Which storage option is right for you?

Students running out of device storage

If your internal storage is running low, you can move existing lecture files elsewhere. When planning, allow for future semesters and the amount of storage you can actually use.

Those building an archive who need a backup

If you want to recover files after a fault or accidental deletion, you need a separate backup option as well as your working archive. The BSI recommends including recovery in your backup plan.

People using multiple devices

If you want to save recordings on one device and access them on another, a NAS can provide a central archive. Synology documents cross-device access for the DS223j; setting up network access is still something you’ll need to plan for.

What should you consider when choosing?

NAS enclosure with drives

Suitable if: you want to store recordings centrally and access them from several devices.

Keep in mind: you’ll need to consider the enclosure, drives and setup separately. Two bays don’t automatically provide a separate backup.

Internal NAS hard drive

Suitable if: you already own a NAS and need additional archive storage for it.

Keep in mind: the drive isn’t a standalone network storage device; its model and form factor must be compatible with your existing enclosure.

External hard drive

Suitable if: you mainly store files on one device and don’t need central network access.

Keep in mind: you’ll need to manage connecting, copying and restoring files yourself. A single drive doesn’t also count as a separate backup.

Consideration What should you look for when buying? Who is this particularly important to?
Usable archive space Estimate file sizes and future storage needs; consider the available bays and storage configuration. If I want to keep recordings from future semesters, the amount of space I can actually use matters; around 36% of consumers make archive capacity their top priority.
Recovery Plan for a separate backup destination and check that you can restore files from it. If I want to be able to recover deleted or damaged recordings, mirroring alone isn’t enough; around 29% of consumers put recovery first.
Access from multiple devices Check which devices you need to use and how to connect to your network; set up access permissions for the archive. If I want to open the same archive on several devices, central network access is essential; around 21% of consumers prioritise access from multiple devices.
Drive for an existing NAS Check the full model number, supported form factor and compatibility information from the enclosure manufacturer. If I already own a NAS and just need compatible extra storage, I don’t want to choose a second enclosure; around 14% of consumers make upgrading an existing NAS their top priority.

Common mistakes

  • Confusing a NAS hard drive with a complete network storage system

    IronWolf, WD Red Plus and Toshiba N300 are drive ranges. To access files over a network, you need a suitable NAS that has been set up.

    Before choosing, check whether the product is an empty enclosure, an internal drive or a complete system with drives installed.

  • Relying on RAID as your only backup

    The BSI points out that mirroring can also copy unwanted changes and is no substitute for a backup.

    Keep your working archive separate from your backup destination, and check that you can actually restore your recordings.

  • Assuming similar drive names mean the drives are technically identical

    Western Digital distinguishes between WD Red with SMR and WD Red Plus and WD Red Pro with CMR. A similar range name alone doesn’t tell you whether a drive is compatible with your enclosure.

    Compare the full model number and recording technology, and check the NAS manufacturer’s compatibility information.

Key brands to consider

Synology

Synology offers NAS enclosures for centralised file management; the DS223j is a documented option with two drive bays.

  • For the DS223j, Synology documents file management, synchronisation and backups to various destinations.
  • The 2.5GbE specification documented for the DS225+ doesn’t automatically apply to the DS223j. You’ll need to consider the enclosure, drives and a separate backup individually.

QNAP

The QNAP TS-233 is a NAS enclosure with two drive bays for a central archive on your home network.

  • QNAP lists two 3.5-inch SATA bays, a Gigabit Ethernet port, USB ports and a USB copy button.
  • The connection specification alone doesn’t tell you what transfer speed your own network will achieve or whether a backup routine has been set up.

Western Digital

Western Digital offers internal NAS drives; the full model name is essential when choosing one.

  • Western Digital describes WD Red Plus and WD Red Pro as CMR drives.
  • According to the manufacturer, WD Red also includes SMR drives. Check with your NAS manufacturer that the specific model is suitable.

Seagate

Seagate’s IronWolf range comprises internal drives for NAS systems and multimedia storage.

  • According to Seagate’s datasheet, the IronWolf range uses CMR recording.
  • Check the full model number against your NAS requirements and plan for a separate backup.

Toshiba

Toshiba describes its internal N300 range as suitable for use in NAS systems, including for archiving, backups and streaming.

  • Toshiba lists NAS-optimised firmware and use in systems with multiple drives.
  • This information doesn’t automatically confirm that every version is compatible with a particular enclosure or means you can do without a separate backup.

Joybuy products

This selection includes Synology NAS enclosures with four or eight drive bays, as well as internal Synology drives for a compatible NAS.

Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS enclosure

Synology DiskStation DS925+ (4-bay NAS)

For a central archive if you want to use multiple drives in one NAS enclosure.

The product description lists two 2.5GbE ports, M.2 NVMe SSD caching and expansion to up to nine bays. According to the product information, Synology-branded drives must be used.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS enclosure

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ (8-bay NAS)

For a central archive if you’re looking for a NAS enclosure with eight drive bays.

The product description lists two 2.5GbE ports, an optional 10GbE upgrade and capacity for up to 360 TB. Before choosing, check which drives and expansions suit your needs.

View at Joybuy
Synology HAT3310-12T NAS hard drive, 12 TB

Synology HAT3310-12T, 12 TB

For a compatible Synology NAS if you want to add an internal drive to your archive.

The product description lists 3.5 inches, SATA III, 7,200 rpm, 512 MB cache and CMR. The drive isn’t a standalone network storage device.

View at Joybuy
Synology HAT3310-16T NAS hard drive, 16 TB

Synology HAT3310-16T, 16 TB

For a compatible Synology NAS if you want to add an internal drive with the stated capacity.

The product description lists SATA at 6 Gb/s, 3.5 inches, 7,200 rpm and CMR. The drive isn’t a standalone network storage device.

View at Joybuy
Synology HAT3300-6T NAS hard drive, 6 TB

Synology HAT3300-6T, 6 TB

For a compatible Synology NAS if you need an internal drive to add more archive space.

The product description lists SATA at 6 Gb/s, 3.5 inches, 5,400 rpm and CMR. The drive isn’t a standalone network storage device.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How can I transfer recordings without losing the only copy?

First, copy the files to your configured destination and check that they open correctly there. Only delete the original files once your separate backup destination is working and you’ve tested the recovery process. The BSI stresses that a backup plan should include recovery.

Do two mirrored hard drives count as a backup?

No. According to the BSI, RAID mirroring doesn’t count as a backup because changes can be applied to both mirrored copies of your data. So make sure you have a separate backup destination.

What should I plan for besides a NAS enclosure?

Check whether the enclosure comes with drives, which drives are compatible and where you’ll keep a separate backup. A NAS enclosure on its own isn’t the same as a configured archive with a tested recovery process.

Can I record any lecture myself and share the file on my NAS?

No, there isn’t a blanket yes to this question. Section 201 of the German Criminal Code covers the unauthorised recording of words spoken in private and certain uses of such recordings. Section 53 of the German Copyright Act permits private copies only subject to its conditions and doesn’t grant general permission to record or share them. Before recording or setting up access, check that you have permission for the specific event, and check your university’s rules and the rights to share the recording. These laws are published on the “Gesetze im Internet” website by the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice.

Does an identifiable voice in a recording have data protection implications?

A voice can be personal data; the University of Münster explicitly lists voices as an example. Who is responsible for data protection in a particular project depends on how the data is processed and can’t be determined simply by choosing a NAS.