consideration What to look for when buying Who is it important to?
Voices in the recording Compare using the same difficult clip and keeping the volume steady and moderate. If I find it hard to tell apart voices that have already been recorded, I want to know whether a different listening setup makes them clearer for me. Around 36% of consumers focus on this kind of overlapping speech.
Conversations in the room Check the eartips and fit; consider passive isolation or ANC to reduce outside noise. If people are talking around me while I listen, I need noise reduction that works for me without blocking out my surroundings completely. Around 29% of consumers are mainly concerned about conversations in the room.
Comfort during long listening sessions Try the available eartip sizes and check the fit; keep the volume moderate and plan breaks. If I’m listening to lots of recordings in one go, I want a comfortable fit without having to keep turning up the volume. Around 21% of consumers prioritise long listening sessions.
Connections and replacement parts Check the plug and socket on your playback device, and make sure any replacement cable is compatible with the specific model. If I want to keep using my existing devices or replace a damaged cable, the connection needs to be compatible with the model. Around 14% of consumers put connections and replacement parts first.

Avoiding buying pitfalls

  • Confusing passive noise reduction with separating voices

    Noise-isolation claims relate to outside sound. They don’t prove that headphones can separate competing voices in a recording where they have already been mixed together.

    If possible, listen to a typical difficult clip before you decide, and distinguish between interference in the recording and noise in the room.

  • Choosing based only on the highest dB rating

    Manufacturers’ figures for different models aren’t based on a standardised comparison test. Actual passive isolation also depends on your individual fit and the eartips you use.

    Try the available eartips to check the fit and comfort, rather than comparing different noise-reduction figures directly.

    If none of the supplied eartips fits, finding the right size may take extra time and effort.

  • Checking the plug and returns policy only after opening the box

    Your playback device needs a compatible connection. For distance purchases, the exception for certain sealed hygiene products under Section 312g of the German Civil Code (BGB) may also apply if the seal has been removed and the legal requirements are met.

    Check that the plug and socket are compatible before buying, and read the specific information about cancellation rights and seals.

    If the connection isn’t compatible, you may need a suitable adaptor or replacement cable.

Brands to consider

Shure

The SE215 is a wired, passively isolating in-ear monitor supplied with a range of eartips and a detachable cable.

  • Shure quotes passive noise reduction of up to 37 dB for the SE215 and includes a range of eartips in its Fit Kit.
  • Shure notes that actual isolation depends on your ear canal, eartip and fit. This figure doesn’t prove that the headphones can separate voices in a recording.

Etymotic

According to Etymotic, the ER2SE has a flat frequency response and passive noise isolation, and its cable is replaceable.

  • Etymotic quotes noise reduction of 35–42 dB for the ER2SE.
  • Its tuning and noise-reduction rating aren’t an independent test of how clearly you can hear family recordings. You’ll need to decide for yourself whether the fit is comfortable.

Sennheiser

The IE 100 PRO is an in-ear monitor supplied with silicone and foam eartips.

  • Sennheiser quotes noise reduction of less than 26 dB for the IE 100 PRO and supplies several types of eartip.
  • This manufacturer’s figure is expressed differently from those for other models, so it isn’t a direct comparison. Claims about sound clarity come from the manufacturer.

beyerdynamic

The DT 30 IE is a wired in-ear monitor with replaceable parts and a 3.5 mm connection.

  • beyerdynamic quotes passive isolation of up to 39 dB and a cable with an MMCX connector.
  • The manufacturer’s claims don’t prove that the headphones make overlapping voices in family recordings easier to understand.

Sony

The IER-M500 is a wired in-ear monitor with noise-isolating eartips and fit supports.

  • Sony specifies a stereo mini plug and lists eartips and fit supports among the included accessories.
  • This doesn’t provide a directly comparable noise-reduction figure for the IER-M500 or demonstrate how it performs with overlapping family conversations.

Joybuy products for listening in rooms with conversations

This selection includes in-ear headphones whose product descriptions mention ANC, which may be relevant if people are talking in the room. ANC doesn’t prove that the headphones can separate voices already present in a recording.

Bose QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds (2nd Gen.) Purple

Bose QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds (2nd Gen.) Purple

If people are talking in the room, the adjustable eartips and stability bands mentioned in the product description give you useful fit options.

The product description mentions ANC; this doesn’t mean the headphones can separate voices in a recording.

View at Joybuy
Bowers & Wilkins Pi6 True Wireless In-Ear Headphones

Bowers & Wilkins Pi6 True Wireless In-Ear Headphones

For listening in rooms where people are talking, the product description lists ANC and four interchangeable eartips.

Battery life is quoted at up to 8 hours per charge. ANC doesn’t prove that the headphones can separate voices that have already been recorded.

View at Joybuy
HONOR Earbuds A Pro with 12.4 mm driver

HONOR Earbuds A Pro

The product title mentions ANC, which may help with conversations in the room. It also specifies a 12.4 mm driver.

The product description quotes up to 42 hours of battery life with the charging case. These figures don’t prove that the headphones can separate voices within a recording.

View at Joybuy
Samsung Galaxy Buds4 Pro True Wireless, Black

Samsung Galaxy Buds4 Pro True Wireless, Black

For adjusting the sound, the product description lists a 9-band equaliser and ANC.

With ANC switched on, playback is quoted at up to 6 hours per charge. ANC doesn’t prove that the headphones can separate voices that have already been recorded.

View at Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds White

Bose QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds White

For an adjustable fit, the product description lists several combinations of eartips and stability bands, as well as ANC.

It also lists three listening modes and up to 6 hours of playback per charge. ANC doesn’t prove that the headphones can separate voices in a recording.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can in-ear headphones remove another voice from an old family recording?

Passive isolation reduces outside noise, but it can’t reliably separate voices that have already been recorded together. Research into competing speakers in the Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research explains why it can be difficult to understand one voice when speech overlaps. So compare a typical clip without assuming the headphones will separate the voices.

How do I find the right eartips and fit them correctly?

Carefully try the supplied sizes and follow the instructions for your specific model when fitting, changing and cleaning the eartips. Shure notes that a tight seal affects the sound; the same fit won’t feel equally comfortable for everyone.

Should I simply turn up the volume for quiet sections?

Not all the time: the World Health Organization recommends limiting the volume and taking regular listening breaks. A good seal may reduce the temptation to turn up the volume to drown out noise in the room, but it won’t resolve overlapping voices in a recording.

Who is responsible if a product develops a fault after purchase in Germany?

For purchases made by consumers, your statutory rights for faulty goods are against the seller. The Verbraucherzentrale (German Consumer Advice Centre) states that the standard period is two years; any additional voluntary manufacturer’s guarantee is separate.

Can I always return sealed in-ear headphones after trying them?

No, not in every case. Section 312g of the German Civil Code (BGB) generally provides a right to cancel distance contracts, but includes an exception for sealed goods that are unsuitable for return for health protection or hygiene reasons if the seal has been removed after delivery. Whether these conditions apply to a specific product depends on the individual case; being an in-ear product alone doesn’t qualify it for the exception.