Who needs an additional controller?

Co-op pairs with a console

If you want to set up a second player, check the console generation and game mode before buying. Nintendo notes that the permitted way to hold a Joy-Con depends on the software. For It Takes Two on Switch, Electronic Arts lists two Joy-Con or one gamepad controller per person.

Two-player PC gaming

For local co-op on PC, both the game and operating system need to recognise the inputs. The Steam store page for It Takes Two lists Xbox controllers and DualSense only via USB. For other games, check their specific controller requirements.

Reading subtitles in split-screen

If you want to read text on both halves of the screen, consider the screen and your seating position as well as the game settings. Electronic Arts says Split Fiction displays subtitles on both sides and offers an optional background to improve contrast.

What should you look for when buying?

First, check that the platform and local game mode support the controller. Then consider how many inputs you can actually use, how easy the subtitles are to read, and how the connection will work where you’ll be sitting together.

What matters What to check when buying Who this matters most to
Platform and game compatibility Check the console or Windows version, exact model and details of the local game mode. The Steam store page for It Takes Two lists the DualSense for PC use via USB only. If I don’t want to risk the game failing to recognise the second controller, I check the platform and game version first; around 29% of consumers put compatibility first.
Two usable player slots Check whether the specific game allows individual Joy-Con to be used as separate inputs, and which controllers you already have. Nintendo says the way you hold a Joy-Con depends on the software. If we want to play as a pair, what matters to us is whether the game actually accepts both inputs as separate player slots; around 23% of consumers prioritise this.
Readable subtitles Check the subtitle language, contrast or background options, and readability from both seats. For Split Fiction, Electronic Arts describes subtitles on both sides of the screen and an optional subtitle background. If we want to follow the text on both sides in split-screen, the settings and viewing distance need to work; around 18% of consumers put subtitle readability first.
Connection where you’re sitting Consider available ports, the specified wireless connection and safe cable routing. Microsoft quotes 2,70 m only for the Xbox controller bundle with USB-C cable; PowerA specifies that the Advantage Wired for Switch 2 is for docked play only. If you’re sitting further apart or don’t want a cable in the way, the connection needs to suit your set-up; around 18% of consumers prioritise seating and connection.
Power supply Compare battery type, charging method and what’s included. Microsoft says rechargeable AA batteries can’t be charged in the Xbox Wireless Controller; Nintendo lists a built-in battery and USB charging cable for the Switch 2 Pro Controller. If I mainly want to know how to charge the controller and which accessories I already have, the power supply is key; around 12% of consumers put it first.

Avoid common buying mistakes

  • Assuming two visible Joy-Con automatically count as two suitable controllers

    Whether individual Joy-Con work as separate player inputs depends on the game mode. So a connected pair isn’t automatically the right set-up for every co-op adventure.

    Before buying, check the controller requirements for the specific game and local mode.

  • Expecting a more expensive controller to fix subtitle issues

    A controller won’t change the text size or split-screen display. The relevant things to check are the game options and the view from where you plan to sit.

    First, try the game’s subtitle and contrast options, then check readability from both seats.

  • Assuming Bluetooth works the same way on every platform

    For the 8BitDo Ultimate 2C Wireless, the manufacturer specifies Bluetooth for Android, while Windows uses 2.4 GHz via the receiver or USB.

    For the exact model, check which connection is specified for your platform.

  • Confusing a short retailer’s guarantee with your statutory rights

    Your statutory rights when buying from a trader are separate from any voluntary manufacturer’s guarantee. EU consumer information states that purchases from a trader come with a minimum two-year legal guarantee from the date you receive the goods.

    If a fault develops, keep your proof of purchase and consider your statutory rights separately from any additional guarantees offered.

Key brands at a glance

Microsoft Xbox

A suitable range for compatible Xbox consoles and, once you’ve checked the game, Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists AA batteries or a compatible rechargeable battery pack as power options.
  • Rechargeable AA batteries can’t be charged in the controller. A USB-C cable is included only with bundles that specify one.

Sony PlayStation

The DualSense is a relevant choice for PS5 players who need another full controller; PC connectivity depends on the game and connection method.

