If you’re building a project archive that will mostly be stored away and rarely moved, a portable HDD could be a good fit. If you regularly transfer large files between devices, an SSD’s higher transfer speeds may make it the better choice. CHIP describes portable HDDs as a storage option where capacity can matter more than high data rates. However, the speed you actually get also depends on the drive, cable and computer port. A single drive is no substitute for a separate backup. And if your recordings include people, make sure you check your school’s rules on recording and storage separately.
Who archives lesson recordings?
A project archive with lots of recordings
As your collection of recordings grows, you’ll need enough space and a separate backup. Also consider whether you’ll need to transfer files often. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) stresses that backed-up data must be restorable, too.
A mobile project team
If you regularly transfer files between workstations, check the connection and cable as well as the speed your computer can actually support. Crucial, Samsung and Kingston each quote maximum transfer rates for specific SSD models and interfaces.
A team handling sensitive recordings
If people can be recognised or heard in your recordings, check your school’s rules on storage and access. The BSI describes encryption as one possible way to protect data, but it doesn’t replace checking whether you’re allowed to make the recording in the first place.
What should you look for when buying?
First, work out how much space you’ll need, including room for future recordings and a separate backup. Then decide whether archive capacity or frequent file transfers matter more for your day-to-day needs.
| Priority |
What to check before buying |
Who is this important to? |
| Archive space |
Add up file sizes and planned recordings; allow capacity for project versions and a separate copy. |
As my archive grows, I want enough room for recordings and working versions. Archive capacity is the top priority for around 33% of consumers. |
| Restorability |
Plan for a separate backup and check that you can open or restore files from it. |
If project files could be lost, I want a usable second copy and to test that I can restore it. Around 25% of consumers prioritise restorability. |
| Frequent transfers |
Check the connections on both the drive and computer, along with the cable supplied. |
If I often move recordings between devices, I want compatible connections and quick transfers. Around 17% of consumers pay particular attention to frequent transfers. |
| Device compatibility |
Check the operating system, file system and intended backup method are compatible; reformatting can erase existing data. |
If I want to use the drive with my existing computers and a particular backup method, they need to work together. Around 17% of consumers say compatibility is their main concern. |
| Confidentiality |
Consider access controls and, if needed, encryption, as well as keeping the password safe; check your school’s rules separately. |
If my recordings contain personal information, I want to control who can access them and understand the rules for recording and storage. Around 8% of consumers prioritise keeping their files confidential. |
Avoid common buying mistakes
-
Assuming a single drive is a complete backup
If the drive fails or gets lost, your only copy of the recordings could be affected, too.
Plan for a separate second copy and test that you can restore files from it.
You’ll need extra storage or another approved backup location for a separate copy.
-
Assuming an SSD’s quoted speed is your guaranteed copy speed
Maximum speeds apply to specific models and conditions. They don’t automatically tell you how quickly your computer will transfer your files.
Check that the drive’s interface matches your computer and find out which cable is included.
If you don’t have a suitable cable or port, you may need to buy a compatible cable or adapter.
-
Reformatting a drive that already has data on it for Time Machine
Apple points out that reformatting erases existing data on the volume.
First, save your files somewhere else and decide whether you want to set up a separate backup volume.
Moving existing files elsewhere first may require additional storage space.
-
Assuming encryption means you’re allowed to record
Access controls don’t determine whether you’re allowed to make recordings containing personal information and store them for your project.
Check your school’s requirements and data protection rules separately from your choice of drive.
Brands to consider
Toshiba
The Canvio Basics range includes portable HDDs for storing files. Toshiba lists the HDTB520EK3AA variant with 2 TB of capacity.
- For this variant, Toshiba specifies use with Windows without additional software and USB 3.2 Gen 1.
- Check whether it’s suitable for other operating systems, and plan a second backup regardless.
Seagate
Expansion Portable is a range of USB-powered HDDs. The manufacturer’s data sheet lists the STKM2000400 with 2 TB of capacity.
- The data sheet specifies a USB 3.0 cable and a two-year limited manufacturer’s warranty for EMEA.
- The data sheet says the drive needs reformatting for Time Machine. Rescue service availability depends on the country.
Crucial
The X9 Portable SSD is one option for transferring files. Crucial lists the CT1000X9SSD9 as a 1 TB variant.
- Crucial quotes read speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s as the maximum sequential performance of the device.
- This maximum isn’t a guaranteed speed for every computer or when transferring lots of small files.
Kingston
The XS1000 is a range of portable SSDs for backups and transfers, with variants up to 2 TB.
- Kingston specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2 and speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s, as well as connection options for USB-C and USB-A.
- Check which cable or adapter is included with the specific package.
Samsung
The Portable SSD T9 range includes high-speed SSDs. The German product page lists the MU-PG1T0B/EU with 1 TB of capacity.
- Samsung quotes speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s over USB 3.2 Gen 2x2.
- That headline speed isn’t necessarily important for occasional archive storage; how useful it is also depends on your computer’s port.
Drives for project recordings
This selection includes external HDDs for storing files, including a desktop drive for a permanent setup, as well as a portable SSD for carrying project files.
Image unavailable
WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C
This portable HDD could suit a growing project archive if you can make use of the stated capacity.
5 TB; 2.5-inch format; USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 1 according to the product description, which also gives a weight of 240 g.
View on Joybuy
Image unavailable
WD Elements Portable 4 TB USB-C
This portable HDD is an option if you want to use project files between Windows and Mac computers.
4 TB; USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 1; pre-formatted as exFAT and intended for Windows and macOS, according to the product description.
View on Joybuy
Image unavailable
WD Elements 2 TB Portable External Hard Drive, USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1
For a project archive with a stated capacity of 2 TB; the product description says it works with Windows and macOS.
2 TB; 2.5-inch format; USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 1; pre-formatted as exFAT according to the product description.
View on Joybuy
Image unavailable
WD Elements 8 TB Desktop External Hard Drive, USB 3.0
This HDD is better suited to a permanent archive setup than frequent use on the move.
8 TB; 3.5-inch desktop drive; USB 3.0; requires the supplied power adapter according to the product description. NTFS is listed as the pre-formatted file system; reformatting is specified for use with macOS.
View on Joybuy
Image unavailable
Samsung Portable Solid State Drive T7 2 TB, USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2, Titanium Grey
This portable SSD could be a good choice if you regularly carry project files or want to use the stated hardware encryption.
2 TB; USB 3.2 Gen 2; supplied with USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables according to the product description. Samsung software is required to set up password protection, according to the description.
View on Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
How do I work out how much capacity I need?
Add up your existing recordings and project versions, then estimate how many more files you plan to add. Allow space for a separate second copy, too; the project name alone doesn’t tell you how many TB you’ll need.
Can I use a Windows-formatted drive for Time Machine straight away?
Not as a correctly formatted Time Machine backup volume. Apple recommends APFS or APFS (Encrypted) and points out that reformatting erases existing data. Check what’s on the drive before setting it up.
How should I look after my archive once I’ve bought a drive?
Make a separate backup regularly and check that you can open or restore files from it. The BSI stresses that backed-up data must be restorable, too.
Is a manufacturer’s warranty the same as my statutory rights?
No. Under EU rules, consumers buying from a trader have a legal guarantee of at least two years from the date they receive the goods. Any additional manufacturer’s warranty is separate; check the terms for the specific model.