For occasional, mainly text-based A4 checklists, a cartridge printer can be a good fit if it offers clear print quality, suitable replacement ink and running costs that work for the amount you print. If you regularly print larger quantities, compare tank models with cartridge or subscription options based on the same planned page volume. Wi-Fi, duplex printing, colour and scanning matter most when they suit the way you work on your project; manufacturers’ yield figures and subscription details can’t reliably predict your actual costs.
Which printers suit different needs?
For occasional checklist printing
If you mainly need clear A4 text, compare the cost of suitable replacement cartridges and ongoing printing with the printer’s purchase price. Automatic duplex printing is useful if your lists regularly use both sides of the page.
For project teams printing lots of copies
If you’re printing copies for several people on a regular basis, factor in consumables and any subscription alongside the printer’s price. Compare models based on how you expect to print; manufacturers’ yield figures are based on the conditions they specify.
For teams using digital templates
If your templates are on mobile devices or you need to digitise completed documents, check the Wi-Fi connection and compatibility with your devices. Scanning and an automatic document feeder are additional features to consider if you’ll actually be scanning paper documents.
What should you look for when buying?
| What to look for |
What to check when buying |
Who is it important for? |
| Clear A4 text |
Check A4 support and black ink; only consider automatic duplex printing if you want to use both sides of the page. |
If I need small boxes and labels on my checklists to be easy to read, text quality comes first. Around 40% of consumers prioritise the readability of their lists. |
| Ongoing printing costs |
Compare the printer, suitable replacement ink and, if relevant, a page subscription for the same planned page volume. |
If I regularly print lists for a group, I want to factor in consumables and any subscription costs when planning. Around 30% of consumers give top priority to ongoing printing costs. |
| Project workflow and scanning |
Check Wi-Fi and printing support for your existing devices; assess scanning and the document feeder separately. |
If my templates are on mobile devices or I need to digitise completed documents, the right workflow matters. Around 20% of consumers prioritise how printing and digitising fit into their project workflow. |
| Colour |
Before buying, check whether the template needs colour and factor in suitable colour ink. |
If colours convey status or information on my checklist, I want the printer to reproduce those markings. Around 10% of consumers prioritise colour-coded markings and templates. |
Common buying and usage pitfalls
-
Comparing only the printer price
If you’re printing multiple copies for a project, consumables and an optional page subscription can affect ongoing costs. Manufacturers’ page-yield figures are no guarantee of how much ink you’ll use.
Compare the printer price and suitable ink for the same planned number and type of pages. Only factor in a subscription if the model, page allowance and your printing habits are a good match.
Depending on the model, you may also need to pay for replacement cartridges, ink bottles or an optional monthly page subscription.
-
Assuming an ink subscription will automatically save you money
Printing needs can vary over the course of a short-term school project. Canon says unused pages on the PIXMA Print Plan can be carried over for a maximum of one month.
Before signing up, check that the printer model and page allowance suit your needs, and find out how extra pages, plan changes and cancellations are handled.
A subscription comes with a monthly fee; depending on the plan, extra pages may cost more.
-
Assuming cleaning is a free substitute for maintenance
If print quality is poor, you may need to follow the maintenance steps specified for your model. Epson advises running a nozzle check first on the EcoTank and Expression devices mentioned, followed by a printhead clean if necessary.
If you notice any issues, follow the instructions for your specific model and check the guidance on ink levels.
Cleaning cycles can use ink.
A guide to the key brands
Canon
The PIXMA TS6550i is an A4 all-in-one cartridge printer for text-based lists, mobile printing and automatic duplex printing.
- Canon lists pigment black ink, Wi-Fi and automatic A4 duplex printing. Its standard cartridges are the PG-595 and CL-586.
- The PIXMA Print Plan is optional. Check whether a page subscription suits your printing needs; the Druckerchannel readers’ choice award for the TS6550i was in the entry-level printer with ink subscription category.
Epson
The EcoTank ET-2950 is a refillable A4 colour all-in-one printer for project documents you print regularly.
- Epson lists duplex printing, scanning, copying and Wi-Fi. Its stated ink yield is based on conditions set by the manufacturer.
- Actual yield depends on how you print, so manufacturers’ figures are no substitute for comparing models based on your expected usage.
Brother
The DCP-T580DW is an A4 all-in-one ink tank printer with Wi-Fi and USB.
- Brother lists automatic duplex printing and a 150-sheet paper tray. According to Brother, the supplied ink can print up to 7,500 pages in black and 5,000 pages in colour.
- These are manufacturer figures, not an independent comparison of actual printing costs; consider them in light of your own printing habits.
HP
The Smart Tank 7305 is an all-in-one tank printer for project documents where you may also need to scan or copy as well as print.
- HP lists Wi-Fi, automatic two-sided printing and a 35-sheet automatic document feeder.
- If you only need to print checklists, the document feeder is relevant only if you also want to scan multi-page paper documents.
Suitable products on Joybuy
Related products will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a scanner or automatic document feeder for checklists?
You need neither just to print. If you want to digitise completed multi-page documents, check scanning and the document feeder separately; HP lists a 35-sheet automatic feeder for the Smart Tank 7305.
What should I consider when choosing an ink subscription for a school project?
Check that the printer model and page allowance match how much you expect to print. Canon says unused pages on the PIXMA Print Plan can be carried over for a maximum of one month; before signing up, also check the cost of extra pages and the terms for changing or cancelling your plan.
What can I do if my prints are streaky or faint?
Start by following the maintenance steps for your specific printer model. For the EcoTank and Expression devices mentioned, Epson’s guidance recommends running a nozzle check first and, if necessary, cleaning the printhead afterwards; be sure to follow the advice on ink levels.