Who is this guide for?

Those caring for delicate local history books

If you are digitising bound or damaged volumes, the way each book is supported should suit its condition. The German Federal Archives also highlights planning and quality assurance as part of the work involved in digitisation projects.

Those cataloguing small historical publications

If you need readable page images and searchable files, assess the OCR output separately from how well the printed text can actually be recognised. A search function on its own says nothing about how accurately difficult passages will be recognised.

Those coordinating a shared scanning station

If several people are working with books in different formats, setup, file naming and post-scan checks all need to be part of the scanning workflow. The manufacturer of the IRIScan Desk 6 Pro describes an online installer and the camera permissions required for setup.

What should you look for?

Start with the condition of the volumes and how far they can be opened. Then consider the legibility of test scans, the size of the scanning area and a repeatable workflow for a shared scanning station.

Consideration What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Protecting the binding and pages Assess the opening angle and any damage to the volume; check whether it can be supported without pressure or needs a suitable book cradle. If I’m digitising delicate or damaged volumes, I want the support to suit their condition. Around 33% of consumers put protecting the binding first.
Readable images and searchable text Scan sample pages with small print, text in the gutter and illustrations; check the page image and searchable output separately. If I want to check place names, captions and small print later, I need a readable page image and useful text recognition. Around 27% of consumers put readability and text search first.
Format coverage Measure the largest page or open double-page spread you need to scan and compare it with the scanning area of the specific model. If I’m scanning volumes in different sizes, the open book needs to fit fully within the scanning area. Around 20% of consumers put format coverage first.
Shared workflow Check the installation process and permissions on the computer you plan to use; agree rules for file names, output and post-scan checks. If several people use the scanning station, I want setup and file storage to be clear to everyone. Around 20% of consumers put a repeatable shared workflow first.

Which mistakes should you avoid?

  • Assuming an overhead camera or narrow book edge will automatically be gentle on every old book

    The right way to handle a book depends on its condition and how far it can be opened. A narrow book edge alone does not prove that a delicate book can be scanned without damage.

    Before choosing a device, assess your most delicate volumes and establish how far they can be opened and how they can be supported.

  • Equating interpolated dpi or an OCR feature with archival quality

    VIISAN describes the S21’s resolution of up to 600 dpi as software-interpolated. An OCR feature also does not guarantee accurate recognition of small print or text in the gutter.

    Check sample images and text recognition against the smallest print and the most challenging parts of the book.

  • Treating the stated capture time as the time needed to archive a whole book

    The Plustek OpticBook 4800’s scan time refers to an A4 scan at 300 dpi. It does not cover the full workflow; the German Federal Archives also includes planning and quality assurance in the work involved in digitisation projects.

    Test the whole workflow with a representative volume rather than comparing only the time taken to capture an image.

  • Treating a private copy or library rule as blanket permission for the studio

    The conditions in sections 53 and 60e of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) differ. They do not provide blanket permission to share a collection accessible to a group or publish it online.

    Before scanning or sharing anything, check the rights, the type of institution and the intended use.

Relevant brands at a glance

CZUR

According to CZUR, the ET series is designed for overhead scanning of bound materials, with page correction.

  • CZUR says the series can correct curved pages.
  • Scanning and software features vary by model. The manufacturer’s specifications do not show how legible historical print will be in practice, so check the specific model and test scans.

Plustek

The OpticBook 4800 is a book-edge flatbed scanner for pages that can be laid flat.

  • Plustek specifies a 2 mm book edge and 600 dpi optical resolution for this model.
  • The stated scan time is for A4 at 300 dpi, not for digitising an entire book. A narrow book edge does not replace an assessment of the book’s condition.

VIISAN

According to the manufacturer, the S21 is an overhead scanner for materials up to the stated A2 format.

  • VIISAN lists a 20.1 MP sensor, curve correction and OCR for this model.
  • According to VIISAN, the resolution of up to 600 dpi is achieved through software interpolation; it is not an optically measured resolution.

IRIS

The IRIScan Desk 6 Pro is an overhead option for materials up to the stated A3 format.

  • IRIS lists a 13 MP camera and output formats such as searchable PDF.
  • IRIS describes an online installer and the camera permissions required. Check in advance that you can set up the model on the computer you plan to use in the studio.

Image Access

According to Image Access, the BookTEK 5 V2 Archive is designed for bound archive collections and features a self-adjusting book cradle.

  • Image Access describes V-shaped and flat operating modes, as well as glass plate options.
  • You cannot determine whether a device is suitable for a particular volume from its design alone; the book’s condition must also be considered.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

How do I set up a shared scanning station?

Before scanning, agree a workflow for checking the condition of each book, positioning it, naming files and checking pages. For the IRIScan Desk 6 Pro, IRIS describes an online installer and the camera permissions required; check these on the computer you will actually be using.

Is a searchable PDF enough as an archive file?

Not as the sole proof that pages are legible or have been recognised correctly. Check the page image and recognised text separately, especially in challenging sections; the manufacturer’s description ‘searchable PDF’ initially tells you only that the export function is available.

What additional costs should I allow for when digitising?

When planning, allow for staff time as well as the device itself, including setup, suitable book handling, file naming and quality control. The scan time for a single image does not reflect the full workflow.

Can the studio share scanned local history books or put them online?

Not simply because scanning is technically possible. Section 53 of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) allows, under certain conditions, an individual to make individual copies for private use, provided this is not directly or indirectly for commercial purposes. Section 60e of the German Copyright Act contains a specific rule for publicly accessible libraries that do not pursue direct or indirect commercial purposes. This does not establish whether those conditions apply to the studio; check the rights and intended use of the specific collection before sharing it.