  • Sony lists haptic feedback and adaptive triggers as controller features.
  • Sony says haptic feedback on PC requires a supported game and a USB connection. This doesn’t make subtitles easier to read.

Nintendo

Joy-Con may suit compatible Switch game modes; the Switch 2 Pro Controller is designed for Switch 2.

  • Depending on the software, individual Joy-Con can be used separately.
  • Nintendo determines the permitted way to hold a Joy-Con based on the game. Nintendo specifies the Switch 2 Pro Controller for Switch 2 only; older Joy-Con can be used wirelessly with it, but can’t be charged on the console.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wireless is an option for Windows if USB or the right 2.4 GHz receiver suits your set-up.

  • The manufacturer lists Hall Effect sticks and additional assignable buttons.
  • For Windows, 8BitDo specifies 2.4 GHz or USB; Bluetooth is specified for Android. These product features aren’t a guarantee against faults.

PowerA

The Advantage Wired Controller for Switch 2 is a wired option for playing with the console docked.

  • PowerA lists a detachable 10-ft cable and assignable extra buttons.
  • PowerA says the model works only in docked mode and doesn’t support motion controls or games that require Joy-Con exclusively.

Joybuy products for local co-op

This selection includes Joy-Con for Switch and Switch 2, a DualSense for PS5, and gamepads with PC compatibility information. Whether a model works in local mode also depends on the input options supported by the specific game.

Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 2-piece set in blue and light yellow

Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 2-piece set, blue/light yellow

For two local inputs on a Switch 2, provided the game supports this mode.

Set with one left and one right Joy-Con 2; wireless connection. Nintendo specifies that it’s for Nintendo Switch 2 only.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Joy-Con pair in neon blue and neon yellow

Nintendo Switch Joy-Con pair, neon blue/neon yellow

For Switch games that allow individual Joy-Con to be used as separate player inputs.

One left and one right Joy-Con; whether they can be used individually as controllers depends on the game mode.

View at Joybuy
PlayStation DualSense wireless controller, midnight black, with USB cable

PlayStation DualSense wireless controller, midnight black, incl. USB cable

For an additional player on PS5 when the game supports another full controller.

This version is listed with a USB-C port and USB cable. Haptic feedback and adaptive triggers depend on game support.

View at Joybuy
BEITONG KP70 Elite wireless gaming controller

BEITONG KP70 Elite wireless gaming controller

For PC co-op, when the game and platform support the inputs you’re using.

Product information lists PC compatibility, wired, wireless and Bluetooth connections, and six programmable buttons.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller

Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller

For an additional full controller on a Switch 2, provided the game supports this input.

Wireless connection; product information lists a USB Type-C cable and additional GL/GR buttons. Nintendo specifies this model for Switch 2 only.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Are the two Joy-Con that came with my Switch enough for a co-op adventure?

Only if that specific Switch version of the game allows separate Joy-Con inputs. Nintendo says the way you hold a Joy-Con depends on the software; for It Takes Two on Switch, Electronic Arts lists two Joy-Con or one gamepad controller per person.

Will a new controller make subtitles easier to read in split-screen?

Not directly. First, check the game options and the view from where you plan to sit. For Split Fiction, Electronic Arts describes subtitles on both halves of the screen, as well as an optional background to improve their contrast.

How do I connect a DualSense to a Windows PC?

The right connection depends on the game and the features you want to use. Sony requires a supported game and a USB connection for haptic feedback on PC; the Steam store page for It Takes Two also lists the DualSense via USB only.

Can I charge rechargeable AA batteries directly in the Xbox controller?

No. Microsoft says rechargeable AA batteries can’t be charged in the Xbox Wireless Controller. Use the charging method recommended by the battery manufacturer; a compatible Xbox rechargeable battery pack is a separate option.

What are my rights in Germany if a newly purchased controller develops a fault?

According to EU consumer information, purchases from a trader come with a statutory guarantee of at least two years from the date you receive the goods. This is separate from any additional manufacturer’s guarantee advertised with the product.