Who needs to think carefully about their choice?

Console players sharing the sofa

You need an extra controller that works with your existing PS5, Xbox or Switch, and want to make it easy to tell everyone’s devices apart. PlayStation, Microsoft and Nintendo describe their controllers and player indicators as platform-specific.

PC football matches

You’re connecting several gamepads to Windows and want to check the connection type and whether the specific game recognises them. Microsoft, PlayStation and 8BitDo list different connection options and supported platforms depending on the model.

Playing in low light

You want to find your way around the gamepad in a dark room. Check whether a model actually lists illuminated zones or just a player indicator; PowerA and PlayStation describe different lighting features.

What to look for when buying

First check the platform and whether your football game supports the controller. Then consider the number of local players and how visible you want the controls to be. Cable length and power supply will affect where you can sit.

Consideration What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Platform and game Check the full model name against the list of supported platforms. On PC, also check whether the specific game recognises the controller. If I’m tied to a particular console or Windows PC, the controller needs to work with it. Around 36% of consumers put platform compatibility first.
Local players Check the player limit and controller support for your version of the game. Pair each controller separately before playing and assign it in the game. If another player is joining in, I want to know whether the game mode supports the kind of match we want to play. Around 29% of consumers prioritise a working local multiplayer set-up.
Finding your way in the dark Check which areas actually light up; don’t confuse player indicators with illuminated action buttons. In a dimly lit room, I want to be able to see the controls or player indicators more easily. Around 21% of consumers put controller visibility first.
Cable and power supply Consider how far you sit from the console and how the cable will be routed. For a wireless model, check its specified power supply. If I want to play comfortably from my seat, the cable or wireless power supply needs to suit my set-up. Around 14% of consumers prioritise power and seating distance.

Common misconceptions

  • A light bar doesn’t mean the action buttons light up

    A player indicator and explicitly listed RGB lighting zones are different features. A light bar doesn’t mean the buttons are illuminated.

    Check which areas are actually illuminated for the full model name, rather than relying on product images alone.

  • Controllers with similar names aren’t necessarily the same

    8BitDo lists different platforms for the Ultimate 2 Bluetooth and Ultimate 2 Wireless. The GameSir G7 Pro and G7 HE are also different models.

    Before buying, compare the full model name and platform details for the specific version.

  • The controller description doesn’t determine how many players a game supports

    Having an extra controller doesn’t prove that your version of the game or chosen mode supports the number of local players you want.

    Check the game’s local player limit and controller support before buying another gamepad.

Brands to consider

Sony PlayStation

The DualSense is designed for PS5. PlayStation also describes connections to compatible Windows PCs via USB or Bluetooth.

  • PlayStation documents a light bar and player indicator light on the DualSense.
  • According to PlayStation, haptic feedback on PC requires a compatible game and a USB connection. The lights don’t confirm that the action buttons are illuminated.

Microsoft Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is designed for Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth and button mapping options.
  • These features don’t confirm that the action buttons are illuminated. If you’re using it wirelessly, make sure you have a suitable power supply.

PowerA

The Advantage Wired with Lumectra is a wired option for supported Xbox consoles and Windows.

  • PowerA lists four RGB zones and a 10-ft USB-C cable.
  • This is a wired model. The listed lighting zones don’t mean that every button lights up.

Nintendo

The Switch 2 Pro Controller is designed for Switch 2 owners.

  • Nintendo lists a charging cable and an estimated battery life of around 40 hours.
  • According to Nintendo, the Switch 2 Pro Controller doesn’t work with the original Switch. However, an original Switch Pro Controller can be used wirelessly with the Switch 2.

8BitDo

According to the manufacturer, the Ultimate 2 Bluetooth is compatible with Windows and Switch. 8BitDo says it supports Switch 2 after a firmware update.

  • The Bluetooth version may be worth considering if you want to switch between supported platforms.
  • The Ultimate 2 Bluetooth and Ultimate 2 Wireless have different specifications. Platform details for one don’t automatically apply to the other.

GameSir

GameSir describes the G7 Pro as a customisable controller option for Xbox and PC.

  • The manufacturer lists TMR sticks and customisation options for this model.
  • This description from the manufacturer doesn’t prove that it performs better in football games; the G7 HE is a different model.

Joybuy product options

The Joybuy models below are listed in their product names for different PC and Nintendo platforms. In a dark room, explicitly listed RGB features are worth considering. For wired models, make sure the cable can reach comfortably from your seat.

EasySMX D10 PC controller with RGB backlighting

EasySMX D10 PC Controller

For PC players looking for wireless Bluetooth connectivity and RGB backlighting, as listed in the product name.

The product name also lists a TMR joystick, dual-mode triggers, mechanical buttons, a 1000 Hz polling rate and compatibility with PC, Switch, Android and iOS.

View at Joybuy
VIELLAN wireless gaming controller with Hall effect sticks and RGB lighting

VIELLAN Wireless Gaming Controller

For PC players considering a wireless controller with explicitly listed RGB lighting.

The product name lists Hall effect sticks, 255-level Hall triggers, programmable rear buttons, a 1000-mAh battery and USB-C. The button layout is described as a PS5 layout; this doesn’t mean it’s compatible with PS5.

View at Joybuy
NYXI Hyperion 3 wireless controller for Switch 2

NYXI Hyperion 3 Wireless Controller for Switch 2

For Switch 2 players looking for a wireless controller for this platform.

The product name lists a 9-axis gyroscope, Hall effect joysticks, mechanical buttons and two rear buttons.

View at Joybuy
BIGBIG WON Rainbow 2 Pro wired controller with RGB lighting

BIGBIG WON Rainbow 2 Pro Wired Controller

For players whose platform matches one of the options listed in the product name—PC, Nintendo Switch or PS4—and who want a wired connection.

The product name lists RGB lighting, a 6-axis gyroscope system and programmable features. Make sure the cable can reach comfortably from your seat.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller in black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller, Black

For players looking for an extra controller for a Nintendo Switch gaming session.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a controller with RGB lighting for a local football match?

No. First, make sure the controller is compatible with your platform and game, and that you have enough usable controllers. PowerA lists RGB zones on a specific wired model; the light bar documented by PlayStation isn’t the same as confirmed illuminated action buttons.

How do I set up a DualSense on a Windows PC?

PlayStation describes connections via USB or Bluetooth with supported versions of Windows. Once paired, check that the specific game recognises the controller. According to PlayStation, haptic feedback on PC requires a compatible game and a USB connection.

Can I keep using my existing Switch Pro Controller with the Switch 2?

Yes. Nintendo says the original Switch Pro Controller can be used wirelessly with a Switch 2. Conversely, according to Nintendo, the Switch 2 Pro Controller doesn’t work with the original Switch.

What should I check for power and accessories?

PowerA lists a 10-ft USB-C cable for the Advantage Wired. Nintendo lists a USB charging cable and an estimated battery life of around 40 hours for the Switch 2 Pro Controller. Consider the cable length and how far you sit from the console, and check what’s included with the version you choose.

Can I return a controller bought online in Germany?

Consumers generally have a right to cancel distance-selling contracts; section 312g of the German Civil Code (BGB) sets out exceptions. Section 355 BGB specifies a 14-day cancellation period. For goods, the Verbraucherzentrale explains that the period starts when you receive them; the specific circumstances of the contract still matter.