The right printer for your needs

Coordinators who regularly print text schedules

If you regularly hand out clear, legible A4 schedules, check that the paper feed and duplex printing suit your print volume. Brother lists a 250-sheet paper cassette and automatic duplex printing for the HL-L2445DW.

Teams with several people printing

If several volunteers print from different devices, make sure the specific printer model’s connections fit the way your group works. Brother lists LAN, Wi-Fi and USB for the HL-L2445DW, and USB and Wi-Fi for the DCP-L2620DW.

Groups with additional requirements

Printed colour codes point to a colour model. If you need to scan or copy completed paper schedules, a multifunction printer may be suitable; these are two separate requirements.

What to consider when buying

Consider each purchasing priority separately: a feature is only useful if your group actually needs it as part of its routine.

Purchasing priority What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Regular print runs Check A4 support, the number of sheets needed per run, the paper cassette and automatic duplex printing on the exact model. If I regularly print A4 delivery schedules, I don’t want to keep refilling the paper or struggle to print multi-page schedules. Around 31% of consumers put a smooth printing process first.
Ongoing costs Compare toner and drum units compatible with the exact model, stated yields and replacement prices on the same basis. If schedules are printed regularly, I want to factor in ongoing consumables rather than focus on just one yield figure. Around 25% of consumers prioritise ongoing costs.
Access for several volunteers Check the devices and network you already have against the connections on the exact model, and decide who will look after the printer. If different volunteers print schedules, I want a way to print that works with their devices and the printer’s location. Around 19% of consumers put shared printing access first.
Confidential schedules Check whether the schedules contain personal information and who needs access; organise where they are printed and collected accordingly. If the schedules include names or addresses, I want to know who can see the print jobs and finished copies. Around 13% of consumers prioritise keeping schedules confidential.
Additional features Use a sample schedule to check whether colour codes are needed; assess scanning and copying separately. If black-and-white markings are enough, I don’t need colour printing just in case colour codes might be useful. However, returned paper schedules may make a scanner worthwhile. Around 12% of consumers put an additional feature such as colour, scanning or copying first.

Common misconceptions

  • Comparing only the printer price or toner yield

    The Brother HL-L2445DW uses separate toner and drum units. A yield figure on its own therefore won’t tell you the cost of replacing all the consumables.

    For your expected print volume, factor in all consumables compatible with the exact model and compare them on the same basis.

  • Assuming similar model names mean the same connections

    Brother lists LAN, Wi-Fi and USB for the HL-L2445DW, but USB and Wi-Fi for the DCP-L2620DW. You can’t assume one model has the same connections as another.

    Check the connections and printing options against the full model name before deciding how the printer will fit into your routine.

  • Confusing colour with scanning or data protection

    HP describes the Color LaserJet Pro 3202dw as a printer without scanning or copying functions. A secure printing feature also doesn’t replace rules about who can see the finished printouts.

    Assess colour codes, scanning paper schedules and protecting personal information as separate requirements.

Relevant brands and model ranges to consider

The details relate to the models and model ranges mentioned; they are not a general assessment of the manufacturers.

Brother

Worth comparing if you’re choosing between a standard black-and-white printer such as the HL-L2445DW and a black-and-white multifunction printer such as the DCP-L2620DW.

  • Brother lists automatic duplex printing and separate toner and drum units for both models. The HL-L2445DW also has LAN, Wi-Fi and USB.
  • The connections vary between models: Brother lists USB and Wi-Fi for the DCP-L2620DW. Check the specifications of the specific model you’re considering.

Canon

The i-SENSYS LBP246dw II is a black-and-white printing option to consider if paper feed and secure print-job features are part of your selection criteria.

  • Canon lists a 250-sheet cassette, a 100-sheet multipurpose tray, and secure and encrypted printing for this model.
  • According to Canon, you’ll need an optional cassette to increase the maximum paper capacity. Security features must also be set up appropriately.

HP

The models mentioned meet different needs: the LaserJet Pro 4002dw prints in black and white, while the Color LaserJet Pro 3202dw prints in colour.

  • HP lists double-sided black-and-white printing for the LaserJet Pro 4002dw; the Color LaserJet Pro 3202dw is a colour model.
  • According to HP, the Color LaserJet Pro 3202dw doesn’t scan or copy. HP also notes that the models mentioned have dynamic security features that may restrict cartridges using non-HP chips. Check how this applies to the specific model and consumables.

Kyocera

The ECOSYS PA3500wx is an A4 black-and-white option to consider if you also want to check the paper feed and service conditions.

  • Kyocera lists double-sided printing, a standard cassette with a capacity of up to 250 sheets and a 100-sheet multipurpose tray.
  • Additional paper feeds are optional. Warranty and service are subject to their respective terms; claims about low running costs are the manufacturer’s own and don’t amount to an independent cost comparison.

Joybuy products

The following Joybuy products include black-and-white multifunction printers and a colour multifunction printer. They’re worth considering if you also need to scan or copy paper schedules, or print colour codes.

PANTUM BM2300AW A4 black-and-white laser multifunction printer

PANTUM BM2300AW A4 black-and-white laser multifunction printer

For groups that print A4 delivery schedules and also need to scan or copy paper schedules.

Model specification: 22 ppm, Wi-Fi and ADF. The description also lists USB, Bluetooth and mobile printing.

View at Joybuy
HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3302sdwg colour laser multifunction printer

HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3302sdwg

For groups that print colour codes and need to scan or copy paper schedules.

The product description lists automatic double-sided printing, as well as printing, scanning and copying.

Connections include Wi-Fi, Ethernet and USB. It also has two paper trays with a combined input capacity of 350 sheets.

View at Joybuy
PANTUM BM2300NW A4 black-and-white laser multifunction printer

PANTUM BM2300NW A4 black-and-white laser multifunction printer

For groups that print A4 schedules and also need to scan or copy paper schedules.

Model specification: 22 ppm, dual-band Wi-Fi and Ethernet; the description lists a 150-sheet feed.

Duplex printing is manual, so printing on both sides requires a few extra steps.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I start comparing costs if I don’t yet know how many pages I’ll print?

First, estimate how many schedules you’ll print for each distribution and how often you’ll distribute them over a given period. Then compare the toner, any separate drum, and paper for the exact printer, using their documented yields or costs on the same basis. Toner yield alone doesn’t tell you the cost per page.

Can a shared printer go anywhere in the clubroom?

Set it up to suit its connections and where it will actually be used. If delivery schedules contain personal information, those responsible must take appropriate technical and organisational measures to prevent unauthorised access, following guidance from the Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information. Make suitable arrangements for printing and collecting the finished copies too; this doesn’t mean that a particular location or PIN printing is required in every case.

Do we need colour or a scanner?

Assess both separately using a sample schedule and your group’s routine: printed colour codes call for colour printing, while returned paper schedules may make a scanner or copier useful. According to HP, the HP Color LaserJet Pro 3202dw isn’t a multifunction printer; the Brother DCP-L2620DW is a black-and-white multifunction printer.

How can the group take emissions and printer placement into account?

The German Environment Agency recommends choosing low-emission laser printers and points to the Blue Angel as a guide. Its recommendation to place large office printers separately is precautionary advice, not a general requirement for the location of every small printer. As the printer criteria were revised in 2026, your group should check the label on the specific model and the relevant edition of the criteria.

Can a printer that’s no longer needed go in household waste?

No. The German Environment Agency explains that waste electrical and electronic equipment must be disposed of separately from household waste; municipal collection points generally accept it free of charge. Before handing it in, also check whether any personal information is still stored on the printer.