Map illustrators working on a desktop
You create maps with editable routes, shapes and labels on your existing computer, and are looking for a suitable pen input device.
If you mainly edit maps on your existing computer, working with paths, shapes and labels, a graphics tablet without a screen could be a good input option. For freehand details drawn directly on the image, consider a pen display connected to your computer. A standalone tablet may suit you if you want to draw without a computer and are happy to work with its apps and file formats. Before choosing, check software and file compatibility, desk space, connections and whether the pen is included.
You create maps with editable routes, shapes and labels on your existing computer, and are looking for a suitable pen input device.
You draw lots of map details freehand and want to see your lines directly on the image as you work. Connections and desk space will also affect your choice.
You want to draw without relying on your home-office computer, so you’ll need to consider the pen, apps and file sharing as part of one complete workflow.
A good fit if: You have a suitable computer and monitor, and mainly edit maps using paths, shapes or labels.
The trade-off: You draw on one surface while looking at a separate screen; you’ll still need a computer and drawing software.
A good fit if: You draw outlines or terrain by hand and want to see the line directly beneath the pen tip.
The trade-off: The display needs a connected computer and desk space. Video and power connections must be compatible with the specific model.
A good fit if: You want to sketch or carry on working while away from your home-office computer.
The trade-off: Its apps and file formats won’t necessarily match your desktop workflow. Check, too, whether the pen you want is included.
The priorities below are for consumers choosing a graphics tablet for map illustration in a home office.
| Buying priority | What to check | Who it matters most to |
|---|---|---|
| Software and file workflow | Check the required application and operating system, as well as how you can import, export and continue editing the file formats you use. | If I want to keep editing routes, shapes and labels in the desktop applications I’m used to, the file workflow needs to work. Around 33% of consumers say their desktop and file workflow is their top buying priority. |
| Drawing details directly | Decide whether a separate drawing surface will do, or whether you want the image to appear directly beneath the pen tip. | If I draw lots of outlines or terrain details freehand, I want to see the line directly on the image. Around 27% of consumers put direct control of these details first. |
| Space and included accessories | Compare the active drawing area with the device’s overall dimensions, and check what comes with the version you’re considering. | I want to fit the drawing area, monitor and keyboard comfortably on my desk, and know what I’ll need to use the device. Around 20% of consumers prioritise desk space and a complete set-up. |
| Drawing without a computer | Check whether the pen is included, and test transferring a sample file between the tablet app and your desktop workflow. | If I want to create map drafts without relying on my home-office computer, the pen, app and file sharing need to work together. Around 20% of consumers make drawing without a computer their top buying priority. |
According to the manufacturer’s manual, the XPPen Artist 15.6 Pro V2 connects to a computer. The Magic Drawing Pad, by contrast, is a standalone device.
First decide whether you want to draw on your existing computer or without one. Then check the connection requirements for the specific model.
The model code DTK-1660 identifies the Wacom Cintiq 16 reviewed. The Vergleich.org table doesn’t specify a particular generation for the Artist Pro 16.
Compare the full model code, included pen and connections rather than relying on the series name alone.
Path, text and GIS features depend on the software workflow you use; pen specifications don’t confirm that these features are available. Inkscape describes drawing and text tools, among other features, while the QGIS documentation covers vector data such as lines and points.
Try a representative map file to check that you can edit the elements you need, as well as import and export them.
Switching between a tablet app and a desktop project can mean extra work when transferring files.
Samsung says the Galaxy Tab S11 includes an S Pen. For the iPad Pro reviewed, Apple lists compatible Pencil models, but no Pencil in the stated box contents.
Check pen compatibility and the box contents for the exact version you’re choosing.
A Pencil isn’t included in the stated box contents for the iPad Pro reviewed. If you need one, budget for it as a separate accessory.
Worth considering for graphics tablets without a screen used with an existing computer, and for connected pen displays.
The range includes connected Artist pen displays and the standalone Magic Drawing Pad.
Kamvas pen displays are an option for drawing directly on a computer; the Kamvas Pro 24 (4K) range is designed for a permanent workstation.
Galaxy Tab S models are standalone tablets for illustrators who don’t want to stay connected to a computer.
The iPad Pro is worth considering as a standalone tablet if compatible iPad apps suit your illustration workflow.
A graphics tablet without a screen for working with paths, shapes and labels on your existing computer. The Medium version offers a larger working area than the Small.
A 15.4-inch pen display with shortcut keys for drawing details directly on screen. It connects to a computer, and may require an additional power supply.
A standalone tablet for sketching without a computer, with an S Pen included. Check that your preferred drawing app and file-sharing workflow meet your needs.
The manufacturer describes the One by Wacom as being used with a computer. A graphics tablet without a screen doesn’t replace the computer, monitor and drawing application.
Not necessarily: a USB-C port alone doesn’t guarantee the required video output or power supply. The XPPen Artist 15.6 Pro V2 manual describes connecting it to a computer and, in some cases, using an additional power supply. Check the requirements for the exact model against your laptop’s connections.
Check which replacement nibs are designed for your chosen model and whether they’re included; the XPPen Artist 15.6 Pro V2 manual lists eight nibs. In Germany, the Federal Environment Agency advises disposing of waste electrical equipment separately from household waste.
For qualifying online purchases from a business seller in the EU, you generally have a 14-day right to cancel from the date you receive the goods; exceptions and possible return costs apply. You also have statutory rights if goods are faulty. The European Commission gives a minimum period of two years from receipt; this is separate from any voluntary manufacturer’s warranty.
If you use OpenStreetMap data in a work that you publish or distribute, the OpenStreetMap Foundation requires attribution; the exact requirements depend on the work and how it is presented. Check the relevant licence for other map data.