Which printers are right for different needs?

House share that prints rotas regularly

If you print text-based rotas regularly, remember to factor in consumables as well as the printer itself. Brother Germany states that the toner and drum are separate components on the Brother HL-L2400DW.

House share with a shared printer

If several people need to print from their own devices, check the connections available on the exact model and whether the printer can be added to your house-share network. Brother Germany and Canon Germany list the connection options for their respective models.

Anyone handling confidential rotas

If rotas contain employee details, check the data controller’s requirements before printing at home, and consider who can see the printer and printouts. The Data Protection Conference explains that employees may generally process personal data only on the instructions of the controller or processor, unless a legal provision states otherwise.

What should you consider when buying?

When choosing a printer for shift rotas in a student house share, the main considerations are how often you’ll print, who needs access, how confidential the rotas are and where the printer will go.

Consideration What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Ongoing costs Compare the starter toner, compatible replacement cartridge, stated page yield and, where applicable, a separate drum for the exact model. If I print rotas regularly, I want to include consumables in the total cost. Around 36 % of consumers prioritise the cost of repeat printing.
Printing from multiple devices Check Wi-Fi or LAN, supported operating systems and the mobile printing options available on the exact model. If several housemates need to print from their own devices, the connection and setup must work with the house-share network. Around 29 % of consumers put shared access first.
Confidential shift rotas Check the data controller’s instructions and choose a suitable place to print and collect printouts. If a rota contains employees’ personal data, I want to prevent unauthorised access to the printer and printed pages. Around 21 % of consumers prioritise confidentiality.
Space Measure the space where you plan to put the printer, allowing room for paper, operation and consumables. Canon Germany gives the dimensions of the i-SENSYS LBP243dw II as approximately 399 × 373 × 249 mm with the trays retracted. If there’s little space available in the house share, I need a printer that fits the intended spot and still allows practical access to the paper. Around 14 % of consumers prioritise where the printer will go.

Which buying pitfalls should you avoid?

  • Comparing only the printer price, not the consumables

    The Brother HL-L2400DW has separate toner and drum components. So if you print regularly, remember to account for both.

    Check the part numbers and stated yields for the exact model, then work out what you’ll need based on your expected print volume.

    With models that use a separate drum unit, consumables may include a drum as well as replacement toner.

  • Assuming similarly named printer models are the same

    The Canon i-SENSYS LBP243dw II and the older LBP243dw are different model versions. HP M209d and HP M209dw are also different model names.

    Use features and consumables information only when it relates to the exact model version.

  • Assuming a shared printer is automatically suitable for confidential documents

    A network connection doesn’t determine who is allowed to process employees’ personal data or see the printouts. For employees, the Data Protection Conference refers to the instructions of the controller or processor, unless a legal provision states otherwise.

    If your rotas contain personal data, check in advance whether printing them in your house share is permitted and how printouts can be collected securely.

Which printer brands are worth considering?

Brother

Worth considering if you want to compare a straightforward mono printer with an all-in-one model for scanning or copying.

  • Brother lists Wi-Fi, automatic duplex printing and separate toner and drum units for the HL-L2400DW.
  • A review by F.A.Z. Kaufkompass cites the lack of LAN and slow Wi-Fi as drawbacks of the HL-L2400DW. This applies to that model, not Brother printers as a whole.

Canon

The i-SENSYS LBP243dw II is worth considering if you’re looking for a mono model with network and mobile printing options.

  • Canon Germany lists duplex printing, Wi-Fi, AirPrint and Mopria for the i-SENSYS LBP243dw II.
  • Canon gives the dimensions as approximately 399 × 373 × 249 mm with the trays retracted. Also, don’t assume that details for the similarly named LBP243dw without “II” apply to this model.

HP

The LaserJet M209d is a mono printing option if you’re mainly interested in printing and duplex functionality.

  • HP lists mono printing and double-sided printing for the M209d specifically.
  • HP says this model uses dynamic security measures that may block print cartridges containing a non-HP chip. Bear this in mind when choosing replacement toner; details for the M209dw don’t automatically apply to the M209d.

All-in-one printers for house-share shift rotas

These Joybuy models are for anyone who needs scanning or copying as well as printing.

PANTUM BM2300AW A4 mono laser all-in-one printer

PANTUM BM2300AW A4 Mono Laser Multifunction Printer

If you also want to scan or copy paper rotas, this all-in-one model is designed to meet that need.

A4 mono laser printing, 22 ppm, Wi-Fi and ADF.

Joybuy
HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3302sdwg

HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3302sdwg

If you also need to scan or copy other documents, this all-in-one model is another option worth considering.

Colour laser printer with automatic duplex printing, Wi-Fi, Ethernet and USB.

Joybuy
PANTUM BM2300NW A4 mono laser all-in-one printer

PANTUM BM2300NW A4 Mono Laser Multifunction Printer

If you print A4 mono rotas and also want to scan or copy, this all-in-one model is worth considering.

22 ppm, dual-band Wi-Fi and Ethernet. Duplex printing is manual, not automatic.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a scanner to print a shift rota?

No, not if the rota is already digital. If you want to digitise or copy paper rotas with handwritten changes using the same device, consider an all-in-one printer such as the DCP-L2620DW, which Brother describes as a 3-in-1 model.

What should housemates check before setting up Wi-Fi?

Check that the devices and operating systems people will print from are compatible with the connection options supported by the exact printer model. Brother lists Wi-Fi and USB for the HL-L2400DW; a review by F.A.Z. Kaufkompass cites the lack of LAN and slow Wi-Fi as drawbacks.

Which ongoing costs should I factor in?

Check which toner cartridges are compatible and, for models with separate components, whether you’ll also need a separate drum. Don’t compare the printer price alone. Brother Germany states that the toner and drum are separate components on the Brother HL-L2400DW.

Can I simply print rotas containing personal data in my house share?

There’s no simple yes or no. If you’re processing personal data on behalf of a controller as an employee, the Data Protection Conference says you must follow the controller’s instructions, unless a legal provision states otherwise. Check with the relevant person or department that printing at home is permitted and ask who can access the printouts.

What should I do with an old printer?

In Germany, old printers must not go in household waste. The German Environment Agency lists local collection points and, subject to certain conditions, retailer take-back schemes.