Who are the different scanning options suitable for?

People caring for fragile collections

If you are digitising fragile volumes or ones that do not open easily, first check how far they can be opened and supported. The Federal Archives and Image Access both highlight preservation and the use of a book cradle as relevant considerations when handling delicate originals.

Cataloguing teams

If your team regularly digitises text-heavy local history books, searchable files and a repeatable workflow are important. CZUR, VIISAN and Plustek list features such as OCR and page correction for certain product ranges; check the specification of the particular model you are considering.

Teams sharing a desk

If several people use the same limited workspace, you will need room for the book and computer as well as the scanner, and space to operate it. IRIS describes the IRIScan Desk 7 Pro as having a short camera arm; the manufacturer also provides software installation instructions and information about camera permissions.

What should you look for when choosing?

For historic collections, the Federal Archives identifies preservation as the primary concern. For a shared workspace, you should also consider the largest book format you need to scan and the workflow for repeated scans.

Priority What to check before buying Who is most affected?
Protecting the binding and paper Assess the opening angle and condition of the volumes; compare book cradles, V-shaped supports and glass contact. When I care for fragile volumes, suitable support matters more to me than scanning speed. Consumers whose main concern is protecting the original are likely to account for around 33%.
Searchability and scanning workflow Check sample pages with small print, tight bindings and illustrations; review the image file, OCR text and page order. When we repeatedly digitise lots of text-heavy local history books, I need searchable files and a workflow the team can repeat. Consumers whose main priority is making text searchable account for around 27%.
Space and ease of use at a shared table Measure the space needed for the device, open book, cables and computer; check software access and permissions on the computers you plan to use. At a shared table, I need to fit the book and computer alongside the scanner, and make sure several people can use the workflow. Consumers for whom a shared workspace is the deciding factor account for around 20%.
Book and insert formats Measure the largest item you need to scan and check whether the stated format refers to a single page or the entire open spread. When I need to digitise large books or inserts, the size of the scanning area is crucial. Consumers whose main priority is large-format scanning are likely to account for around 20%.

Which mistakes should you avoid?

  • Assuming ‘contactless’ means ‘suitable for every historic book’

    Even with a camera, the book’s condition and the opening angle required determine how the original can be handled. Capturing an image without taking the book apart does not replace an assessment of the individual item.

    Assess representative volumes before buying and, for fragile copies, check whether a supported V-shaped cradle would be suitable.

  • Comparing interpolated dpi with optical detail resolution

    VIISAN describes the S21’s resolution of up to 600 dpi as software-interpolated. This figure should therefore not be treated as equivalent to an optically measured resolution.

    Compare sample scans of the same fine print and image details rather than relying on figures alone.

  • Confusing a searchable PDF with a verified digital copy

    Manufacturers list OCR and automatic page processing as features, but that does not guarantee error-free recognition of a particular historic item.

    Spot-check the original image, searchable text and page order. Checking the page order, image and OCR text takes additional team time.

  • Assuming permission to scan means permission to publish online

    Reproduction and making a work available to the public must be considered separately. The institutional provisions set out in §§ 60e and 60f UrhG apply only when their respective conditions are met.

    Before publishing, check the rights to the specific work, the institution’s status and the intended access arrangements. The Deutsche Digitale Bibliothek outlines additional legal requirements for out-of-commerce works.

Which brands and product ranges are worth considering?

Image Access

BookTEK 5 V2 Archive for supervised archive and library workflows, with a book cradle.

  • Image Access lists a self-adjusting book cradle, as well as V-shaped and flat operating modes.
  • This is a different class of device from a compact desktop camera. The suitability of a damaged individual item must be assessed before scanning.

CZUR

The ET series is a desktop overhead option for books that are scanned regularly and open sufficiently.

  • CZUR Deutschland lists A3, curve correction and OCR for the ET series.
  • Resolution, operating system and connections vary by model; features listed for a series do not guarantee a particular result.

VIISAN

The S21 is an overhead option when large books or inserts determine the format you need.

  • VIISAN lists an A2 capture area for the S21, along with page separation, dewarping and OCR.
  • According to VIISAN, the resolution of up to 600 dpi is software-interpolated and should not be taken as an optically measured resolution.

Plustek

The OpticBook 3800L is a book flatbed option for originals that open sufficiently.

  • Plustek Deutschland lists a scanning edge designed for book spines, as well as TWAIN/WIA and OCR software.
  • The glass plate and opening angle must suit the original in question; the book-edge design is not a blanket guarantee of gentle handling.

IRIS

The IRIScan Desk 7 Pro is a compact document camera and book-scanning option for desks with limited space.

  • IRIS describes a short camera arm and automatic page-turn detection.
  • Check software installation and camera permissions on the computers you plan to use; this does not indicate anything about the quality of the results.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can a club or archive scan entire protected local history books and put them online?

Not as a blanket rule. Under § 60e UrhG, publicly accessible libraries that do not pursue direct or indirect commercial purposes may make certain copies from their collections, subject to the statutory conditions; § 60f UrhG extends provisions to archives and other institutions under additional conditions. This does not automatically answer whether the material can be made publicly available online under § 19a UrhG. The purpose, the institution’s status and the rights to the specific work must all be checked. The Deutsche Digitale Bibliothek outlines additional requirements for out-of-commerce works. The relevant provisions can be found in the German Copyright Act on Gesetze im Internet.

Does the private copying exception allow me to scan an entire protected book at a club table?

No, it does not provide blanket permission. § 53(4) UrhG restricts the reproduction of a book in substantially complete form and sets out exceptions. Whether another permission applies depends on the specific work and how it will be used. The provision can be read in the German Copyright Act on Gesetze im Internet.

How do I set up several work computers for a desktop scanner?

Before buying, check that the software for the specific model supports the operating systems you plan to use. For the IRIScan Desk 7 series, IRIS describes installation on Windows or macOS and notes that camera permissions are required; these model-specific setup instructions do not automatically apply to all book scanners.

What ongoing costs or support tasks should the team allow for?

Allow time for condition checks, image review, OCR corrections, file naming and storage. If you use several work computers, you should also check software access and camera permissions for the specific model.